Shock waves are some of the most interesting and prevalent phenomena in astrophysics. They are ubiquitous throughout the universe and their role in the transport of energy into the interstellar medium is fundamental[
High Power Laser Science and Engineering, Volume. 6, Issue 2, 02000e36(2018)
Analysis of microscopic properties of radiative shock experiments performed at the Orion laser facility
In this work we have conducted a study on the radiative and spectroscopic properties of the radiative precursor and the post-shock region from experiments with radiative shocks in xenon performed at the Orion laser facility. The study is based on post-processing of radiation-hydrodynamics simulations of the experiment. In particular, we have analyzed the thermodynamic regime of the plasma, the charge state distributions, the monochromatic opacities and emissivities, and the specific intensities for plasma conditions of both regions. The study of the intensities is a useful tool to estimate ranges of electron temperatures present in the xenon plasma in these experiments and the analysis performed of the microscopic properties commented above helps to better understand the intensity spectra. Finally, a theoretical analysis of the possibility of the onset of isobaric thermal instabilities in the post-shock has been made, concluding that the instabilities obtained in the radiative-hydrodynamic simulations could be thermal ones due to strong radiative cooling.
1 Introduction
Shock waves are some of the most interesting and prevalent phenomena in astrophysics. They are ubiquitous throughout the universe and their role in the transport of energy into the interstellar medium is fundamental[
The possibility of scaling the magnetohydrodynamics equations between astrophysics and laboratory flows[
Sign up for High Power Laser Science and Engineering TOC Get the latest issue of High Power Laser Science and Engineering delivered right to you!Sign up now
New experiments have been recently performed to investigate the collision and interaction of two counter-propagating piston-driven radiative shocks[
The main objective of this work is to provide a description of microscopic properties of the plasmas generated in the experiments described above. We have therefore performed numerical simulations of the atomic and radiative properties of the post-shock and radiative precursor regions of radiative shocks in xenon. For this purpose, the plasma conditions (mass densities and electron temperatures) used in the microscopic simulations were provided by the radiation-hydrodynamics (rad-hydro) simulations performed with the NYM and PETRA codes. In particular, we have studied the thermodynamic regime of the plasma in both the post-shock and radiative precursor regions, the monochromatic opacities and emissivities, and the charge state distributions (CSDs) for times prior to the shocks collision as after this time the xenon mixes with the piston material (plastic and bromine). An analysis of the specific intensities of the radiation emitted by the plasma of both regions at early times was made, when the interaction between the shocks and the radiative precursors is weak and the spectra are due to a single shock. However, some of the results obtained could also be useful in analyzing the spectra at later times when the radiative precursors interact. The analysis of the intensities may also be helpful for future experiments in assessing whether an experimental capability (such as emission spectroscopy) would be useful. Finally, the radiation-hydrodynamics simulations predicted hydrodynamic instabilities that could be due to the strong cooling of the radiative shocks. For this reason, a theoretical analysis of the possibility of the onset of thermal instabilities in these experiments has been carried out.
This paper is structured as follows. Section
2 Theoretical model
The calculation of plasma radiative and spectroscopic properties requires the use of atomic data, such as energy levels, oscillator strengths, cross-sections and atomic-level populations. The following section briefly describes the models used in this work to calculate these values.
2.1 Atomic data
The oscillator strengths, energy levels and photoionization cross-sections were calculated using FAC code[
The selection of the atomic configurations for population kinetics simulations is a key factor but still an open question, overall for complex elements like xenon with a large number of electrons. In this work, we have included configurations with energies up to three times the ionization potential. This choice should be adequate for accurate modeling of thermal plasmas[
According to this criterion, the following configurations were included: (1) ground configuration; (2) single excited configuration from the valence shell, , to shells with
; (3) doubly excited configurations from the valence shell to shells with
; and (4) single excited configurations from shell
to shells with
.
