Asynchronous read-out single-photon avalanche diode (SPAD) array detectors1
Advanced Photonics, Volume. 6, Issue 1, 016003(2024)
Compact and effective photon-resolved image scanning microscope Article Video
Fluorescence confocal laser-scanning microscopy (LSM) is one of the most popular tools for life science research. This popularity is expected to grow thanks to single-photon array detectors tailored for LSM. These detectors offer unique single-photon spatiotemporal information, opening new perspectives for gentle and quantitative superresolution imaging. However, a flawless recording of this information poses significant challenges for the microscope data acquisition (DAQ) system. We present a DAQ module based on the digital frequency domain principle, able to record essential spatial and temporal features of photons. We use this module to extend the capabilities of established imaging techniques based on single-photon avalanche diode (SPAD) array detectors, such as fluorescence lifetime image scanning microscopy. Furthermore, we use the module to introduce a robust multispecies approach encoding the fluorophore excitation spectra in the time domain. Finally, we combine time-resolved stimulated emission depletion microscopy with image scanning microscopy, boosting spatial resolution. Our results demonstrate how a conventional fluorescence laser scanning microscope can transform into a simple, information-rich, superresolved imaging system with the simple addition of a SPAD array detector with a tailored data acquisition system. We expected a blooming of advanced single-photon imaging techniques, which effectively harness all the sample information encoded in each photon.
1 Introduction
Asynchronous read-out single-photon avalanche diode (SPAD) array detectors1
We integrate our new DFD-DAQ and control system into an SP-LSM architecture equipped with a commercial SPAD array detector. We validate the DFD module embedded in the microscope control and DAQ unit by implementing different FLISM-based imaging techniques. We combine our new platform with the fluorescence lifetime phasor analysis to implement functional superresolution imaging. Despite the lower temporal precision of a typical TT-DAQ module, the DFD-DAQ module allows the investigation of timescales short enough to monitor the lifetime changes of molecules with biological interest. The combination of our architecture with the phasor analysis also enables superresolution imaging of multiple fluorophores without spectral emission separation. In this case, we distinguish the different dyes on a sample by leveraging their different fluorescence lifetimes. Furthermore, we took advantage of the integration of the DFD module into the microscope control system to implement a pulse-interleaving multiwavelength excitation scheme. Different wavelengths enable the excitation of multiple fluorophores, which might have overlapping absorption spectra. We introduce a phasor-based method for multispecies separation, also in the event of spectral excitation cross talk. Finally, we implement nanoscopy by combining STED-ISM with separation-by-lifetime tuning (SPLIT).25,26 This approach uses the phasor analysis and the fluorescence lifetime changes induced by the stimulation emission process27 to improve the resolution of STED microscopy. Our results demonstrate the versatility and vast potentialities of the proposed architecture.
2 Results
In this work, we used a custom fluorescence laser-scanning microscope [Fig. 1(a)] equipped with a
Sign up for Advanced Photonics TOC Get the latest issue of Advanced Photonics delivered right to you!Sign up now
Figure 1.Setup and acquisition scheme. (a) Sketch of the STED-ISM custom microscope. The FPGA board controls two excitation lasers, a depletion laser, a couple of galvanometric mirrors, and a piezo-electric-controlled stage. The same FPGA board reads the output of each channel of the SPAD array detector. (b) Working principle of the heterodyne acquisition. The lifetime decay is sampled along multiple excitation periods using a detuned sampling frequency. The sampling accumulates a delay in each period, enabling data collection at different time points. Each sampling period is subsampled by short windows, boosting the temporal resolution.
The DFD-TDC performs digital heterodyning: excitation and sampling frequencies,
We designed our system to generate the excitation and sampling frequencies from the same FPGA clock: the excitation signal triggers the laser pulses, and the temporal histogram is fully calculated at the FPGA level. In short, our system embeds the control of the microscope and the measurement of the photon arrival time histogram in a single compact device. Advantageously, our architecture uses only a limited amount of hardware and software resources (see Note 1 in the Supplementary Material).
