Chinese Journal of Lasers, Volume. 51, Issue 10, 1002304(2024)

Research and Application Progress in Laser Additive Manufacturing of Heterogeneous Metals (Invited)

Yi Ma1 and Yingchun Guan1,2、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Mechanical Engineering and Automation, Beihang University, Beijing 100083, China
  • 2National Engineering Laboratory of Additive Manufacturing for Large Metallic Components, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(22)
    Aerospace applications of Cu/Ni heterogeneous metal systems. (a) GRCop-42(Cu-Cr-Nb)/HR-1(Fe-Ni-Cr) combustion chamber formed by LDED[39]; (b) Cu-based/Ni-based injector formed by LPBF[39]; (c) coupled thrust assembly formed by LDED[39]; (d) injector structure and heterogeneous alloy connecting interface[39]; (e) GRCop-42 combustion chamber formed by LPBF[40]; (f) nickel-based cooling nozzle formed by BP-DED[40]; (g) coupled bimetallic structure[40]; (h) C18150/Inconel 625 rocket nozzle formed by SLM+LDED[41]; (i) CuNi2SiCr/Inconel 625 rocket nozzle formed by LDED[41]; (j) Cu-based/Ni-based bimetallic heat exchanger formed by SLM[41]; (k) Cu-based/Ni-based bimetallic combustion chamber formed by SLM[42]
    Aerospace applications of Fe-based heterogeneous metal systems. (a) CW106C/1.2709 steel large caliber engine nozzle formed byLPBF[43]; (b) 316L/aluminum-based bronze rocket engine nozzle formed byLDED[44]; (c) IN718/SS316L heat exchanger formed bySLM[45]; (d) CuCrZr/316L heat exchanger formed bySLM[46]
    Aerospace applications of Ti-based heterogeneous metal systems. (a) Ti6Al4V/Nb coupled rocket nozzle component formed by LDED[47]; (b) Ti6Al4V/Ti48Al2Cr2Nb turbine blade disk formed by LDED[48]
    LDED equipment for heterogeneous metal additive manufacturing. (a) Schematic of the working principle of LDED for heterogeneous metal additive manufacturing[56]; (b) dual hopper LDED system[57]; (c) LASERTEC 6600 additive-subtractive composite manufacturing equipment[58]; (d) schematic of LMD static powder mixer equipment[59]
    LPBF equipment for heterogeneous metal additive manufacturing. (a) Dual feeder LPBF equipment[60]; (b) zoning system for LPBF equipment[61]; (c) ultrasonic powder spreading device for LPBF[62]; (d) electrostatic powder spreading device for LPBF[44]; (e) blade-ultrasonic powder spreading equipment for LPBF[63]
    Hybrid manufacturing cases. (a)(b)Schematic diagram of LMD-WAAM hybrid fabrication of IN625/SUS304L gradient material and macroscopic photographs of formed component[68]; (c) 17-4 PH/AISI 316L componentformed by LPBF-WAAM[69]; (d) LPBF-LDED equipment, and QCr0.8 copper alloy/S06 stainless steel heterometal connection through the intermediate layer In718[70]
    Factors affecting the quality of heterogeneous metal interfaces and solutions. (a1)(a2) Porosity/lack of fusion[74] and related solutions; (b1)(b2) cracks[75] and related solutions; (c1)(c2) harmful phases[38] and related solutions; (d1)(d2) residual stresses[76] and related solutions
    Heterogeneous metal joining strategies and cases. (a) Schematic diagrams of the four types of joining strategies[77]; (b) LPBF direct joining of Cu10Sn/Ti6Al4V and its interface[19]; (c) finger-crossed 316L/CuSn10 interfacial structure and samples formed by SLM[81]; (d) bionic SS316L/IN625 interface structure formed by LDED[82]; (e) Ti6Al4V/SS316 stainless steel heterometal connection through the intermediate layer Cu10Sn using SLM[79]; (f) inconel 718/Ti64 heterometal connection through VC-Inconel 718-Ti64 combination bonding layer using LENS[80]; (g) martensitic stainless steel/austenitic stainless steel connection through gradient layer using LENS[78]
    Influence of process parameters on the microstructure and properties of heterogeneous metal components. (a) Variation of the relative density of LMD-formed GH4169/K417G heterogeneous metal components with laser power[76]; (b) LMD parameter optimization strategy and IN625/304L heterogeneous metal components prepared under the optimal parameters[90]; (c) Ti6Al4V/AlSi10Mg heterogeneous metal interfaces formed by LPBF under different process parameters[30]; (d) NiTi/CuSn10 heterogeneous metal interfaces formed by SLM under different process parameters[12]
    Development and application of online monitoring technology for LAM preparation of heterogeneous metals. (a)(b) Schematic diagram of the integrated high-speed imaging device of the LMD equipment and high-speed imaging pictures of the Cu deposition process[99]; (c) LDED system with integrated monitoring and sensing device[100]; (d)(e) schematic diagram of the in-situ X-ray imaging device integrated into the LPBF system and the photos of the Inconel 718/316L forming process captured under different processing parameters[101]; (f) schematic diagram of integrated optical device for LDED systems[102]
    Development and application of simulation technique for LAM preparation of heterogeneous metals. (a) LDED modeling adaptive mesh and boundary conditions for thermal analysis[103]; (b) machine learning flowchart for SLM parameter optimization[104]; (c) simulation of powder bed temperature distribution with different gradient IN718 components during LPBF manufacturing of IN718/Ti6Al4V[105]; (d) simulation of deformation and stress distribution in LDED manufacturing of Cu/SS304L[83]
    Effect of pretreatment on microstructure and properties of heterogeneous metal components. (a)‒(c) Preheating process of LDED in the manufacture of Inconel 625/Ti6Al4V gradient materials and the comparison of the effect of forming samples with or without preheating[110]; (d)(e) comparison of microstructures of CuBe/H13 formed by LMD with or without preheating[111]; (f)‒(h) hardness, relative density, and microstructure of GH4169/K417G samples formed by LMD with or without preheating[76]
    Effect of post-treatment on microstructure and properties of heterogeneous metal components. (a)(b) The effect of heat treatment on the microstructure and mechanical properties of LPBF-formed 316L/Inconel 718 components[112]; (c) the effect of heat treatment on the hardness of LPBF-formed maraging steel/Co-Cr-Mo alloy components[113]; (d) the effect of hot isostatic pressing on the microstructure and hardness of LPBF-formed Ti/Ti64 components[114]
    • Table 1. Typical heterogeneous metal systems and their properties and applications

