Chinese Optics Letters, Volume. 23, Issue 4, 043601(2025)

Coherent coupling in a WS2/graphene van der Waals heterostructure integrated with an Au nanoantenna

Liping Hou... Qifa Wang, Huan Luo, Chenyang Li, Xuetao Gan*, Fajun Xiao** and Jianlin Zhao*** |Show fewer author(s)
Author Affiliations
  • Key Laboratory of Light Field Manipulation and Information Acquisition, Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, and Shaanxi Key Laboratory of Optical Information Technology, School of Physical Science and Technology, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi’an 710129, China
  • show less

    Coherent interactions between excitons strongly coupled to plasmons are vital for quantum information devices. For practical applications, suppressing the incoherent dissipation pathways in the hybrid system is essential. Here, we report on a strong plasmon–exciton coupling in a monolayer WS2/graphene van der Waals heterostructure (WS2/Gr vdWhs) integrated with an Au nanocube (Au NC). The presence of graphene effectively suppresses the nonradiative decay pathway of neutral excitons in the vdWhs, resulting in a narrower photoluminescence (PL) linewidth. The further integration of the WS2/Gr vdWhs with the Au NC enables coherent interaction between the in-plane exciton and a tilted plasmonic dipole, delivering a Rabi splitting energy of 120 meV and an incoherent coupling strength of 1 meV. Our findings possess the potential to facilitate the advancement of quantum nanophotonic devices.

    Keywords

    1. Introduction

    At the nanoscale, the strong interaction between the emitter and optical cavity has been considered to be a pivotal factor propelling the advancement and application of quantum devices[1]. In the strong coupling regime, the coherent and incoherent exchange of photon energy collectively contributes to radiation coupling. This not only modifies the energetics of the coupled system but also dominates its dynamics by altering the radiative damping of hybrid modes, resulting in sub- and super-radiant phenomena[2,3]. For instance, polaritons formed through coherent energy exchange in strong coupling systems provide an excellent platform for achieving Bose–Einstein condensation[4,5], low-threshold lasing[6], quantum information processing and storage[7], and the realization of photonic logic gate structures[8]. The coupling strength, defined as g=Nμ|Evac|μN/V, can be enhanced by reducing the mode volume (V) of the optical cavity and increasing the transition dipole moment (μ) of the emitter[9]. In this regard, plasmonic nanostructures have been extensively employed to achieve strong coupling under ambient conditions[10], leveraging the advantage of strong local field enhancement[11], thereby enhancing the rate of coherent energy exchange. The coherent energy exchange in strongly coupled systems, consisting of metal nanostructures and various emitters such as quantum dots[12], dye molecules[13], and J-aggregates[14], has resulted in mode splitting in the spectral domain and ultrafast coherent energy oscillation in the time domain. The coherent plasmon and exciton interaction is of central importance for various applications, including all-optical ultrafast plasmonic circuits[13], nanoscale optical modulators, and quantum gates[12]. However, the coherent coupling is influenced by the photostability of these organic molecules or quantum dots, as well as the heterogeneous and disordered assembly of excitons.

    Monolayer transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) are direct bandgap semiconductor materials characterized by significant transition dipole moments, relative inertness, optical stability, and large exciton binding energy[1517]. Recently, the plasmon–exciton coherent coupling has been extensively investigated in monolayer TMDs integrated with a variety of plasmonic structures, including single metallic nanoparticles[18], particle-on-mirror (PoM) nanocavities[10,19], and metallic nanostructure arrays[20,21]. As an example, in the hybrid structure composed of the monolayer WS2 and PoM nanocavity, neutral excitons can coherently couple with magnetic plasmon mode, leading to a Rabi splitting energy of 200 meV[22]. Of note, besides the coherent coupling, the hybrid system also has an incoherent damping channel. In this channel, the spontaneously emitted photon decays to a continuum reservoir and is subsequently reabsorbed by the other subsystem without conserving any phase relationship[3,22,23]. Consequently, this channel inevitably degrades the coherence of the coupling process[24] and hinders the potential applications in quantum computing and communication[25]. Current studies reveal that the incoherent coupling strength of hybrid systems can be significantly mitigated by suppressing the photon exchange between the two subsystems through the continuum reservoir[23,26]. This is achieved by aligning the net electric dipole moment (μpl) perpendicular to the exciton transition dipole moment (μex) and minimizing the nonradiative decay of the exciton[24]. However, to achieve a strong coupling, the electric dipole moment of the plasmonic mode is commonly required to be parallel with the dominated in-plane exciton of TMDs[20,27], which simultaneously introduces large decoherence to the coupled system. On the other hand, for monolayer TMDs, the underlying substrate inevitably introduces the nonradiative recombination losses caused by charged impurities, optical phonons, and surface roughness[28,29], resulting in the broadening of the exciton linewidth[24,30]. These two factors pose substantial obstacles in suppressing incoherent damping during strong coupling.