In this work, we use two specific configurations, running at
2.1 Fluorescence Lifetime Assay
To validate the proposed architecture, we used the DFD configuration running at
Figure 2.Validation of the DFD architecture. (a) Calibration procedure. The measured phasor is shifted and rescaled by the IRF calibration values. Additionally, each histogram is phase-shifted by the value provided by the trigger reference signal. Top, calibration of Alexa 594; bottom, calibration of Rhodamine 101. (b) Measured lifetime of an autofluorescent plastic slide as a function of the detected photon flux and of the hold-off time of the SPAD. The reported values are the saturation thresholds (in units of megacounts/s), defined as the flux at which lifetime estimation deteriorates by a factor larger than 3%. (c) Lifetime of a fluorescein solution at increasing concentration of a quencher, potassium iodide. We depict with the same colors the exponential curves and the corresponding phasors.
Implementing the TDC using a DFD approach allows for recording virtually all photon signals. Indeed, the dead time of the DFD module is given by the window duration, in our implementation
We experimentally verified the maximum photon flux that can be sustained by our multichannel DFD-DAQ module. We registered the fluorescence signal generated by an autofluorescent plastic slide (Chroma) at increasing excitation power. We calculated the fluorescence lifetime
Finally, we used our platform to measure the fluorescence lifetime values for a series of fluorescein solutions obtained with increasing concentrations of the quencher potassium iodide. As expected, the platform retrieves shorter lifetimes as the quencher concentration increases [Fig. 2(c)].
2.2 FLISM for Functional Imaging
After validating the multichannel DFD-DAQ module, we used the module to implement FLISM.6,9 FLISM harnesses the photon-resolved spatiotemporal information provided by the SPAD array to obtain a superresolved fluorescence lifetime map of the sample. On each acquisition, the microscope builds a 5D photon-counts map
Figure 3.FLISM imaging. (a) Alpha-tubulin stained with ATTO 647N in fixed HeLa cells. (b) Nuclear pore complexes stained with Abberior STAR 580 in fixed HeLa cells. (c) Live HeLa cell labeled with the CellBrite® NIR 680 cytoplasmic membrane dye. The displayed frames are captured at
Next, we used the FLISM approach to measure living HeLa cells labeled with the CellBrite® NIR 680 cytoplasmic membrane dye. Because the dye uniformly labels any membrane structure, conventional intensity-based imaging cannot distinguish the signal stemming from cell membrane or membrane-enclosed organelles (e.g., lysosomes). Conversely, FLISM reveals a broad distribution of the fluorescence lifetime values, which allows for distinguishing the plasma membranes (longer fluorescence lifetime) from intracellular vesicles or lipid-based structures (shorter fluorescence lifetime). Indeed, the variation of the probe fluorescence lifetime allows for monitoring the changes in the local environment. The superior SNR of ISM imaging allows for working at reduced illumination intensity, thus allowing for long-term imaging [Fig. 2(c)]. We follow the variations of the fluorescence lifetime of the membrane dye within the HeLa cells for more than 2 h.
2.3 FLISM for Multispecies Imaging
Biological investigations often require visualizing multiple biomolecules and cellular compartments simultaneously. Multispecies imaging generally targets the different biomolecules with spectrally separable fluorophores. A time-resolved detection system enables separating fluorophores based on their fluorescence lifetime, offering a viable alternative to distinguishing dyes with similar emission and excitation spectra. Conveniently, this solution requires only a single detector. Furthermore, lifetime separation does not preclude spectral separation. Indeed, the two approaches can be combined to enable the separation of an even wider number of species.20
Here we demonstrate how our DFD-DAQ module can implement imaging through fluorescence lifetime multiplexing. In particular, we show that FLISM method can perform superresolution multispecies imaging using a single SPAD array detector. We stained
For this reason, we analyzed FLISM data with a linear unmixing algorithm—called phasor separation—inspired by previously reported unmixing methods.25,33,34 This latter decomposes the FLISM signal of each scan point
Figure 4.Time-resolved acquisition for multicolor ISM imaging. (a) ISM imaging of different species, reported by two dyes with similar “spectra” but different fluorescence lifetimes. (b) Pulse-interleaving ISM imaging of different species with overlapping absorption spectrum and identical lifetime. Left, schematic diagrams of (top) the absorption/emission spectra of fluorophores 1 (magenta) and 2 (green), and (bottom) of the detected signal over time. The excitation lines are also represented. Right, phasor representation of (top) two measurements obtained with only one species labeled at a time, and (bottom) of the measurement with both species labeled. Left image, raw open confocal image. Central image, open confocal result obtained by (a) segmenting the phasor space in two regions, related to the first and the second fluorophores or (b) by temporal gating of the detected signal in two temporal channels, related to the first and the second excitation events. Right image, open confocal and ISM results obtained by phasor separation.