      View table

      Table 1. Typical heterogeneous metal systems and their properties and applications

      Material systemMaterial propertyApplicationTypical heterogeneous metal system
      Cu/Ni

      Thermal conductivity/heat resistance/

      high strength

      Aerospace thrust components/integrated circuit

      Inconel 718/GRCop8411

      NiTi/CuSn1012

      Inconel 718/ CuCr0.813

      Cu/FeHigh stiffness/electrical conductivity/thermal conductivity/wear resistanceNuclear industry/power generation industry/automobile industry

      316L/CuSn1014

      316L/C5240015

      316L/CuCrZr16

      Cu/TiHeat resistance/high specific strengthAerospace heat exchanger

      Ti6Al4V/Cu17

      Ti6Al4V/CuNi2SiCr18

      Cu10Sn/Ti6Al4V19

      Cu/AlElectrical/thermal conductivity/low densityEnergy conduction/cooling device/solar collectorAlSi10Mg/C1840020
      Ni/FeHigh strength/corrosion resistance/oxidation resistanceGas turbine/power generation equipment/heat exchanger

      316 L/Inconel 71821

      316L/Inconel 62522

      SS420/Inconel 71823

      Ni/TiBiocompatibility/wear resistance/high specific strength/heat resistanceAerospace thermal protection system/orthopedic implants

