The discoveries of the quantum Hall effect (QHE)[
Chinese Physics B, Volume. 29, Issue 10, (2020)
Acoustic topological phase transition induced by band inversion of high-order compound modes and robust pseudospin-dependent transport
A simple two-dimensional phononic crystal hosting topologically protected edge states is proposed to emulate the quantum spin Hall effect in electronic systems, whose phononic topological phase can be reconfigured through the rotation of scatters. In particular, the band inversion occurs between two pairs of high-order compound states, resulting in topological phase transition from trivial to nontrivial over a relatively broad high-frequency range. This is further evidenced by an effective Hamiltonian derived by the k ? p perturbation theory. The phononic topology is related to a pseudo-time-reversal symmetry constructed by the point group symmetry of two doubly degenerate eigenstates. Numerical simulations unambiguously demonstrate robust helical edge states whose pseudospin indices are locked to the propagation direction along the interface between topologically trivial and nontrivial phononic crystals. Our designed phononic systems provide potential applications in robust acoustic signal transport along any desired path over a high-frequency range.
1. Introduction
The discoveries of the quantum Hall effect (QHE)[
In order to obtain pseudospin-dependent edge states in the phononic crystals with double Dirac cones, the vast majority of previous studies generally take advantage of the band inversion between the pseudospin dipoles and quadrupoles to generate the topological phase transition from trivial to nontrivial. By fine adjusting the filling ratio or material parameters of the scatterers, trivial and nontrival bandgaps share a common but relatively narrow low-frequency range. In this paper, we design a 2D triangular phononic crystal consisting of anisotropic scatterers and propose a rotating-scatterer mechanism to realize band inversion between two pairs of doubly degenerate compound states in high-frequency range. More specifically, snowflake-like scatters are used to engineer a metamolecular crystal for intriguing band structures by simply rotating the scatters. In the rotational process, four-fold accidental degeneracy of higher-order compound modes appears at the BZ center, together with an acoustic quantum spin Hall phase transition. It is worth mentioning that the common bandgap of the topologically trivial and nontrivial phases is remarkably broad and possesses high frequencies. Based on the rotational symmetry of the primitive cell, we propose a pseudo-TR symmetry, which behaves in the same way as TR symmetry in electronic systems and renders the Kramers doublet in our designed phononic system. Furthermore, an effective Hamiltonian is developed to unveil the intrinsic link between the band inversion and the topological phase transition. Numerical simulations unambiguously demonstrate the backscattering-immune edge states that exist at the interface between two phononic crystals with different topological phases.
2. Triangular acoustic system
As depicted in Fig. 1, the snowflake-like metamolecule is constituted of one cylindrical rod and six three-legged rods. The 2D phononic crystal constructed by us possesses a triangular-lattice structure consisting of the snowflake-like metamolecules immersed in an air host. All the rods are made out of iron having mass density α = 7670 kg/m3, longitudinal wave velocity c = 6010 m/s, and shear wave velocity ct = 3231 m/s. The background medium has mass density ρ0 = 1.21 kg/m3 and speed of sound c0 = 343 m/s. We consider the following geometrical parameters: the width of the legs h = 0.03a, the length of the legs d = 0.135a, the radius of the cylindrical rods r = 0.1a, and the distance between the centers of cylindrical rods to the centers of three-legged rods R = 0.27a, with a being the lattice constant. Throughout this paper, the aforementioned geometrical parameters, i.e., the sizes of iron rods, are held constant. The orientation of the three-legged scatters is decided by the angle θ with respect to the horizontal axis. It is easy to see that if θ = 0°, the phononic system has a C6v symmetry, including a six-fold rotational symmetry and six mirrors. By simply rotating the three-legged rods, the mirror symmetry of the primitive cell can be broken and a controllable bandgap with different topological phases can be achieved.
Figure 1.Schematic view of a triangular phononic crystal consisting of snowflake-like metamolecules. Red dashed hexagon indicates the primitive cell composed by one cylindrical iron rod and six three-legged iron rods embedded in an air host.