An alternative approach for simultaneous multispecies imaging with a single SPAD array detector is the pulsed interleaved excitation (PIE) technique. The PIE technique can be applied if the probes have different absorption spectra but similar emission spectra. It consists of a sequential excitation at different wavelengths, synchronized with the signal recording. This strategy reduces the spectral emission cross talk without significantly reducing the acquisition speed, since the excitation repetition rate can be as fast as tens of megahertz. The PIE technique encodes the spectral information into the time domain, which can be used to separate the different fluorophores if no other discrimination is possible. Indeed, the PIE technique is key when the dyes have very similar lifetime values, so they cannot be reliably separated using this latter. In more detail, a phasor associated with the second excitation window will appear rotated by 180 deg in the complex plane. This approach well conditions the phasor unmixing problem well, which would be ill-posed if the lifetime value of the dyes is the same. We achieve PIE by synchronizing several pulsed lasers with different colors. The pulses from the different lasers are alternated with a delay much longer than the fluorescence lifetime of the probe to ensure that a dye emits all the photons before exciting the other dye. We record the photons’ arrival time information with respect to the excitation pulse, enabling the generation of different images obtained by binning the photons in different temporal windows, one for each species.35 This method, known as time-gating, fails if the absorption spectra of the probes overlap, since one fluorophore could be excited by multiple excitation colors. Harnessing the phasor information, we remove the cross talk by unmixing the contributions of different fluorophores by decoding the absorption information encoded in the fluorescence dynamics. To demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed approach, we performed PIE imaging of a fixed HeLa cell (Tubulin labeled with ATTO 647N and nuclear-pore complexes with Abberior STAR 580). The two dyes have an overlapping absorption spectrum. Thus time-gating alone cannot effectively separate the structures labeled with the two dyes. In particular, ATTO 647 can be excited by the lasers at 560 and 640 nm, contributing to the counts of the window assigned to STAR 580. Additionally, the two dyes have very similar lifetime values (nominally, both have
2.4 FLISM for Nanoscopy Imaging
Another advanced fluorescence LSM technique that can significantly benefit from the single-photon imaging paradigm is STED microscopy. In STED microscopy, a second laser beam, the STED beam, induces stimulated emission on the fluorescent probe. The STED beam is engineered in phase and polarization to generate a doughnut-shaped intensity distribution at the focus. By spatially overlapping the foci of the depletion and excitation beam, the probed region of the laser-scanning microscope reduces in size well below the diffraction limit: the higher the STED beam intensity is, the smaller the probed region is.36 The combination of STED microscopy with ISM enables a reduction of the STED beam intensity to achieve a target resolution. This benefit is maximal at low STED beam intensity and vanishes for high-intensity values. However, live-cell imaging is typically performed at reduced STED beam intensity to mitigate phototoxicity. Indeed, we recently demonstrated that live-cell superresolution imaging is feasible for extended time-lapse experiments without damaging the sample. Furthermore, the additional spatial information that the detector array provides enables effective background removal.10
In the context of gentle live-cell STED microscopy, a widely used approach to reduce the STED beam intensity is time-resolved STED microscopy27,37,38—now implemented in all commercial instruments. Time-resolved STED microscopy is a class of implementation that leverages the relation between fluorescence depletion and fluorescence lifetime. Indeed, stimulated emission opens a new relaxation pathway for the probe, whose rate is proportional to the intensity of the STED beam. Thereby, the higher the intensity is, the higher the efficiency of depletion is, and the shorter the fluorescence lifetime of the probe is. Because the STED beam intensity at the focus is shaped like a doughnut, it induces a fluorescence lifetime spatial signature: the fluorescence lifetime is the shortest at the periphery and unperturbed at the center of the probed region, where the intensity of the depletion beam is at its maximum and minimum, respectively. Time-resolved STED microscopy harnesses the spatial dependency of fluorescence lifetime to distinguish the fluorescence signal generated from the center or periphery of the probed region. The result is a smaller effective point spread function (PSF). Thus the resolution is enhanced without increasing the STED beam intensity.
