Infrared and Laser Engineering, Volume. 51, Issue 10, 20211119(2022)

Design method of freeform surface for off-axis reflective head-mounted display optical system

Congshan Rui1,2, Chunmei Zeng1,2, Zhiqiang Feng1,2, Chengliang Xia1,2, and Yang Hong1,2
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Optoelectronic Science and Engineering, Soochow University, Suzhou 215006, China
  • 2Key Lab of Advanced Optical Manufacturing Technologies of Jiangsu Province & Key Lab of Modern Optical Technologies of Education Ministry of China, Suzhou 215006, China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(20)
    Diagram of three-dimensional direct design method based on Marius's law
    Flow chart of three-dimensional direct design method based on Marius's law
    (a) Define the data points on pupil; (b) Define the feature rays and the starting points of feature rays
    (a) Layout of freeform surface single-mirror optical system in YOZ plane; (b) Diagram of freeform surface construction in full FOV
    Layout of freeform surface two-mirror optical system in YOZ plane
    (a) Sag map of freeform surface fitted; (b) Layout of the optical system; (c) MTF curves of the optical system
    (a) Layout of the single-mirror HMD optical system after optimi-zation; (b) Grid distortion; (c) MTF curves of the optical system
    [in Chinese]
    Layouts of freeform surface two-mirror HMD system. (a) Both F1 and F2 are spheres; (b) F1 is a freeform surface; (c) Both F1 and F2 are freeform surfaces
    Comparison of the average RMS spot diameter between three optical systems
    (a) Layout of the two-mirror HMD optical system after optimi-zation; (b) Grid distortion; (c) MTF curves of optical system
    Surface sag and slope diagram of freeform surface single-mirror HMD system. (a) Surface sag diagram of M1; (b) Surface slope diagram of M1
    Surface sag and slope of diagram of freeform surface two-mirror HMD system. (a) Surface sag diagram of F1; (b) Surface sag diagram of F2; (c) Surface slope diagram of F1; (d) Surface slope diagram of F2
    • Table 1. Specifications of freeform surface off-axis single-mirror HMD optical system design

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 1. Specifications of freeform surface off-axis single-mirror HMD optical system design

      ParameterSpecifications
      Full field of view/(°)24(19.12×14.4)
      Exit pupil diameter/mm3
      Effective focal length/mm14.25
      Pixel size/μm14.1
      Distance of exit pupil/mm>15
      Spectral rangeVisible light band
      Image quality>30%@35 lp/mm
      Distortion<5%
      Size of the micro display0.25 in(6.35 mm)
    • Table 2. Zernike polynomial coefficients of freeform surface mirror

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 2. Zernike polynomial coefficients of freeform surface mirror

      Polynomial$ {Z}_{i}(x,y) $Polynomial coefficients$ {C}_{j} $
      $ {Z}_{1} $1$ {C}_{1} $18.472
      $ {Z}_{2} $2 $x$$ {C}_{2} $0
      ${{Z} }_{3}$2 $ {y} $$ {{C}}_{3} $$ 9.011\times {10}^{-2} $
      ${{Z} }_{4}$$\sqrt{3}\left[2\left({{x} }^{2}+{{y} }^{2}\right)-1\right]$${{C} }_{4}$$ -5.269\times {10}^{-3} $
      ${{Z} }_{5}$$2\sqrt{6}{x}{y}$${{C} }_{5}$0
      ${{Z} }_{6}$$\sqrt{6}\left({{x} }^{2}-{{y} }^{2}\right)$${{C} }_{6}$$ 1.499\times {10}^{-4} $
      ${{Z} }_{7}$$ \sqrt{8}\left[3\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)-2\right]{y} $$ {{C}}_{7} $$ 1.149\times {10}^{-5} $
      ${{Z} }_{8}$$ \sqrt{8}\left[3\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)-2\right]{x} $$ {{C}}_{8} $0
      $ {{Z}}_{9} $$ \sqrt{8}\left(3{{x}}^{2}-{{y}}^{2}\right){y} $$ {{C}}_{9} $$ 1.748\times {10}^{-6} $
      $ {{Z}}_{10} $$ \sqrt{8}\left({{x}}^{2}-{3{y}}^{2}\right){x} $$ {{C}}_{10} $0
      $ {{Z}}_{11} $$ \sqrt{5}\left[6{\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)}^{2}-6\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)+1\right] $$ {{C}}_{11} $$ -6.282\times {10}^{-7} $
      $ {{Z}}_{12} $$ \sqrt{10}\left({{x}}^{2}-{{y}}^{2}\right)\left[4\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)-3\right] $$ {{C}}_{12} $$ 3.439\times {10}^{-8} $
      $ {{Z}}_{13} $$ 2\sqrt{10}\left[4\left({{x}}^{2}+{{y}}^{2}\right)-3\right]{x}{y} $$ {{C}}_{13} $0
      $ {{Z}}_{14} $$ \sqrt{10}\left({{x}}^{4}-{6{x}}^{2}{{y}}^{2}+{{y}}^{4}\right) $$ {{C}}_{14} $$ -9.838\times {10}^{-7} $
      $ {{Z}}_{15} $$ 4\sqrt{10}\left({{x}}^{2}-{{y}}^{2}\right){x}{y} $$ {{C}}_{15} $0
    • Table 3. Specifications of freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system design