      Inconel 718/Ti6Al4V24

      TC4/Inconel 62525

      NiTi/Ti6Al4V26

      Fe/TiHigh specific strength/corrosion resistanceAerospace engines/load-bearing componentsTi6Al4V/316L27
      Fe/AlHigh strength/corrosion resistance/lightweightAutomotive manufacturing/aerospace hydraulic systems/space launch systems

      316L/AlSi10Mg28

      316L/Al29

      Ti/AlLightweight/ductility and malleability/high strengthAerospace and automotive structural component

      Ti6Al4V/AlSi10Mg30

      AA2024/Ti6Al4V31

      Ti6Al4V/Al12Si32

      Co/TiBiocompatibility/high strengthMedical implantCoCrMo/Ti6Al4V33
      Co/NiCorrosion resistance/high strengthNuclear industry/petrochemical industry

      CoCrMo/Inconel 71834

      CoCrMo/Inconel 62535

      Co/FeHeat resistance/wear resistance/high toughnessMachining tools and mold manufacturingSS316L/CoCrMo36
      W/CuElectrical/thermal conductivity/resistance to plasma radiationIntegrated circuit radiator/electrode/nuclear industryCu10Sn/W37
      W/FeDuctility and malleability/resistance to plasma radiation/high strengthNuclear industryW/316L38
    • Table 2. Advantages, limitations, and solutions of traditional LPBF and LDED techniques in heterogeneous metal manufacturing

      View table

      Table 2. Advantages, limitations, and solutions of traditional LPBF and LDED techniques in heterogeneous metal manufacturing

      TechniqueAdvantageLimitationSolution
      LPBF

      1) High forming accuracy

      2) Higher quality of interface bonding

      1) Lower processing efficiency50

      2) Difficult to control the precise distribution of powder51

      3) Cross-contamination issue with powders52

      4) Intra-layer heterogeneous material composition connectivity is limited53

      1) Hybrid manufacturing

      2) Development of new powder spreading device

      3) Developing multi-beam and large-area equipment

      4) Upgrade of powder recycling unit

      LDED

      1) High degree of processing freedom

      2) Wide selection of raw materials

      3) High processing efficiency

      4) Good flexibility in powder feeding

      1) Lower forming accuracy54

      2) Intra-layer heterogeneous material composition connectivity is limited55

      1) Integration of additive and subtractive manufacturing processes

      2) Hybrid manufacturing

      3) Improvement of powder feeding and mixing device

    • Table 3. Development and advantages of heterogeneous metal additive manufacturing equipment for LPBF and LDED

      View table

      Table 3. Development and advantages of heterogeneous metal additive manufacturing equipment for LPBF and LDED

      Equipment Optimization StrategyTechniqueMaterialAdvantage/effectReference
      Blade-based dual powder recoaterLPBFNi/TiCracks and brittle phases exist at the interfacial joints; such technique is difficult to realize the deposition of heterogeneous materials in the same layer and are limited in the applicable material systems, with poor forming quality60
      Ultrasonic assisted powder spreadingLPBFW/316LHeterogeneous metals are well bonded; such technique has high powder layup accuracy and design freedom, but is very inefficient65
      Electrostatic powder spreadingLPBFSuch technique has a high degree of design freedom and powder feeding efficiency, but is prone to powder layer contamination problems63
      Blade + ultrasonic hybrid powder spreadingLPBF316L/Cu10SnGood metallurgical bonding of heterogeneous metals; such technique combines high precision and efficiency66
      Dual powder feederLDEDAISI 316L/ AISI H13Individual transportation of dissimilar powders and successful bonding of heterogeneous metals are realized57
      Static mixing deviceLDED316L/CuImproved powder mixing homogeneity for the preparation of functional gradient layers59
      Integration of additive and subtractive manufacturingLDEDImproved efficiency and precision of heterogeneous metal forming58
      Equipment improvementLPBF

      AISI 316L/

      Ni-based high-temperature alloy

      Preparation of intra-layer bimetallic samples realized61
      LPBFAISI 316L-18Ni (300)Preparation of intra-layer bimetallic samples realized67
    • Table 4. Hybrid manufacturing processes for heterogeneous metals and their advantages

      View table

      Table 4. Hybrid manufacturing processes for heterogeneous metals and their advantages