Time-resolved STED microscopy initially used a time-gated detection37,38 to remove the short-lived fluorescent signal. The fluorescence signal is recorded only after a fixed delay (a fraction of the probe’s natural fluorescence lifetime) from the excitation events triggered by the pulsed laser. The longer the delay is, the smaller the effective probed region is. However, time-gated detection also rejects part of the fluorescence signal generated from the center, thus reducing the SNR. Given the photon arrival time histogram of the probed region, a computational alternative can solve the hardware time-gated detection limitations, providing the same resolution improvement but without a strong SNR reduction. In particular, the SPLIT method can separate the long-lived and short-lived fluorescence signal generated from the inner and outer parts of the STED microscopy probed region, respectively.25,26,39,40 The SPLIT method represents the two decays as a linear combination of phasors. Thus the unmixing problem of the different components is solved by the SPLIT method by inverting a simple linear system (see Note 3 and Figs. S8 and S9 in the Supplementary Material).
Here we used our proposed DFD-DAQ module to introduce time-resolved STED-ISM. In particular, we combined APR-based STED-ISM with the SPLIT approach. We call this combination SPLIT-STED-ISM. We first applied the SPLIT approach on the 5D raw STED photon-counts map
We tested the new SPLIT-STED-ISM method on fixed HeLa cells with ATTO 647N-labeled tubulin. The longer the duration of the STED pulse is, the more useful SPLIT is in removing the incomplete depletion background at the periphery of the probed region.27 In a practical scenario like ours, the pulse width is nonnegligible with respect to a probe’s fluorescent lifetime—about 600 ps to a few nanoseconds. Thus combining STED-ISM with SPLIT produces a high-contrast and high-quality image [Fig. 5(a) and Fig. S11(a) in the Supplementary Material]. Finally, we complemented nanoscopy with multispecies imaging. In detail, we used the PIE approach combined with STED microscopy. We separated the different fluorophores (STAR RED for nuclear pore complexes and STAR ORANGE for the Golgi apparatus) through time-gating—given the lack of fluorophores cross talk. Thus we demonstrated how, by encoding the spectral information into the time domain, we enable multicolor STED imaging using a single detector. Multispecies imaging does not hinder the SPLIT method, which can be applied to each excitation window. Thus we generated a multicolor SPLIT-STED-ISM image [Fig. 5(b) and Fig. S11(b) in the Supplementary Material]. With a single measurement, we separated the contribution of different fluorophores, performed superresolution imaging of the labeled structures, and improved contrast and resolution of each channel (Figs. S12 and S13 in the Supplementary Material). This result demonstrates the vast capabilities of our photon-resolved platform. Indeed, the new possibilities unlocked by the additional temporal and spatial information do not compromise any of the conventional features of STED imaging. We achieved each benefit with a simple tailored acquisition system based on a SPAD array detector without changing the core optical architecture or the experimental protocols.
Figure 5.SPLIT-STED-ISM. (a) Side-by-side comparison of raw STED imaging and SPLIT-STED-ISM imaging of the cytoskeleton network. The insets show magnified details of the network. The incomplete depletion background is also visualized (bottom inset, right corner). (b) Multispecies SPLIT-STED-ISM imaging (green, Golgi apparatus; red, nuclear pore complex protein, NPC). Pulse-interleaving excitation and time-resolved detection enable the separation of two color channels—one per each fluorophore—and to apply SPLIT to the NPC channel. The upper corner shows the raw STED image (blue), while the lower corner shows the final multi-color SPLIT-STED-ISM image.
3 Discussion
We presented an FPGA-based multichannel DAQ system tailored for fluorescence LSM with asynchronous read-out SPAD array detectors. This system uses the DFD principle to implement 25 low-resource TDCs. Using limited resources of the FPGA, our architecture enables the integration of the DAQ-DFD module and the microscope control unit into the same FPGA-based board, greatly reducing the microscope cost and complexity. These benefits come at the cost of a lower temporal precision and sampling (
We used the proposed DFD-DAQ system to implement the well-established FLISM technique and demonstrate novel advanced imaging techniques based on the single-photon laser scanning microscopy paradigm. In particular, we demonstrated a method capable of distinguishing fluorophores on the base of their absorption spectra. We used the pulse-interleaving excitation scheme to encode the spectral information of the fluorophores into the time domain. Successively, we used a phasor-based approach to decode the fluorescence light emitted by the two species. The proposed method automatically corrects the fluorophore excitation cross talk. Notably, the same approach can also distinguish fluorophores with different lifetimes, setting the basis for multispecies ISM imaging with a single detector. Thus we effectively increased the portfolio of usable dyes.