2.2 Determination of plasma atomic-level populations
For high densities, when the plasma reaches local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), the population of the ionization stages, , is obtained from the Saha equation given by
For arbitrary densities, the atomic-level populations can be determined from the solution of a system of collisional-radiative (CR) rate equations. This set of kinetic equations is given by
The set of rates equations in the CR model is coupled to the radiative transfer equation
The CR model as well as the Saha–Boltzmann (SB) equations used in this work is implemented in the MIXKIP code[
Once the rate or SB equations (Equations (
2.3 Calculation of radiative properties
To calculate the radiative properties, we have used the RAPCAL code[ and
, respectively), include bound–bound, bound-free and free–free contributions. In this work, the complete redistribution hypothesis was assumed for the line profile in the bound–bound transitions. This includes natural, Doppler, UTA and electron impact[
3 Description of the experimental setup and radiation-hydrodynamics simulations
The experiments[ bar
. Plastic discs were attached to opposite octagonal faces, separated by 4 mm, which acted as pistons. Shocks were driven by focusing four laser beams (each beam
,
, 1 ns pulse duration) onto each piston (laser intensity
). These experiments were diagnosed with point projection X-ray backlighting (XRBL) and laser optical interferometry. XRBL provided information about the post-shock region. For the radiative precursor, laser interferometry was used to measure the free electron density along the probe beam path. The large xenon volume used in the experiments resulted in shocks with quasi-spherical geometry. A collision between the two shocks occurred after
followed by the formation of reverse shocks. The XRBL images indicated a shock velocity of around
and a reverse shock velocity of around 30 km/s. Figure
2D rad-hydro simulations were performed using then NYM and PETRA codes. NYM is a Lagrangian code with multigroup implicit Monte Carlo X-ray transport and full laser-interaction physics. This code was, therefore, used to model the laser–piston interaction. The simulations provided by the NYM code were linked to the Eulerian code PETRA which used multigroup X-ray diffusion to study the late time plasma behavior (after ). The collision of the counter-propagating shocks was simulated assuming a fully reflective boundary (for hydrodynamics and radiation) at the center of the diagnostic window (at a distance of 2 mm from the position of the pistons) both for the plasma flow and for the radiation. In general, the simulations accurately reproduced the overall shock dynamics[
4 Results
4.1 Analysis of the radiative precursor
Figure and 16 ns obtained from 2D rad-hydro simulations. For the latter, the profile of the electron densities is also presented. The shock front is located at the highest temperature and ahead of the shock front a radiative precursor is observed. Simulations suggest that temperatures in the radiative precursor range from
to 20 eV at 8 ns. As time progresses, the lowest temperatures in the radiative precursor increase (maybe due to the proximity of the other shock and the overlapping of the two radiative precursors), as shown in Figure
Figure . However, the characteristic time of the dominant atomic processes (electron–ion collisions) in the plasma,
, is given by[
The CSDs were also calculated assuming LTE, that is, through the SB equations (Equation ( ions at temperatures around 15 eV (although these differences are lower than 5%) and become more noticeable at 18 eV. At this temperature, the LTE model predicts that the most abundant ion is
with an average ionization of
while the NLTE model predicts the most abundant ion as
with an average ionization of
. Therefore, the LTE approach is accurate enough for the calculation of the average ionization and CSDs for temperatures lower than 18 eV, with slight differences at higher temperatures.
The range of electron densities obtained from the CRSS simulations in the radiative precursor varies from at 2 eV to
at 20 eV, obtaining similar results to the ones provided by the radiation-hydrodynamics simulations, which use SESAME tables for the opacities and equations of state. For example, the electron densities obtained with the atomic kinetic model at
and 20 eV were
,
and
, respectively, whereas those obtained with the macroscopic simulation at 8 ns were
,
and
, respectively, with relative differences lower than
between both simulations. Since the temperatures used in the CRSS simulations are those provided by the rad-hydro simulations, the agreement between the electron densities obtained indicates that kinetic atomic models implemented in both simulations should provide similar values of the average ionization.
