As a newly emerging catalysis, tribocatalysis is receiving more and more attention with regard to the criteria to fabricate or choose materials as catalysts for it. In this study, two different commercial silicon (Si) powders, Si30 and Si300, were adopted as catalysts in tribocatalytic degradation of organic dyes. Only round nanoparticles from 30 to 100nm were observed in Si30, while some highly large and irregular particles, as large as 1000nm × 500nm and with a roughly flat major surface, could be observed in Si300. Stimulated through magnetic stirring using Teflon magnetic rotary disks, as much as 95% of 20 mg/L rhodamine B (RhB) solution and 97% of 20 mg/L methyl orange (MO) solution were degraded by Si300 after 3h and 50min, respectively; while only 73% of RhB and 83% of MO were degraded by Si30 after 5h and 4h, respectively. EPR spectra showed that more superoxide and hydroxyl radicals were generated by Si300 under magnetic stirring. It is proposed that in those large particles in Si300, their large flat major surfaces dramatically enhance their absorption of mechanical energy through friction and there are much less lattice defects to hinder electrons and holes from diffusing to the surface, which both results in the contrasting tribocatalytic degradations of organic dyes between Si300 and Si30. These findings reveal a huge difference in tribocatalytic performance among different materials of the same composition.