We also demonstrated the combination of ISM with time-resolved STED microscopy. In a recent paper, we showed the benefits of combining STED microscopy with the APR method to reduce the STED beam intensity, thus minimizing the risk of inducing photodamage.10 Here we demonstrate that leveraging single-photon temporal information can further boost the benefits. We proved that the SPLIT method increases the resolution and contrast of the image. Since the algorithm can be applied to each pixel and channel independently, it leaves the dimensionality of the ISM data set intact. Thus the processed data are still compatible with the recent and advanced image reconstruction algorithm developed for ISM, such as focus-ISM10 or multi-image deconvolution.42 We envision that maximum likelihood reconstruction methods that consider both the spatial and temporal information will emerge as a superior reconstruction tool for time-resolved STED-ISM data sets. Indeed, the spatiotemporal information is encoded in the temporal PSFs: the stimulated emission process introduces a temporal evolution on the effective PSF. Namely, the stronger the effect of the STED beam, the narrower the PSF associated with each scanned image (Figs. S10 and S14 in the Supplementary Material).
In conclusion, we believe that the proposed architecture will make photon-resolved image scanning microscopy easily accessible, paving the way for gentle, versatile imaging at high spatial resolution and information content.
4 Methods
4.1 Microscope Architecture
For this work, we updated the STED-ISM setup described previously,10 adding the possibility of exciting the sample also with a green laser beam and recording the photon arrival time histograms (Fig. S1 in the Supplementary Material). Briefly, the excitation beams were provided by two triggerable pulsed (
4.2 Experimental Procedure
To respect the Nyquist–Shannon criterion, the sampling frequency has to be larger than twice the largest frequency of the signal. For an exponential decay, the cut-off frequency is
4.3 Sample Preparation
4.3.1 Quenched fluorescent solutions
For spectroscopy measurements [Fig. 2(c)], we prepared different solutions of fluorescein (46955, free acid, Sigma-Aldrich, Steinheim) at different concentrations of the quencher salt potassium iodide [60399-100G-F, BioUltra,
4.3.2 Fluorescent beads
To qualitatively characterize the spatial resolution enhancement of ISM and STED microscopy (Figs. S3 and S8 in the Supplementary Material), we used a commercial sample of ATTO 647N fluorescent beads with a diameter of 23 nm (Gatta-BeadsR, GattaQuant).
4.3.3 Fixed cell imaging
To validate our DFD-DAQ system for FLISM imaging [Figs. 3(a) and 3(b), Fig. S4 in the Supplementary Material], multispecies imaging based on pulse-interleaving excitation [Fig. 4(b)], and single-color STED imaging [Fig. 5(a)], we used a fixed HeLa cell labeled to visualize
To validate our DFD-DAQ system for multispecies imaging based on fluorescence lifetime [Fig. 4(a)], we used fixed MCF10A labeled to visualize
To validate our DF-DAQ system for multicolor STED-ISM imaging [Fig. 5(b)], we used a ready-to-image sample kit (Imaging set for STED at 775 nm, Abberior). The microscope slide contains fixed mammalian cells immuno-stained for a nuclear pore protein with STAR RED (Abberior GmbH, Göttingen, Germany) and the Golgi apparatus protein giantin with STAR ORANGE (Abberior GmbH, Göttingen, Germany).
4.3.4 Live cell imaging
For FLISM functional live-cell imaging, we used HeLa cells [Fig. 3(c)]. HeLa cells were seeded on
Giorgio Tortarolo got his MSc degree in engineering from the University of Genoa, Italy, in 2015. After graduating, he joined the Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy, as a PhD student, under the supervision of Dr. Giuseppe Vicidomini. He worked on an innovative image scanning microscopy platform and, in 2020 got his PhD. Currently, he is a Human Frontier Science Program cross-disciplinary fellow at EPFL, Lausanne, Switzerland, under the supervision of Prof. Suliana Manley.