The electron densities of a region of the radiative precursor were experimentally obtained at 18 ns by means of laser interferometry[ to
. As the mass density in the precursor does not change significantly from the initial density of the xenon gas fill, the average ionization can be determined. Using the mass density as an input, the CRSS model was used to determine the electron temperatures that provide similar average ionizations and electron densities to the experimental ones. This yielded temperatures from 4.20 to 6.50 eV for the radiative precursor. For that region of the radiative precursor, the hydrodynamic simulations predicted values of the electron densities from
to
and electron temperatures from
to 7.17 eV. These 2D simulations slightly overestimate the values of the electron density with respect to the experimental ones and, therefore, the electron temperatures as well[
Although the electron densities reached in the radiative precursor are not particularly high, the surrounding plasma, modeled by the inclusion of the CL in the population calculation, introduces some differences in the CSDs since the electron temperatures were also low. Thus, for example, at 12 eV, the most relevant ions obtained with the simulation including the CL were , whereas the ones obtained with the simulation for the isolated situation were
. This could lead to noticeable changes in the calculation of the spectra. Therefore, the effect of the plasma surrounding must be considered in the atomic kinetic calculations for these ranges of electron temperatures and densities.
In the experiments[
Figure and 10 eV are quite different. Analysis of the CSDs (Figure
. The CSD at 10 eV shows that the ions species in the plasma are
although the abundance of
and
ions are minor compared to the other ions. Therefore, none of the relevant ions at 4 eV are at 10 eV. This fact explains the significant differences between both spectra. The bound–bound contribution at 4 eV is practically contained in photon energies between 0–30 eV which are associated with single electron transitions from
and
subshells. For photons with higher energies the main contribution is bound-free. At a temperature of 10 eV an absorption structure in the photon energy range 0–30 eV is present and primarily due to electron transitions in the same shell
of
ions. Another two significant absorption features are present for a temperature of 10 eV. The first one located around a photon energy of 60 eV is primarily due to electron transitions from
to higher shells in
ion. For the other two ions present, the transitions involved are those between
and
subshells. The second absorption feature is around 90 eV. In this case, the most relevant transitions are the ones between the
and
and between the
and
subshells. Therefore, from this analysis it is clear that the bound–bound absorption at electron temperatures of
and 10 eV is basically restricted to the UV and XUV ranges.
According to Figure and 20 eV are
and
ions, respectively. Because of the similarity between them, the absorption structures should be quite similar in the monochromatic opacities at both temperatures, as Figure
ion, is present at 16 eV but not at 20 eV. For these two temperatures significant absorption structures in the range 0–30 eV were not obtained on account of the ionization degrees as these temperatures are larger than at
and 10 eV. We can also observe that the monochromatic opacities for the two highest temperatures have richer line spectra than the ones for the other two lower temperatures due to a stronger involvement of the
shell. The figure shows that the monochromatic opacities have a strong absorption feature in the energy range 70–85 eV. For the
ion, the main transitions involved at these energies are the ones from configurations
to
configurations. However, similar transitions from configuration
for
ion are shifted to higher photon energies (around 90–100 eV) and, therefore, this ion does not have a relevant contribution to that absorption feature at photon energies around 70–85 eV in the opacity at a temperature 20 eV. Line transitions are detected in the energy ranges 100–160 and 190–250 eV in which transitions to configurations with higher principal quantum number and also from
and
subshells are involved. Therefore, at the temperatures of
and 20 eV there is noticeable absorption of XUV.
As previously discussed, spectroscopic diagnostics is a useful tool for obtaining information about the plasma conditions. Typically, shell spectrum is commonly used to derive plasma conditions[
shell spectrum is less useful. Under the conditions analyzed in this work, the ionization degree of xenon is low, both in the radiative precursor and in the post-shock regions, and the ions present in the plasma are those from
to
, which means that
and
shells participate in the spectra. These shells contribute considerably more complex spectra than
shell, and so only permit estimations of ranges of electron temperatures in the plasma. The method consists in analyzing the presence of the contribution of certain ions to the spectra, taking into account the temperature sensitivity of xenon in this range of plasma conditions. Thus, the specific intensities emitted by the radiative precursor were calculated at different temperatures. Assuming stationary situation for the radiation in Equation (
must be transported through the layers that lie ahead and the specific intensity of that radiation along the ray is given by
In Figure (indicated in Figure
The analysis of the intensities and
(Figure
. From the analysis of
we can detect that Layer
strongly absorbs in the photon energy range 0–40 eV. This absorption is rather important between 15–20 eV as we can see from the purple curve in Figure
and
.