      Technology integration strategyMaterialAdvantage/effectReference
      LMD-WAAMSUS304L/IN625Combines the high efficiency of WAAM with the flexibility of LMD/Good metallurgical bonding of heterogeneous materials with high mechanical properties68
      LPBF-WAAM17-4 PH/ AISI 316LHybrid manufacturing facilitates the preparation of complex and large cross-section structures/Heterogeneous interfaces are well bonded and have high mechanical properties69
      LPBF-LDEDQCr0.8/In718/S06 stainless steelCombines the high precision of LPBF with the flexibility of LDED/Heterogeneous interfaces are well bonded and defect-free70
      WAAM-LDEDER70S6/Inconel 625Combines the high efficiency of WAAM with the flexibility of LDED/Heterogeneous interfaces are well bonded and have high mechanical properties71
      LPBF-LDEDSS316L/IN625Integration of LPBF for high forming accuracy and LDED for fast deposition/Good heterogeneous interface bonding72
      SLM-CS(cold spraying)Al/Ti6Al4VCS avoids defects associated with the melting process, SLM offers high forming accuracy/Better bonding at heterogeneous interfaces, and inhibits the generation of brittle phases73
    • Table 5. Joining strategies and forming effects of heterogeneous metals

      View table

      Table 5. Joining strategies and forming effects of heterogeneous metals

      Connection strategyMaterialTechniqueEffectReference
      Direct connectionCu10Sn/Ti6Al4VLPBFInterface delamination, bonding failure19
      Cu/SS 304LLDEDHigh residual stresses at the interface, poor bonding effect83
      Gradient layer connection

      Martensitic stainless steel/

      Austenitic stainless steel

      LENSGood metallurgical bonding, improved mechanical properties78
      316L/IN718LPBFGood metallurgical bonding, good mechanical properties84
      AISI 316L/Fe35MnLPBFGood metallurgical bonding, mechanical properties vary with composition gradation85
      316L/Inconel 625LDEDGood metallurgical bonding, uniform microstructure at the interface22
      Ti6Al4V/NiTiLDEDDefect-free interface structure and good mechanical properties86
      Intermediate layer connection

      316L/HOVADUR K220/

      Ti-6Al-4V

      SLMGood metallurgical bonding79
      Cu10Sn/316L/WLPBFGood metallurgical bonding37
      TC4/Cu/IN718LDEDInhibits the creation of defects, good interfacial bonding87
      IN625/Cu/TC4LDEDGood metallurgical bonding88
      Ti6Al4V/Cu/Al-Cu-MgLPBFGood metallurgical bonding, no visible defects89
      Compositional bond layer connection

      Inconel 718/VC mixture/

      Ti6Al4V

      LENSNo cracks in the interface, successful bonding80
      Interface shape design316L/CuSn10SLMGood metallurgical bonding, improved mechanical properties81
      316L/IN625LDEDGood bonding, improved mechanical properties82
    • Table 6. Optimization/processing parameters for classical heterogeneous material

      View table

      Table 6. Optimization/processing parameters for classical heterogeneous material

      MaterialTechnique

      Laser

      power /W

      Scanning speed /(mm/s)Scanning space / overlap rate

      Layer

      thickness /μm

      Powder

      feeding rate

      Reference
      Ti6Al4V/ AlSi10MgLPBF31022000.123030
      Ti6Al4V/Inconel 625LMD150060050%6.0 g/min91
      Ti6Al4V/Ti48Al2Cr2NbLMD190074.96 g/min92
      Ti6Al4V/NiTiSLM906000.093026
      Ti6Al4V/IN718SLM3007000.055093
      316L/Co-Cr-MoLENS8006.676.0 g/min36
      316L/IN718LPBF955000.0842584
      316L/Hastelloy XLPBF952000.0453094
      316L/IN718LDED1000750%1 r/min95
      316L/TC4LMD1400650%2.5 r/min96
      Inconel 718/316LLPBF3009000.083097
      Inconel 718/CoCrMoLPBF22570034
      Inconel 718/SS420LDED9001523
      Inconel 625/316LLENS335183.8 g/min98
      Inconel 625/304LLMD6001050%8 g/min90
      GH4169/K417GLMD528440%18.9 mm3/s76
      NiTi/CuSn10SLM1202500.083012
    • Table 7. Monitoring techniques for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      View table