In our designed phononic crystals, due to the obvious distinction between the longitudinal wave velocity of iron and that of air, the shear wave modes inside the iron components do not alter the fundamental physics of the system and can be ignored.[
3. Band inversion and topological phase transition
To precisely explore the coupling physics between the center rod (marked as meta-atom A) and the six external rods (marked as meta-atom B) of the snowflake-like structure, we study the band structure and eigenstates for the proposed phononic crystal with the rotational angle θ = 23°, as shown in Fig. 2. It is observed that four doubly degenerate points (labeled as pA, dA, pAsB, and dAsB) emerge in the band structure at the Γ point. The corresponding eigenfields at the four points are illustrated in Fig. 2(b), which reveal that the eigenmodes of such phononic system contain the center modes (superscript A) and the external modes (superscript B). As discussed in Ref. [39], the four pairs of doubly degenerate eigenmodes can be classified into two types: singleton modes (pA and dA) and compound modes (pAsB and dAsB). The eigenmodes pA and dA can be identified as dipolar and quadrupolar resonance states in meta-atom A, respectively. The eigenmodes pAsB combine dipolar states in meta-atom A with monopolar states in meta-atom B. And the eigenmodes dAsB correspond to quadrupolar states in meta-atom A and monopolar states in meta-atom B. It is worth noting that in meta-atom A, a pair of dipolar modes are accompanied by a pair of quadrupolar modes, and the dipoles possess opposite symmetry along the axes x and y of the primitive cell, whereas the quadrupoles obey identical symmetry along the axes x and y. Here we use σx,y = +1, –1 to represent even or odd symmetry along the axe x or y, respectively. For the two compound modes pAsB, one obeys symmetry σx/σy = –1/+1 and is named px mode, and the other obeys σx/σy = +1/–1 and is named py mode. For the two compound modes dAsB, one obeys symmetry σx/σy = +1/+1 and is named dx2 – y2 mode, and the other obeys σx/σy = –1/–1 and is named dxy mode. By utilizing the eigenmodes pA and dA, topologically nontrivial bandgap has been achieved in many researches, but the bandgap is relatively narrow and has low frequencies.[
Figure 2.(a) Band structure for the triangular phononic crystal with rotational angle
As shown in Fig. 3(a), two double degeneracies, one for the lower bands including the modes pAsB and the other for the upper bands containing the modes dAsB, appear at the BZ center for θ = 15°. Besides, with the increase of the rotational angle θ, the bandgap gradually decreases, the states pAsB and dAsB become degenerate at the Γ point for θ = 24.85°, and a double Dirac cone induced by four-fold accidental degeneracy is obtained as illustrated in Fig. 3(b). By further increasing the rotational angle θ, the four-fold degeneracy is destroyed and a phononic bandgap is reopened near the double Dirac point as shown in Fig. 3(c) for θ = 35°. The corresponding pressure field distributions of the doubly degenerate eigenmodes at the BZ center are exhibited in Fig. 3(e). It can be seen that the pressure fields at the lower-frequency side of the bandgap present dAsB feature, those at the higher-frequency side of the bandgap display pAsB feature. Namely, a band inversion is generated by rotating the three-legged rods, resulting in a topological phase transition from trivial to nontrivial. The trivial and nontrivial phononic crystals share a broad omnidirectional bandgap from the dimensionless frequency 1.3475 to 1.5341, just as demonstrated by the gray dashed lines in Figs. 3(a)–3(c).
Figure 3.(a)–(c) Band structures for the triangular phononic crystals with different rotational angles: (a)
4. Theory analysis of the topological property
According to the group theory, there are two 2D irreducible representations E1 with basis functions (x,y) and E2 with basis functions (2xy,x2 – y2) at the Γ point of a triangular lattice. The representation E1 has odd parity respective to spatial inversion operation, coinciding with the symmetry of doubly degenerate modes pAsB. However, the representation E2 has even spatial parity, being consistent with the symmetry of doubly degenerate modes dAsB. Under the rotational operator with angle α, the matrix representation on basis (x,y) is
Based on the angular momenta of the wave function of pressure fields pAsB and dAsB, two pairs of pseudospin states are given by
On the basis (p+,p−), the pseudo-TR operator is described as
In order to further understand the topological property of the band inversion between the high-order compound psudospin states, we construct an effective Hamiltonian in the vicnity of the BZ center based on the k ⋅ p perturbation theory.[
Substituting Eq. (10) into Eq. (1) and utilizing the orthogonality relation of the four eigenfunctions Γβ (β = 1,2,3,4), we obtain the effective Hamiltonian around the Γ point
5. Topologically protected edge staes