Alessandro Zunino obtained his BSc degree in 2015 and his MSc degree in physics in 2018 from the University of Milan, Italy. In 2018, he started his PhD project at the Italian Institute of Technology (IIT), Genoa, Italy, under the supervision of Prof. Martí Duocastella and Prof. Alberto Diaspro. He obtained his PhD in physics in June 2022. Currently, he is a postdoctoral researcher within the group of Dr. Giuseppe Vicidomini at IIT.
Simonluca Piazza completed his MSc degree in biomedical engineering at the University of Genoa, Italy, 2014. He then earned his PhD in optical microscopy from the Italian Institute of Technology, Italy, 2018, under the guidance of Dr. Marti Duocastella, during which he developed advanced optical systems for imaging and fabrication. Since 2019, he has been a co-founder and CEO of Genoa Instruments, a company specializing in designing, manufacturing, and bringing to market super-resolution optical microscopes based on image scanning microscopy.
Mattia Donato got his BSc degree in 2010 and his MSc degree in 2013 in physics from the University of Genoa, Italy. His master thesis was developed in the Fusion Diagnostics Group at Uppsala University, Sweden, on the topic of neutron detectors characterization. Subsequently, he worked in the Detector Group at European XFEL focusing on the commissioning of an X-ray megahertz imager, obtaining his PhD from University of Hamburg in 2018. Currently, he works at Dr. Giuseppe Vicidomini's group, IIT, Genoa, Italy.
Sabrina Zappone studied medical biotechnologies at the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Italy. After graduation, she joined the Molecular Microscopy and Spectroscopy Group at the Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, Italy, as a fellow student. Since November 2021, she has been a PhD student in bionanotechnology (bioengineering and robotics) at the University of Genoa, Italy, in collaboration with the Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia and under the supervision of Dr. Giuseppe Vicidomini.
Agnieszka Pierzyńska-Mach obtained her PhD in biophysics in 2017 from Jagiellonian University, Cracow, Poland. Subsequently, she completed a postdoctoral fellowship at the Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy, in the group of Prof. Alberto Diaspro and the European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy. In 2018, she secured an individual fellowship MSCA Horizon 2020 and investigated the nanoscale distribution of chromatin factors using advanced super-resolution microscopy techniques. Currently, she is an imaging scientist at the EPFL, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Marco Castello obtained his MSc degree in biomedical engineering from the University of Genoa, Italy, in 2012. Following his graduation, he earned his PhD in optical microscopy from the Italian Institute of Technology, IIT, Genoa, Italy, in 2017, under the mentorship of Dr. Giuseppe Vicidomini. He focused on advancing the field of optical microscopy with the development of a practical implementation of image scanning microscopy based on a SPAD array. Starting from 2019, he has served as co-founder and CTO of Genoa Instruments. The company focuses on the design and manufacturing of super-resolution optical microscopes based on image scanning microscopy.
Giuseppe Vicidomini obtained his PhD in computer science in 2008 from the University of Genoa, Italy, under the supervision of Prof. Alberto Diaspro. Following this, he joined the group of Prof. Stefan Hell at the Max Planck Institute in Goettingen, Germany. In 2011, he returned to Italy as a researcher at the Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, and in 2016, he became the principal investigator of the Molecular Microscopy and Spectroscopy lab. Giuseppe Vicidomini is a grantee of the BrightEyes ERC project and co-founder of Genoa Instruments.
[14] C. J. R. Sheppard. Super-resolution in confocal imaging. Optik, 80, 53-54(1988).
[28] I. Johnson. Molecular Probes Handbook: A Guide to Fluorescent Probes and Labeling Technologies(2010).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Giorgio Tortarolo, Alessandro Zunino, Simonluca Piazza, Mattia Donato, Sabrina Zappone, Agnieszka Pierzyńska-Mach, Marco Castello, Giuseppe Vicidomini, "Compact and effective photon-resolved image scanning microscope," Adv. Photon. 6, 016003 (2024)
Category: Research Articles
Received: Jul. 5, 2023
Accepted: Dec. 22, 2023
Posted: Apr. 17, 2024
Published Online: Jan. 29, 2024
The Author Email: Castello Marco (marco.castello@genoainstruments.com), Vicidomini Giuseppe (giuseppe.vicidomini@iit.it)