Photonics Research, Volume. 11, Issue 11, 1934(2023)

Design strategy of a high-performance multispectral stealth material based on the 3D meta-atom

Pingping Min1, Zicheng Song1, Tianyu Wang2, Victor G. Ralchenko1,3, Yurong He2, and Jiaqi Zhu1、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1National Key Laboratory of Science and Technology on Advanced Composites in Special Environments, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150080, China
  • 2School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150080, China
  • 3Prokhorov General Physics Institute of Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow 119991, Russia
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(16)
    Schematic of the 3D meta-atom-based multispectral stealth material.
    Schematic of the 3D meta-atom: (a) side view of the 3D meta-atom, (b) top view of the IRSL, (c) top view of the MAU.
    Design of the IRSL. (a) The simulated transmittance of the IRSL with respect to frequency for various Rs2 and w. (b) The correlation chart between the IR emissivity and microwave transmittance spectra for IRSL design.
    Effect of variation in the imaginary part of relative permittivity and permeability on the absorptivity: (a) three-dimensional map; (b) two-dimensional map.
    Retrieved constitutive parameters and normalized impedance for different models.
    Scatter distribution plots of the imaginary part of relative permittivity versus the imaginary part of relative permeability at frequencies from 2 to 20 GHz for different models (the yellow area indicates the range where predicted absorptivity is over 90%).
    (a) Simulated absorption curves for different models. (b) Simulated frequency-dependent power loss of the constituents in the 3D meta-atom for Model-IV.
    Scatter distribution plots of the imaginary part of relative permittivity versus the imaginary part of relative permeability (top) and pie chart analysis on the consistency of predicted and simulated absorptivity (bottom) at frequencies from 2 to 20 GHz for different models.
    (a) Simulated absorption curve and (b) simulated variation curves of FBW with oblique incidence angles under TE and TM polarizations for the proof-of-concept prototype.
    Simulated absorptivity of the proof-of-concept prototype under oblique incidence with TE and TM polarizations.
    Measurement results of the fabricated prototype. (a) Photographic image of the prototype. (b) Visible transmission measurement. (c) Measured IR emissivity spectra (left) and comparison of measured and simulated microwave absorptivity (right). Inset: photograph of microwave absorption performance measurement scenario.
    Measured absorbance curves of the prototype under oblique incidence with (a) TE and (b) TM polarizations.
    Thermal infrared image of (a) glass substrate with uniform temperature distribution on the thermal plate and (b) continuous ITO, IRSL, and PET on the glass substrate.
    • Table 1. Sheet Impedances of Different Models

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 1. Sheet Impedances of Different Models

      Impedance
      ExamplesPillarIRSL
      Model-IPEC (no losses)5 Ω/sq
      Model-II10 Ω/sq5 Ω/sq
      Model-III100 Ω/sq5 Ω/sq
      Model-IV200 Ω/sq5 Ω/sq
    • Table 2. Quantitative Statistics on the Consistency of Predicted and Simulated Absorptivity for Different Models

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 2. Quantitative Statistics on the Consistency of Predicted and Simulated Absorptivity for Different Models

      ModelsPred. A<0.9and Sim A<0.9Pred. A<0.9and Sim A<0.9Pred. A>0.9but Sim A<0.9Pred. A<0.9but Sim A>0.9Accuracy
      Model-I098.1%0.9%1%98.1%
      Model-II5.1%92.5%2.4%097.6%
      Model-III60.6%35.1%3.5%0.8%95.7%
      Model-IV88.2%7.3%4.5%095.5%
    • Table 3. Comparison with Other Multispectral Stealth Materials

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 3. Comparison with Other Multispectral Stealth Materials

      Refs.IR EmissivityBandwidth (GHz)FBWAngle StabilityOptical TransparencyThicknessFoM
      TETM
      [27]0.237.5–1882.4%40°40°0.30.112λL3.88
      [28]0.497.3–18.888.1%Not mentioned0.250.085λL2.05
      [33]0.538.9–16.459.3%30°30°0.70.068λL1.81
      [60]0.255.7–16.597%30°40°Not mentioned0.073λL3.88
      [61]0.468–32120%30°60°0.540.101λL3.14
      [62]0.38.7–32115%30°45°0.60.112λL4.43
      This work0.282.7–18.8150%50°68°0.660.138λL6.02
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Pingping Min, Zicheng Song, Tianyu Wang, Victor G. Ralchenko, Yurong He, Jiaqi Zhu, "Design strategy of a high-performance multispectral stealth material based on the 3D meta-atom," Photonics Res. 11, 1934 (2023)

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Optical and Photonic Materials

    Received: Jul. 4, 2023

    Accepted: Sep. 1, 2023

    Published Online: Nov. 3, 2023

    The Author Email: Jiaqi Zhu (zhujq@hit.edu.cn)

    DOI:10.1364/PRJ.498640

    Topics