      Table 7. Monitoring techniques for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      Monitor signalMaterialTechniqueMonitoring deviceAdvantage/effectReference
      Optical signalCu, Al, Steel/Ti alloyLMDHigh-speed camera (optical imaging)Real-time monitoring of the melt pool dynamics, powder status and solidification characteristics, which can be adjusted accordingly99
      Ti/NbLDEDSpectrum collection deviceHigh precision monitoring of chemical composition/process status/serious defects100
      Inconel 718/316LLPBFHigh-speed X-ray imaging deviceIt can realize real-time monitoring of microstructure and defect evolution as well as thermal behavior of molten pool, and can adjust the process accordingly101
      316 L/AlSi10MgLMDCollimating lens + optical fiber (spectral collection)The relationship of spectral intensity-gradient composition evolution can be established to realize composition control in manufacturing process102
      Acoustic signalTi/NbLDEDMicrophonesFor laser-material interaction monitoring with high acquisition rates but poor monitoring accuracy100
    • Table 8. Simulation and modeling techniques for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      View table

      Table 8. Simulation and modeling techniques for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      Forecast contentMaterialTechniqueModel/methodAdvantage/effectReference
      Thermal behavior + residual stressIN718/Ti6Al4VLDEDSequential coupled thermo-mechanical modelThe predicted results are qualitatively in agreement with the experimental results / thermal response, solidification behavior and residual stress sources can be predicted103
      Cu/SS304LLDEDThermo-mechanical Finite Element ModelingAccurate prediction of temperature and residual stress distribution can be achieved83
      IN718/Cu10SnLPBFMesoscopic modeling based on the VOF methodThe behavior of molten pool and solidification trajectory can be predicted105
      316L/Inconel 718LDEDFinite element simulationHigh simulation accuracy for effective analysis of thermal behavior during the forming process106
      TC4/TC11LMDFinite element simulationThe temperature field trend, period and peak temperature calculated by the model are in good agreement with the experiment, which verifies the validity of the model107
      Process parametersAlSi10Mg/316LSLMGaussian process regression (MO-GPR) modelingProcess parameter optimization can be significantly shortened104
      Fe/NiLDEDMathematical models constructed based on MATLABCorrelating laser process parameters to composition states108
      316L/CuSLMMultivariate Gaussian process modelCan be used for parameter prediction under different gradient composition changes109
    • Table 9. Pre- and post-treatments for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      View table

      Table 9. Pre- and post-treatments for laser additive manufacturing of heterogeneous metals

      Processing methodMaterialTechniqueEffectReference
      Substrate preheatingInconel 625/Ti6Al4VLDEDOptimized microstructure and improved forming quality110
      CuBe/H13LMDInhibit the formation of defects and improve mechanical properties111
      GH4169/K417GLMDReduced residual stresses and increased relative density of samples76
      Heat treatment316L/Inconel 718LPBFModulation of microstructure distribution to improve mechanical properties112
      Maraging steel/Co-Cr-MoLPBFElimination of residual stresses, improvement of interface quality and toughness113
      In718/316LLDEDThe strength and toughness of the components are improved115
      Hot isostatic pressureTi/Ti64LPBFElimination of residual stresses and improvement of mechanical properties114
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Yi Ma, Yingchun Guan. Research and Application Progress in Laser Additive Manufacturing of Heterogeneous Metals (Invited)[J]. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 2024, 51(10): 1002304

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Laser Additive Manufacturing

    Received: Jan. 2, 2024

    Accepted: Feb. 19, 2024

    Published Online: Apr. 18, 2024

    The Author Email: Yingchun Guan (guanyingchun@buaa.edu.cn)

    DOI:10.3788/CJL240428

    CSTR:32183.14.CJL240428

    Topics