    To address these challenges, we propose a strong coupling system by integrating monolayer WS2/graphene van der Waals heterostructures (WS2/Gr vdWhs) with an Au nanocube (Au NC). Growing monolayer WS2 on Gr, featured by defect-free lattices and smooth surfaces, effectively suppresses nonradiative pathways of neutral excitons[31], leading to a narrower photoluminescence (PL) linewidth[32,33]. Additionally, a tilted plasmonic dipole is employed to achieve strong coupling with the in-plane exciton in WS2, while simultaneously maintaining high coherence by suppressing the photon exchange between the two subsystems. These two advantages afford us to observe a plasmon–exciton strong coupling, characterized by a Rabi splitting up to 120 meV and a remarkably low incoherent coupling strength of 1 meV. Remarkably, this incoherent coupling strength is three times smaller than the optimal results reported in current plasmon–exciton hybrid systems.

    2. Simulation Details

    The scattering spectra of the coupled systems were calculated using the finite-element method (FEM), with experimental counterparts as models. The permittivity values for gold, graphene, and monolayer WS2 were determined based on the experimental data[3436], while those of Al2O3 and CTAB were set to 1.5 and 1.435, respectively. The scattering field is calculated through a two-step method, wherein the background field originating from the plane wave incident on the bare substrate serves as the excitation in the presence of Au NC.

    3. Results and Discussion

    The coupled system consists of an Au NC positioned on a monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs, as shown in Fig. 1(a). The bright-field image of the coupled system is presented in Fig. 1(b), where the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs flakes, with a dimension over 20 µm, are indicated by the white dashed box. In Fig. 1(c), we present the scanning electronic microscope (SEM) image of the coupled system, wherein the constituent Au NC, denoted by a white dashed circle, exhibits an edge length of 87 nm as shown in Fig. 1(d). The monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs is characterized by the Raman spectrum depicted by the blue solid lines of Fig. 1(e), where the peak positions at 351.6, 356.3, and 418.1cm1 are identified as 2LA, E2g1, and A1g modes, respectively. The frequency difference of 61.8cm1 between A1g and E2g1 modes, along with a peak intensity ratio of 6.2 for I(2LA)/I(A1g), confirms the monolayer thickness of the as-grown WS2 flakes[37,38]. The Raman spectrum of Gr [Fig. 1(e)] shows an I(G)/I(SiG) peak area intensity ratio of 0.32, suggesting that the graphene primarily consists of regions with 4 layers[39].

    Monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system. (a) A schematic of the coupled system with an Au NC and a monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs. (b) Bright-field and (c) SEM images of the Au NC. The white dashed circle indicates the Au NC measured in the optical setups. (d) Zoom-in SEM image of the corresponding individual Au NC. The scale bar is 100 nm. (e) Raman spectra of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs (blue solid lines).

    Figure 1.Monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system. (a) A schematic of the coupled system with an Au NC and a monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs. (b) Bright-field and (c) SEM images of the Au NC. The white dashed circle indicates the Au NC measured in the optical setups. (d) Zoom-in SEM image of the corresponding individual Au NC. The scale bar is 100 nm. (e) Raman spectra of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs (blue solid lines).