Figure in the monochromatic opacity observed in Figure
Figure
In order to analyze the effect of the resolution of a hypothetical spectrometer on the calculated spectra, simulations of the theoretical spectra convolved with the resolution of the XUV grating spectrometer of Orion[. Due to this high resolution, and that the xenon ions involved in these experiments have a large number of bound electrons (which produce unresolved structures in the spectra), the effect of the spectrometer on the theoretical spectra was not noticeable.
4.2 Analysis of the post-shock medium
Rad-hydro simulations indicate that the mass densities in the post-shock region ranged from (with electron densities around
). The maximum electron temperatures are higher than 25 eV at 8 and 12 ns whereas they are lower at later times. A peak electron temperature of
was reached at 8 ns and that time was selected for the analysis performed in this section. The CSDs for plasma conditions in the post-shock medium of the maximum and minimum temperatures, respectively, are plotted in Figure
The effect of the increase in mass density on the average ionization is evident when comparing Figures , while for the post-shock medium they are
(i.e., the same ions that dominate at 10 eV in the radiative precursor) because of the increase in recombination. Another effect of the increase in mass density is a widening of the line transitions in the spectra due to the increase of the collisional broadening which leads to a large line overlapping. This is illustrated in Figure
The specific intensity of the radiation emitted by the post-shock medium at 8 ns was also analyzed. The width of the shocked medium at this time is relatively small, , and so, the absorption in this region is smaller than seen in the radiative precursor. To calculate the intensity of radiation emitted by the post-shock region this was divided in three layers of
of average electron temperatures
and 18.22 eV and mass densities of
,
and
, respectively. They correspond to the largest and lowest temperatures in the post-shock medium and also an intermediate one. The outgoing radiation was then transported through the radiative precursor assuming its structure is similar to that shown in Figure
and calculated as
in Equation (
(obtained as
in Equation (
Figure , consists of two peaks at photon energies around
and 100 eV that have been broadened due to high mass densities. This has resulted in lines overlapping leading to broadened peaks and a reduction in the depths of the valleys. The absorption of Layer 1 of the radiative precursor (at a temperature of 20 eV) shows peaks at photon energies of around 75 eV and 90–105 eV (see
in the Figure), which agrees with the stronger peaks detected in its monochromatic opacity (see Figure
With respect to the total specific intensity, the absorption in the photon energy range 0–60 eV is due to Layers 3 and 4 of the radiative precursor. For photon energies higher than 110 eV the spectrum has a larger contribution of the post-shock medium than that of the radiative precursor and there are not detailed lines. This lack of detailed lines provides information about the range of densities that can be found in the post-shock medium. Similar emission features are observed in the total intensity, in the energy range 60–110 eV, to those found in the intensity of Layer 1 in the radiative precursor, although more broadened. This is due to CSDs in the post-shock medium being quite similar to the radiative precursor layers at and 16 eV. This is because the difference in electron temperatures between the shock and the radiative precursor is not too large and recombination occurs in the post-shock plasma.
For times later than 16 ns the hydrodynamic simulations show a double peak in post-shock medium. Furthermore, the simulations also show the shock front as a rippled layer (see Figures
Thermal instabilities can be classified by comparing the length scale of the initial seeding perturbation and a characteristic scale of the medium, which is the sound crossing length, , given as
For the range of plasma temperatures in the post-shock medium at times later than 18 ns (22–15 eV) the sound crossing lengths were calculated to be . For perturbations whose lengths are comparable to the sound crossing length, the pressure will be constant and the thermal instabilities are classified as isobaric[
5 Conclusions
In this work we have analyzed the radiative and spectroscopic properties of both the radiative precursor and the post-shock medium of radiative shocks driven into xenon by a piston ablated by the Orion high-power laser. The plasma conditions used for the microscopic simulations were extracted from radiation-hydrodynamics simulations. From the analysis of the thermodynamic regime, we have concluded that the xenon plasma, both in the radiative precursor and the post-shock regions, could be assumed to be in LTE. The CSDs were calculated for plasma conditions achieved in the experiments, yielding a maximum average ionization of . This relatively low ionization implies that xenon ions with a large number of bound electrons are present in the plasma which results in complex spectra. The effect of the surrounding plasma on the ion populations was studied, including the CL in the CRSS simulations. The electron densities achieved in the radiative precursor are not too large, but since the electron temperatures are relatively low, plasma effects should still be considered. These effects are more noticeable in the post-shock medium since the mass density is considerably larger than in the radiative precursor whereas the temperatures are similar in the two regions. Furthermore, the CSDs in the post-shock medium are quite similar to those obtained in the radiative precursor, even though the temperatures in the latter can be lower, due to the increased recombination in the post-shock medium. The monochromatic opacities for several characteristic temperatures found in the radiative precursor were analyzed since the outgoing radiation of the plasma can be transported through this region before reaching a detector. This analysis allowed the plasma absorption to be characterized in terms of temperature, which helps to study the plasma spectra.
