Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, Volume. 61, Issue 22, 2200003(2024)

Review and Prospect of Underwater 3D Imaging Detection

Yuhang Wang1, Xinyu Wang2, Jinghui Zhang1, Lujie Bu1, and Tao Zhang1、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Electromechanical Engineering, Northeast Forestry University, Harbin 150040, Heilongjiang , China
  • 2School of Computing and Control, Northeast Forestry University, Harbin 150040, Heilongjiang , China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(17)
    Composition and principle of distance gating system. (a) The principle of backscattering[21]; (b) detection system composition[22]; (c) distance gate system equipment composition
    Range strobe equipment and imaging results. (a) Range gate device diagram; (b) depth map of the target image obtained using the range-gated device
    The principle diagram of photon counting lidar. (a) Gen-1 photon counting lidar schematic diagram[34]; (b) SPAD detection process diagram[35]; (c) underwater photon counting lidar system[9]
    Single photon device and imaging results[33]. (a) Single photon emitter; (b) single photon cumulative imaging depth map
    Schematic diagram of linear structured light imaging system. (a) Principle of linear structured light scanning; (b) flow chart of structured light imaging; (c) coordinates used in structured light imaging
    Structure light experimental device and imaging results[50]. (a) Diagram of line structured light equipment; (b) scan point cloud image
    Imaging principle of streak tube lidar. (a) Diagram of the fringe tube[62]; (b) structure diagram of stripe-tube laser imaging radar[63]; (c) fringe tube signal schematic diagram[64]
    Airborne stripe tube equipment and imaging results[62]. (a) Airborne stripe tube scanner; (b) three-dimensional reconstruction model of the striated tube
    Three-dimensional reconstruction principle of binocular camera[75]. (a) 3D reconstruction process of binocular camera; (b) underwater binocular stereo vision model; (c) underwater binocular principle
    Binocular camera and its imaging results[76]. (a) Binocular camera equipment diagram; (b) binocular camera imaging point cloud image
    Accuracy comparison chart of multiple underwater three-dimensional imaging methods
    • Table 1. comparison of parameters of underwater distance gating system at home and abroad

      View table

      Table 1. comparison of parameters of underwater distance gating system at home and abroad

      YearReferenceWave length /nmPulse width /nsFrequency /kHzSingle pulse energyDetection range /ALLaser type
      20062453265000 mJ6.7
      200825532151500 μJ4.0LD
      20132653210100 mJ8.0Nd∶YAG
      201627532815 mJ7.4
      201815532212 mJ4.5Nd∶YVO4
      2019285326.0Nd∶YAG
      2023295322.5207.0Nd∶YVO4
    • Table 2. Single photon detection technology experiments at home and abroad

      View table

      Table 2. Single photon detection technology experiments at home and abroad

      YearExperimental typeLaser wavelength /nmDistanceRange resolution /cmProbe pixel scaleImaging speed /(frame/s)Image resolution
      2011Underwater signal detection3653220 m15.0
      2019Underwater signal detection3767024 m1.8192×12810001024×1024
      2021linear array imaging386708.3 AL<116×18×1
      2022Underwater 3D imaging395002 m4.732×3210000384×384
      2023Above water 3D imaging40103055 m33.0
      2023Array imaging415327.5 AL4.6192×128100065×123
    • Table 3. Experimental results of structured light at home and abroad

      View table

      Table 3. Experimental results of structured light at home and abroad

      YearImaging methodExperimental methodMaximum imaging distance /mRelative error /%Absolute error /mm
      2010Line structure photogalvanometer53Scanning with galvanometer11.140.31
      2012Surface structure light imaging[54]Surface structured light is used2.51.250.25
      2012Linear structured light scanning[55]Linear structured light translational imaging2.405.00
      2016Structured light rotation imaging[56]Linear structured light imaging0.72.501.10
      2022translational 3D imaging[57]Translation drive is adopted2.01.910.50
      2023Structured light rotation imaging[10]Refraction correction algorithm0.81.510.20
      2023Linear structured light imaging[58]Use three and single wire combination<10.03
      2023Structured light scanner[50]Stereo vision combined with structured light2.2<10.53
    • Table 4. Streak tube experiments at home and abroad

      View table

      Table 4. Streak tube experiments at home and abroad

      YearExperimental modeLaser wavelength /nmMaximum pulse energy /mJRange resolutionDetection range /m
      2000Underwater striated tube depth information detection666005 cm
      2002Airborne stripe-tube ocean exploration675321002.5%6.1
      2018Underwater striated tube 3D imaging68532181 cm22.0
      2020Underwater striped tube experiment69532205 cm17.5
    • Table 5. Underwater multi-visual 3D experimental data

      View table

      Table 5. Underwater multi-visual 3D experimental data

      YearExperimental typeDistance /mAbsolute error /mmRelative error /%
      2020Binocular structured light underwater measurement 770.60.452.25
      2022Underwater monocular 3D reconstruction780.32.303.74
      2022Underwater binocular 3D reconstruction 793.02.401.25
      2022Underwater binocular color 3D reconstruction 763.02.601.12
      2023Underwater binocular 3D reconstruction 741.03.371.33
    • Table 6. Summary of underwater three-dimensional imaging technology

      View table

      Table 6. Summary of underwater three-dimensional imaging technology

      Imaging modeImaging distanceImaging target sizeAccuracyUsage scenario
      Range gatingfarlargelow (high SNR)from air to water
      Single photon imagingfarlargelowfrom air to water
      Structured light scanningnearlesserhighwater
      Streak tubefarlargelowfrom air to water
      Binocular cameranearbothhighshallow water
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Yuhang Wang, Xinyu Wang, Jinghui Zhang, Lujie Bu, Tao Zhang. Review and Prospect of Underwater 3D Imaging Detection[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2024, 61(22): 2200003

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Reviews

    Received: Feb. 1, 2024

    Accepted: Mar. 18, 2024

    Published Online: Nov. 13, 2024

    The Author Email: Tao Zhang (sxh_00664@163.com)

    DOI:10.3788/LOP240654

    CSTR:32186.14.LOP240654

    Topics