    The scattering spectrum of the Au NC (L=87nm) under p-polarized illumination at an incident angle of 60° is shown in Fig. 2(a). It exhibits a prominent plasmon resonance at 584 nm with a linewidth of 210 meV (Γpl=2γpl). The collaboration of the simulated charge map enables us to identify this plasmonic mode originating from a tilt-oriented electric dipole, as depicted in the inset of Fig. 2(a). This configuration can achieve a balance between the plasmon–exciton strong coupling and the suppression of incoherent coupling strength. The plasmonic mode exhibits a maximum enhancement factor of 13 for the in-plane electric field, as shown in Fig. 2(b), making it suitable for strong coupling with the in-plane neutral exciton of WS2. Compared to the PoM nanocavity[19], the out-of-plane component of the electric field is relatively weak, which allows us to disregard the contribution of dark excitons to the scattering spectrum in this experiment. Figure 2(c) depicts the PL spectra of monolayer WS2 and WS2/Gr vdWhs. Compared with monolayer WS2, the neutral exciton emission from the vdWhs exhibits a redshift of 4 meV due to the decreased tensile stress in WS2 grown on Gr[32,40,41]. Notably, the WS2 in the vdWhs region demonstrates fewer defects and charged impurities[32], which effectively suppresses nonradiative pathways of neutral excitons[28,29,32], resulting in a narrower PL linewidth (Γex=2γex=20meV) compared with the monolayer WS2 (64 meV). The lower panel of Fig. 2(a) shows a typical dark-field scattering spectrum of the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system, revealing a pronounced dip near the position of the neutral exciton. This observation indicates significant coupling arising from the interaction between the plasmonic dipole mode and neutral excitons. Figure 2(d) shows the mode volume of two coupled systems, i.e., WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and WS2-Au NC, as a function of wavelength. As seen, owing to the semimetallic nature of Gr, the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC exhibits a smaller mode volume of 103nm3, which is comparable to the state-of-the-art results achieved with individual nanoparticles such as gold bipyramids[27] and ultra-small gold nanorods[42]. Similar to the PoM nanocavity, the plasmonic mode of the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system has the potential to enhance PL emission[19]. More importantly, this tightly confined electric field is highly favorable for reducing the number of excitons involved in the strong coupling.

    Optical characterization of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC. (a) Scattering spectra of Au NC uncoupled (upper panel) and coupled with monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs flakes (lower panel). The inset shows the charge distributions of the plasmon mode. (b) Electromagnetic field enhancement maps of the Au NC (length 87 nm). (c) PL spectra of WS2/Gr vdWhs (orange solid line) and monolayer WS2 (blue solid line). (d) Mode volume of the Au NC when coupled with the WS2/Gr vdWhs (orange squares) and the WS2 (blue squares).

    Figure 2.Optical characterization of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC. (a) Scattering spectra of Au NC uncoupled (upper panel) and coupled with monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs flakes (lower panel). The inset shows the charge distributions of the plasmon mode. (b) Electromagnetic field enhancement maps of the Au NC (length 87 nm). (c) PL spectra of WS2/Gr vdWhs (orange solid line) and monolayer WS2 (blue solid line). (d) Mode volume of the Au NC when coupled with the WS2/Gr vdWhs (orange squares) and the WS2 (blue squares).

    According to the Maxwell–Garnett theory, the plasmon resonance wavelength strongly depends on the local dielectric environment[43]; therefore, a dynamically adjustable coupling system can be achieved by changing the dielectric screening effect through successively depositing alumina layers onto the sample using atomic layer deposition[44]. For an Au NC on the SiO2/Si substrate, the dipolar plasmonic resonance can be redshifted from 584 to 644 nm by increasing the coating thickness from 0 to 15.4 nm (see Fig. 3). Consequently, this spectral tunability ensures plasmon resonance frequency ωpl shifts across that of exciton ωex, as illustrated by the dots in Fig. 4(a). It is observed that the scattering spectra of the coupled system at room temperature consistently exhibit a dip near the position of the exciton at different detunings, demonstrating an evident anticrossing behavior. The excitonic behavior of TMDs remains relatively stable at room temperature, thereby mitigating the effects of temperature-induced dephasing on excitonic states and minimizing the reduction in exciton coherence, which may consequently influence plasmon–exciton coupling[45]. Moreover, the simulated scattering spectra are consistent with the anticrossing behavior of the coupled system, as shown in Fig. 4(b). It is worth noting that an enhanced exciton oscillation strength results in a simulated coupling strength in the scattering spectra that surpasses the experimental value[44,45].