The specific intensities of radiation emitted by the radiative precursor and the post-shock medium were also analyzed. For the range of plasma temperatures reached in these experiments, the absorption and emission spectra are in the UV and XUV ranges of photon energies. For the analysis of the intensity, the analysis of the CSDs and the monochromatic opacities and emissivities carried out in this work were very helpful. We have determined that some structures detected in the spectra allow the ranges of plasma temperatures to be predicted, which are associated with ions present in the plasma. However, for the range of electron temperatures 15–20 eV, the CSDs are similar and thus it is difficult to distinguish contributions from different temperatures in that range of temperatures. Therefore, from the spectra we could only conclude that there are regions in the plasma with temperatures in the range 15–20 eV. On the other hand, due to the strong dependence of the first charge states of xenon on temperature, it is easier to distinguish contributions from different temperatures in the range 2–10 eV.
We have also analyzed the intensity of radiation emitted by the post-shock medium. Since the mass density is considerably higher than in the radiative precursor, lines are collisionally broadened, resulting in lines overlapping, and individual lines cannot be identified. This could allow us to estimate the plasma density in the post-shock medium.
Finally, a theoretical analysis of the isobaric thermal instability was made in order to explain the instabilities observed in rad-hydro simulations. Since the criterion of this instability is fulfilled, this could be responsible for the double peaks and ripples observed in the simulations. However, confirmation would require both simulations with radiation turned off and experimental measurements of the length of the seeding perturbations.
[1] Y. B. Zel’dovich, Y. P. Raizer. Physics of Shock Waves and High-Temperature Hydrodynamic Phenomena(2002).
[6] A. C. Raga, G. Mellema, S. J. Arthur, L. Binette, P. Ferruit, W. Steffen. Rev. Mex. Astron. Astr., 35, 123(1999).
[7] E. Huguet, J. P. J. Lafon. Astron. Astrophys., 324, 1046(1997).
[21] S. Bouquet, C. Stéhle, M. Koenig, J. P. Chieze, A. Benuzzi-Mounaix, D. Batani, S. Leygnac, X. Fleury, H. Merdji, C. Michaut, F. Thais, N. Grandjouan, T. Hall, E. Henry, V. Malka, J. P. J. Lafon. Phys. Rev. Lett., 22, 056501(2004).
[41] R. Rodríguez, R. Florido, J. M. Gil, J. G. Rubiano, P. Martel, E. Mínguez. Laser Part. Beams, 26, 433(2008).
[42] M. S. Dimitrijevic, N. Konjevin. Astron. Astrophys., 172, 345(1987).
[44] D. Salzmann. Atomic Physics in Hot Plasmas(1998).
[48] Yu. A. Shchekinov. Sov. Astron., 22, 182(1978).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
R. Rodríguez, G. Espinosa, J. M. Gil, F. Suzuki-Vidal, T. Clayson, C. Stehlé, P. Graham. Analysis of microscopic properties of radiative shock experiments performed at the Orion laser facility[J]. High Power Laser Science and Engineering, 2018, 6(2): 02000e36
Received: Nov. 24, 2017
Accepted: Apr. 10, 2018
Published Online: Jul. 4, 2018
The Author Email: R. Rodríguez (rafael.rodriguezperez@ulpgc.es)