Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, Volume. 62, Issue 3, 0330001(2025)

Comparison of Detection Performance of Five Portable Raman Spectrometers

Zhixin Luo1、*, Leiping Zhang2, Gaojun Shi2, Zhe Lian2, Shiyuan Zhu2, Liang Lu2, Lijing Zhong2, and Haotian Liu2
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Forensic Medicine,Shanxi Medical University,Taiyuan 030001,Shanxi ,China
  • 2National Engineering Laboratory for Forensic Science & Institute of Forensic Science, Ministry of Public Security, Beijing 100038, China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(14)
    Schematic of Raman spectrometer structure
    Detection spectra of naphthalene for each product
    FWHM of Raman peaks near 389, 1020, and 1576 cm-1 for each product
    Displacement accuracy statistics
    Repeatability experiment of naphthalene (taking product B as an example)
    Detection result. (a) Maximum displacement difference statistics; (b) δC⋅V statistics
    Intensity repeatability statistics
    RSN statistics
    Database capacity and ratio of sample size to time
    Capacity statistics of different instruments under various parameters
    • Table 1. Name and specifications of the instrument to be tested

      View table

      Table 1. Name and specifications of the instrument to be tested

      Instrument manufacturer*Instrument modelType of instrumentSpectral range /cm-1Wavenumber interval /cm-1DetectorSampling method
      Jiangsu Nephrite Scientific Instrument Co., Ltd.ZPR-1009PRS200‒31501CCDDirect sampling head
      Leading Norm Biotechnology (Beijing) Co., Ltd.LDN-R100PRS150‒35001.97CCDFiber sampling head
      Nanjing Simple & Smart Instrument Equipment Co., Ltd.SSR-3010PRS191‒28672.25CCDFiber sampling head
      Polaris Scientific Instruments (Suzhou) Co., Ltd.Polaris-R80PRS81‒66261.67398CCDFiber sampling head
      Renishaw PLCinVia-ReflexBRS5‒300001.10937CCDDirect sampling head
      Xiamen Persertech Technology Co., Ltd.PERS-F1810PRS301‒32041.68CCDFiber sampling head
    • Table 2. Measurement parameters for each spectrometer

      View table

      Table 2. Measurement parameters for each spectrometer

      Excitation wavelength /nmLaser power /mWIntegration time /msNumber of scansWarm-up time /minAmbient temperature /℃
      785350100021020‒25
    • Table 3. SERS characteristic peak and attribution

      View table

      Table 3. SERS characteristic peak and attribution

      SubstanceStructural formulaRaman shift /cm‒1Affiliation
      Naphthaline[8]513.8mC—C—C bending vibration
      763.8mBending vibration of the benzene ring
      1021.6wC—C telescopic vibration and deformation vibration
      1382.2sBenzene ring symmetrical vibration
      1576.6wRespiratory vibration of benzene ring
    • Table 4. Summary of output time

      View table

      Table 4. Summary of output time

      ItemABCDE
      Number of samples screened1415141313
      Average detection time /s12.3939.043.2023.1325.48
      Relative standard deviation /%0.421.520.100.250.30
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Zhixin Luo, Leiping Zhang, Gaojun Shi, Zhe Lian, Shiyuan Zhu, Liang Lu, Lijing Zhong, Haotian Liu. Comparison of Detection Performance of Five Portable Raman Spectrometers[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2025, 62(3): 0330001

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Spectroscopy

    Received: May. 8, 2024

    Accepted: May. 31, 2024

    Published Online: Feb. 18, 2025

    The Author Email:

    DOI:10.3788/LOP241234

    CSTR:32186.14.LOP241234

    Topics