    Experimental dark-field scattering spectra of the Au NC with an increased alumina coating.

    Figure 3.Experimental dark-field scattering spectra of the Au NC with an increased alumina coating.

    Strong coupling in the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC. (a) Experimental and (b) simulated dark-field scattering spectra of the coupled system with an increased alumina coating.

    Figure 4.Strong coupling in the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC. (a) Experimental and (b) simulated dark-field scattering spectra of the coupled system with an increased alumina coating.

    To explore the coupling effect between the excitons and the dipolar mode, we fitted the scattering spectra with a Fano-like line shape S(ω)=|s(ω)|2 with the scattering coefficient s(ω) defined as[23]s(ω)=ab+k=UPB,LPBbkγkeiϕkωωk+iγk,where ab denotes the background amplitude, ϕk represents the spectral phase of the hybrid states, and bk is the amplitude. The fitted spectra shown as solid lines in Fig. 4(a) are in good agreement with the experiment results. However, due to the low radiation efficiency of these higher-order modes around 550 nm, they appear comparatively weak in the experimental scattering spectrum. Consequently, our theoretical model mainly focused on investigating the coupling between tilt-oriented electric dipoles and neutral excitons. This discrepancy between the fitted and simulated scattering spectra arises as a result.

    Figures 5(a) and 5(e) present two spectral maxima (ωk) and their corresponding spectral full width at half-maximum (FWHM, denoted by Γk=2γk), which are extracted from the measured scattering spectra using Eq. (1). To further analyze the coherent and incoherent coupling process of a coupled system, we employ the coupled-oscillator model (COM)[45] with a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian to describe the eigenvalue problem[14,23]: ([ω¯plΩRΩRω¯ex]i[0γxpγxp0])[αβ]±=E±[αβ]±,where ω¯pl=ωpliγpl and ω¯ex=ωexiγex are the complex resonance frequencies of the plasmon mode and exciton, respectively. ΩR represents the coupling strength, γxp denotes the incoherent coupling strength, and α and β are elements of the eigenvector (Hopfield coefficients) and satisfy |α|2+|β|2=1. The diagonalization of this Hamiltonian results in the emergence of two polaritonic eigenvalues[23]: E±=(ω¯pl+ω¯ex2)±(ω¯plω¯ex2)2+(|ΩR|2γxp2)2iγxpRe(ΩR).

    Anticrossing behavior of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and WS2-Au NC. Energy of the UPB (orange dots) and LPB (blue dots) as a function of detuning for (a) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (b) WS2-Au NC coupled systems. The green dots denote the exciton energy, and the purple dots represent the plasmon energy. Hopfield coefficients for the UPB (upper panels) and LPB (lower panels) of the (c) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (d) WS2-Au NC coupled systems. Fitted (solid curves) and experimental (dots) spectral widths of the UPB and LPB for the (e) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (f) WS2-Au NC coupled systems.

    Figure 5.Anticrossing behavior of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and WS2-Au NC. Energy of the UPB (orange dots) and LPB (blue dots) as a function of detuning for (a) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (b) WS2-Au NC coupled systems. The green dots denote the exciton energy, and the purple dots represent the plasmon energy. Hopfield coefficients for the UPB (upper panels) and LPB (lower panels) of the (c) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (d) WS2-Au NC coupled systems. Fitted (solid curves) and experimental (dots) spectral widths of the UPB and LPB for the (e) WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC and (f) WS2-Au NC coupled systems.