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 3. Specifications of freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system design

      ParametersSpecifications
      Micro display
      Micro displayOLED
      Size0.61 in (12.36 mm×9.36 mm)
      Resolution/pixel800×600
      Pixel size/μm15
      Head-mounted display system
      StructureOff-axis two-reflective system
      Exit pupil diameter/mm8
      F/# 4
      Distance of exit pupil/mm>30
      Full field of view/(°)28(23×16)
      Performance
      MTF>0.4@30 lp/mm,with a 4 mm exit pupil
      Maximum distortion<5%
    • Table 4. Tolerance data for freeform surface single-mirror HMD optical system

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 4. Tolerance data for freeform surface single-mirror HMD optical system

      Manufacture toleranceAlignment tolerance
      Shape error PV/λAir thickness /mm Decenter X/mm Decenter Y/mm Tilt X/(°) Tilt Y/(°) Tilt Z/(°)
      M11/4-±0.2±0.2±0.2±0.2±0.2
    • Table 5. Tolerance data for freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 5. Tolerance data for freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system

      Manufacture toleranceAlignment tolerance
      Shape error PV/λAir thickness /mm Decenter X/mm DecenterY/mm Tilt X/(°) Tilt Y/(°) Tilt Z/(°)
      F11/4±0.2±0.2±0.15±0.2±0.2±0.2
      F21/4±0.2±0.2±0.1±0.2±0.2±0.25
    • Table 6. Tolerance analysis of freeform surface single-mirror HMD optical system

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 6. Tolerance analysis of freeform surface single-mirror HMD optical system

      FieldX field /(°) Y field /(°) Theoretical MTF avgToleranced MTF avgMTF change
      1000.3780.3682.7%
      207.20.4160.4052.6%
      30−7.20.4950.4822.6%
      46.7600.4070.4011.5%
      56.767.20.3560.3385.1%
      66.76−7.20.5350.5300.9%
      79.5600.4550.4383.7%
      89.567.20.3280.3153.9%
      99.56−7.20.5320.5280.7%
    • Table 7. Tolerance analysis for freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 7. Tolerance analysis for freeform surface two-mirror HMD optical system

      FieldX field /(°) Y field /(°) Theoretical MTF avgToleranced MTF avgMTF change
      1000.5160.4787.4%
      2080.5600.5069.6%
      30−80.5740.5337.1%
      411.500.4530.39712.4%
      511.580.5790.5396.9%
      611.5−80.4070.3709.1%
      75.7500.5690.5267.6%
      85.7580.7380.6876.9%
      95.75−80.5050.4628.5%
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Congshan Rui, Chunmei Zeng, Zhiqiang Feng, Chengliang Xia, Yang Hong. Design method of freeform surface for off-axis reflective head-mounted display optical system[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2022, 51(10): 20211119

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Optical design

    Received: Dec. 29, 2021

    Accepted: --

    Published Online: Jan. 6, 2023

    The Author Email:

    DOI:10.3788/IRLA20211119

    Topics