Since the topologies for the phononic crystals shown in Figs. 3(a) and 3(c) are different, there will be unidirectional acoustic edge states at the interface separating these two systems. To validate the existence of these topologically protected edge states, we numerically calculate the projected band structure for a ribbon-shaped supercell, which comprises topologically nontrivial crystal after band inversion and topologically trivial crystal before band inversion, as shown in Fig. 4(a). By applying the periodic boundary condition on the x and y directions, we obtain the projected band structure as displayed in Fig. 4(b). It is found that in addition to the bulk states denoted by black dotted lines, there are doubly degenerate states spanning the bulk bandgap region, which are represented by red dotted lines. After checking the pressure field distributions for the eigenstates at points E and F in Fig. 4(b), we discover that the pressure fields tightly localize at the interface and decay exponentially into bulk crystals on both sides. This means that the red dotted lines represent the dispersion relations of the edge states. Figures 4(c) and 4(d) present the real-space distributions of the pressure and time-averaged intensity fields on the upper interface at typical momenta with
Figure 4.(a) Schematic view of a ribbon-shaped supercell composed of the topologically nontrivial crystal (
As discussed in the previous section, it is possible for us to take advantage of the pseudospin Hall effect to realize acoustic helical edge states, i.e., utilizing the pseudospin DOF to control the propagation direction. The pseudospin specified edge states can be selectively excited by a point-like chiral source, which is an eight-antenna array with a π/4 phase delay between the neighboring ones as shown in Fig. 5(a). When the phases of these antennas gradually decrease clockwise (anticlockwise), the pseudospin-down (pseudospin-up) mode can be stimulated. Figures 5(b) and 5(c) display the pressure field distributions excited by the point-like chiral sources with clockwise and anticlockwise phase delays, respectively, in the air. In order to demonstrate the unidirectional propagation and robustness against perturbations of the pseudospin-dependent edge states, we combine the topologically trivial crystal with nontrivial crystal to construct a Z-shaped interface. As shown in Figs. 5(d) and 5(e), a point-like source with operating frequency f ≈ 1.4027c0/a, which corresponds to the frequency of the E and F points in Fig. 4(b), is placed at the location indicated by white circle. We observe that when the source has a clockwise phase delay, the acoustic wave propagates along the Z-shaped interface towards the upper left direction, manifesting the pseudospin-down edge state. On the contrary, the acoustic wave excited by the point-like source with anticlockwise phase delay propagates along the Z-shaped interface towards the lower right direction, revealing the pseudospin-up edge state. Besides, the simulated results also make clear that even though sharp bends are introduced at the interface, these pseudospin-dependent edge states robustly propagate along the Z-shaped interface without backscattering. It is evident that based on the pseudospin Hall effect induced by band inversion, we can manipulate acoustic waves to propagate along a selected path and direction without resorting to breaking the TRS.
Figure 5.(a) Schematic view of a point-like chiral source consisting of eight antennas, which has a phase difference of
6. Conclusion
We have designed a 2D acoustic topological insulator analogous to the QSHE in electronic systems. The topological insulator is a triangular phononic crystal consisting of snowflake-like metamolecules embedded in an air host. By rotating the three-legged rods within the primitive cell, band inversion is achieved between two pairs of high-order compound modes (i.e., doubly degenerate modes pAsB and dAsB), and a noticeable topological bulk bandgap is obtained in the high-frequency range. Based on the point group symmetry of pAsB and dAsB eigenstates at the Γ point, we construct a pseudo-TR symmetry, which renders the Kramers doublet of acoustic pseudospins. By utilizing k ⋅ p perturbation theory, we propose an effective Hamiltonian around the Γ point, which unveils that the band inversion induces a topological phase transition from trivial to nontrivial. Numerical simulations explicitly manifest the unidirectional propagation and backscattering-immune property of the pseudospin-dependent edge states. The topological phononic crystal designed by us can be fabricated relatively easily, and its topological phase can be reconfigured just by simply changing the orientation of the three-legged rods. This is extremely advantageous for the potential applications in controlling acoustic waves along any desired path without backscattering. And the mechanism of band inversion between high-order compound states can be directly extended to electromagnetic wave systems.
[1] K v Klitzing, G Dorda, M Pepper. Phys. Rev. Lett., 45, 494(1980).
[2] C L Kane, E J Mele. Phys. Rev. Lett., 95(2005).
[3] B A Bernevig, T L Hughes, S C Zhang. Science, 314, 1757(2006).
[4] M Z Hasan, C L Kane. Rev. Mod. Phys., 82, 3045(2010).
[5] X L Qi, S C Zhang. Rev. Mod. Phys., 83, 1057(2011).
[6] F D Haldane, S Raghu. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100(2008).
[7] Z Wang, Y D Chong, J D Joannopoulos, M Soljačić. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100(2008).
[8] K X Liu, L F Shen, S L He. Opt. Lett., 37, 4110(2012).
[9] W J Chen, S J Jiang, X D Chen, B Zhu, L Zhou, J W Dong, C T Chan. Nat. Commun., 5, 5782(2014).
[10] Y Chen, Z K Lin, H Y Chen, J H Jiang. Phys. Rev. B, 101(2020).