    Figures 5(a) and 5(b) show the fitting results to the peak energies of the upper polariton branch (UPB) and lower polariton branch (LPB) using Eq. (3). The Rabi splitting energy of the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system can be obtained as 120 meV at zero detuning δ=|ωplωex|=0, satisfying the criterion for strong coupling 2ΩR>(Γpl+Γex)/2. In Fig. 5(b), we display the anticrossing behavior of the WS2-Au NC coupled system, where the Rabi splitting was found to be 140 meV, indicating that the system also falls into the strong coupling regime. The Hopfield coefficients of the UPB and LPB versus the detuning δ are shown in Figs. 5(c) and 5(d) for two coupled systems. At zero detuning, both polaritons equally incorporate contributions from the plasmon and the exciton. In a system with δ>0, the UPB primarily exhibits plasmon-like characteristics, while the LPB predominantly manifests excitonic attributes. Conversely, in a system with δ<0, there is a reversal in the composition of polaritons. The fit to the spectral width of the UPB and LPB using Eq. (3) is shown in Figs. 5(e) and 5(f). It is worth noting that the spectral widths of the UPB in the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NCs and WS2-Au NCs exceed that of LPB by 2 and 10 meV at zero detuning, respectively. In particular, the incoherent coupling strengths (γxp=1meV) of WS2/Gr vdWhs are found to be three times lower than the previously reported optimal results in plasmon–exciton hybrid systems[3,2224]. Therefore, the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NCs coupled system significantly reduces incoherent coupling strength while preserving coherent energy exchange in strong coupling for two reasons: (i) the narrower exciton linewidth and (ii) the modest coupling strength between the tilted electric dipole and the in-plane exciton.

    To evaluate the exciton number evolved in the strong coupling, the coupling strength can be expressed as ΩR=μ04πNcλεε0V,where N, V, λ, and ε are the effective exciton numbers participating in the coupling, mode volume, exciton wavelength, and relative dielectric function, respectively. The transition dipole moment value of monolayer WS2 was taken from Ref. [21], i.e., μ0=7.53D. The coupling strength of WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC is determined to be 60 meV when it undergoes strong coupling. Considering the effective mode volume of 7.04×103nm3, the exciton number is estimated to be N114 at resonance, which is much smaller than that in monolayer WS2-Au NC (N1036). As a result, the WS2/Gr vdWhs-Au NC coupled system facilitates coherent coupling between a reduced number of excitons and a plasmonic dipole mode, achieved by effectively suppressing the incoherent coupling strengths. The reduction in the exciton number can enhance the response speed of optical modulation and improve the fidelity and coherence time of quantum gates, making it highly favorable for quantum computing and communication technologies[46,47].

    4. Conclusion

    In conclusion, we have proposed a coherent plasmon–exciton coupling system consisting of the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs and the Au NCs. The defect-free lattices and smooth surface of Gr effectively suppress the nonradiative pathways of neutral excitons in WS2/Gr vdWhs, resulting in a narrower PL linewidth of 20 meV compared with monolayer WS2 (64 meV). By integrating the Au NC with the monolayer WS2/Gr vdWhs, we have demonstrated strong coupling between the in-plane neutral exciton and a tilted plasmonic dipole. Simultaneously, coherence is preserved by suppressing the photon exchange between the two subsystems through the continuum reservoir. The coupled system has not only achieved a large Rabi splitting energy of 120 meV but also ensured an exceptionally low incoherent coupling strength of 1 meV. Our results open up an avenue to maintain high coherence in coupled systems and hold promise for enhancing the performance of novel quantum nanophotonic devices.

    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Liping Hou, Qifa Wang, Huan Luo, Chenyang Li, Xuetao Gan, Fajun Xiao, Jianlin Zhao, "Coherent coupling in a WS2/graphene van der Waals heterostructure integrated with an Au nanoantenna," Chin. Opt. Lett. 23, 043601 (2025)

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Nanophotonics, Metamaterials, and Plasmonics

    Received: Jul. 17, 2024

    Accepted: Oct. 9, 2024

    Published Online: Apr. 10, 2025

    The Author Email: Xuetao Gan (xuetaogan@nwpu.edu.cn), Fajun Xiao (fjxiao@nwpu.edu.cn), Jianlin Zhao (jlzhao@nwpu.edu.cn)

    DOI:10.3788/COL202523.043601

    CSTR:32184.14.COL202523.043601

    Topics