[11] L H Wu, X Hu. Phys. Rev. Lett., 114(2015).
[12] Y T Yang, Y F Xu, T Xu, H X Wang, J H Jiang, X Hu, Z H Hang. Phys. Rev. Lett., 120(2018).
[13] A B Khanikaev, R Fleury, S H Mousavi, A Alù. Nat. Commun., 6, 8260(2015).
[14] Z J Yang, F Gao, X H Shi, X Lin, Z Gao, Y D Chong, B L Zhang. Phys. Rev. Lett., 114(2015).
[15] Y J Ding, Y G Peng, Y F Zhu, X D Fan, J Yang, B Liang, X F Zhu, X G Wan, J C Cheng. Phys. Rev. Lett., 122(2019).
[16] Y G Peng, C Z Qin, D G Zhao, Y X Shen, X Y Xu, M Bao, H Jia, X F Zhu. Nat. Commun., 7(2016).
[17] C He, Z Li, X Ni, X C Sun, S Y Yu, M H Lu, X P Liu, Y F Chen. Appl. Phys. Lett., 108(2016).
[18] J Mei, Z G Chen, Y Wu. Sci. Rep., 6(2016).
[19] C He, X Ni, H Ge, X C Sun, Y B Chen, M H Lu, X P Liu, Y F Chen. Nat. Phys., 12, 1124(2016).
[20] B Z Xia, T T Liu, G L Huang, H Q Dai, J R Jiao, X G Zang, D J Yu, S J Zheng, J Liu. Phys. Rev. B, 96(2017).
[21] Z W Zhang, Y Tian, Y Cheng, X J Liu, J Christensen. Phys. Rev. B, 96(2017).
[22] Y C Deng, H Ge, Y Tian, M H Lu, Y Jing. Phys. Rev. B, 96(2017).
[23] B Y Xie, H Liu, H Cheng, Z Y Liu, S Q Chen, J G Tian. Phys. Rev. Appl., 11(2019).
[24] B Z Xia, S J Zheng, T T Liu, J R Jiao, N Chen, H Q Dai, D J Yu, J Liu. Phys. Rev. B, 97(2018).
[25] J Y Lu, C Y Qiu, W Y Deng, X Q Huang, F Li, F Zhang, S Q Chen, Z Y Liu. Phys. Rev. Lett., 120(2018).
[26] Z W Zhang, Y Tian, Y H Wang, S X Gao, Y Cheng, X J Liu, J Christensen. Adv. Mater., 30(2018).
[27] Z H Tian, C Shen, J F Li, E Reit, H Bachman, J E S Socolar, S A Cummer, T J Huang. Nat. Commun., 11, 762(2020).
[28] Y C Deng, M H Lu, Y Jing. J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 146, 721(2019).
[29] L M Nash, D Kleckner, A Read, V Vitelli, A M Turner, W T M Irvine. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 112(2015).
[30] P Wang, L Lu, K Bertoldi. Phys. Rev. Lett., 115(2015).
[31] R Süsstrunk, S D Huber. Science, 349, 47(2015).
[32] S H Mousavi, A B Khanikaev, Z Wang. Nat. Commun., 6, 8682(2015).
[33] S Y Yu, C He, Z Wang, F K Liu, X C Sun, Z Li, H Z Lu, M H Lu, X P Liu, Y F Chen. Nat. Commun., 9, 3072(2018).
[34] Z LiuY, C S Lian, Y Li, Y Xu, W H Duan. Phys. Rev. Lett., 119(2017).
[35] L Tong, H Y Fan, B Z Xia. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 53(2020).
[36] H B Huang, Z H Tan, S Y Huo, L Y Feng, J J Chen, X Han. Commun. Phys., 3, 46(2020).
[37] S F Li, D G Zhao, H Niu, X F Zhu, J F Zang. Nat. Commun., 9, 1370(2018).
[38] M Kafesaki, E N Economou. Phys. Rev. B, 60(1999).
[39] Y Chen, L Xu, G X Cai, H Y Chen. Phys. Rev. B, 98(2018).
[40] Y Li, Y Wu, X Chen, J Mei. Opt. Express, 21, 7699(2013).
[41] J Mei, Y Wu, C T Chan, Z Q Zhang. Phys. Rev. B, 86(2012).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Yan Li, Yi-Nuo Liu, Xia Zhang. Acoustic topological phase transition induced by band inversion of high-order compound modes and robust pseudospin-dependent transport[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2020, 29(10):
Received: Jul. 2, 2020
Accepted: --
Published Online: Apr. 21, 2021
The Author Email: Yan Li (liyanQFNU@163.com)