Microwave photonics (MWPs) is an interdisciplinary field that studies the interaction between microwaves and lightwaves, combining in consequence the advantages brought by both areas [
Photonics Research, Volume. 2, Issue 4, B54(2014)
Microwave photonics: radio-over-fiber links, systems, and applications [Invited]
Microwave photonics (MWPs) uses the strength of photonic techniques to generate, process, control, and distribute microwave signals, combining the advantages of microwaves and photonics. As one of the main topics of MWP, radio-over-fiber (RoF) links can provide features that are very difficult or even impossible to achieve with traditional technologies. Meanwhile, a considerable number of signal-processing subsystems have been carried out in the field of MWP as they are instrumental for the implementation of many functionalities. However, there are still several challenges in strengthening the performance of the technology to support systems and applications with more complex structures, multiple functionality, larger bandwidth, and larger processing capability. In this paper, we identify some of the notable challenges in MWP and review our recent work. Applications and future direction of research are also discussed.
1. INTRODUCTION
Microwave photonics (MWPs) is an interdisciplinary field that studies the interaction between microwaves and lightwaves, combining in consequence the advantages brought by both areas [
Radio-over-fiber (RoF) is one of the main topics of MWP, providing features that are very difficult or even impossible to achieve with traditional technology. In its simplest form, a RoF link consists of a directly or externally modulated laser, where one or more analog electrical signal placed at different microwave frequencies is imposed on an optical carrier, and a detector after the optical fiber link, where the microwave signal is recovered from the optical carrier. The RoF concept has numerous applications, such as phased-array antennas and broadband wireless access networks. However, the nonlinearity of the link generates mixing products of the microwave carrier frequencies. The prominent problem is the third-order intermodulation distortion (IMD3) since it is in-band and cannot be filtered out. Therefore, the nonlinearity of the system must be kept small to obtain a high spurious-free dynamic range (SFDR). Besides, the environment perturbations such as physical vibrations and temperature fluctuations degrade the phase stability of the microwave frequency. Therefore, the phase error must be small to accomplish ultrastable microwave frequency delivery, which is useful in many modern metrology and fundamental physics applications, such as particle physics, relativity tests, and radio astronomy.
On the other hand, a considerable number of signal processing subsystems [
Sign up for Photonics Research TOC Get the latest issue of Advanced Photonics delivered right to you!Sign up now
In this paper, we identify some of the notable challenges in MWP and review our recent work in three main aspects: (1) high linearity conversion and control between lightwaves and microwaves in RoF links; (2) precise processing and handling of broadband microwave signals; and (3) efficient utilization and dynamic management of the resources in distributed antenna systems (DASs).
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The challenges are addressed and our corresponding work is reviewed in Section
2. CHALLENGES AND RECENT ADVANCES
A. High-Linearity Conversion and Control between the Lightwave and Microwave in RoF Links
Figure
Figure 1.Fundamental setup of externally modulated RoF link.
Besides, the capability to transfer the RF signal with stabilized phase to a remote location over the fiber link is also highly desired in many occasions, such as phased-array radar and connected-element interferometry applications. The advantages of an optical fiber link as a transmission medium make it the ideal solution for efficiently transporting radio signals from a central office to remotely located sites [
In this part, we discuss two methods for high-dynamic-range RoF links and highly stable RF delivery links, respectively.
1. High-Dynamic-Range RoF Links
To improve SFDR performance, numerous approaches have been demonstrated in recent years. The general design idea behind most of the aforementioned proposals is to introduce desired nonlinear distortions, which can be used to reduce the strength of the existing ones with the cost of increased system complexity. To overcome the challenge of linearity conversion, a linearization technique incorporating direct optical carrier band (OCB) processing has been investigated [
There are three pairs of main contributors for the IMD3. When a phase shift of arcos (
Figure 2.(a) Experimental arrangement for the IMD3 suppression in analog fiber-optic link employing OCB processing. Electrical spectra of the output fundamental signal and their IMD3s for (b) the conventional link without any processing in the optical domain and (c) the proposed link with OCB processing. (d) Two-tone measurement results for the compensated and uncompensated links. ESA, electrical spectrum analyzer.
So, we use a simple method to realize the linear conversion between the microwave and lightwave, by comprehensively investigating the main optical spectrum contributors of the IMD3 components in intensity-modulated directly detected analog fiber-optic links. The SFDR of the link is increased from
Besides the above online-processing method for improving the SFDR, we propose an advanced digital signal processing (DSP) technique to correct the nonideal characteristics and the phase ambiguity effect in the coherent receiver of a phase-modulation and coherent-detection RoF link to further increase its dynamic range [
In addition, there are other groups that make use of the highly linear RoF system. For example, researchers at the University of California, Los Angeles have proposed a digital algorithm that can achieve a 35 dB suppression of the IMD3 over multiple octaves of the signal bandwidth [
2. Highly Stable RF Delivery over Fiber Links
To realize the RF phase controlling, we propose and demonstrate a phase-compensation scheme that supports long-distance RF standard delivery over conventional fiber communication networks [
The proposed stable RF delivery scheme is shown in Fig.
Figure 3.(a) Experimental setup of the proposed phase error correction system. BPF: bandpass filter. (b) RMS jitter of the remote RF signal without (blue line) and with (red line) phase error correction. (c) SSB phase noise of the RF source and signal at the remote end.
Assume that the initial wavelength of the optical carrier is
Experimentally, we compare the phase delivery stability without and with the proposed fluctuation compensation. In the experiment, a 54 km single-mode fiber (SMF) is located at the laboratory. The output signal is observed by the sampling oscilloscope, which is trigged by the same 2.42 GHz reference at the center station. In the uncompensated delivery, the wavelength of the optical carrier is fixed at 1550 nm, while the other conditions remain the same as those in the compensated situation. The time jitter of the waveform is measured and shown in Fig.
Furthermore, in cooperation with Beijing Aerospace Control Center, we have successfully used our broadband, multifrequency stabilized RF delivery link in the phase-based radiometric system in lunar radio measurement with Chang’E-3 satellite.
B. Fine Processing and Handling of Broadband Microwave Signals
Broadband processing capability is one of the main advantages of photonics. However, the processing fineness is the limited factor in the optical domain. In contrast, electronics have a fine or high-resolution processing capability, but the processing bandwidth is narrow, mainly limited by the analog-to-digital converter (ADC). Therefore, the crucial challenge is how to realize an effective combination between broadband photonics and fine electronics and then achieve a high system performance.
An optical frequency comb (OFC) bridges the gap between the broadband optical and the precise microwave in a single step, which is an essential way to solve this issue, as shown in Fig.
Figure 4.Schematic of the system that combines broadband photonics and high-resolution electronics.
Besides, handling microwave signals in an integrated RF system for flexible information transition among multiple dimensions is very important, such as for microwave frequency conversion in a microwave repeater. In this section, we will introduce a comb-based multiband microwave frequency conversion method.
1. High-Resolution and Broadband Photonic RF Channelization System
Photonic channelization offers many advantages in dealing with ultrawide-bandwidth RF signals compared to pure electronic solutions [
Figure 5.Configuration of the coherent OFC-based channelization scheme. PBS, polarization beam splitter; PBC, polarization beam coupler.
The use of two coherent combs avoids precise optical alignment, and the numerical filter in the digital signal processor enables an ideal rectangular frequency response in each channel without any ultranarrow optical filters. Besides, due to the use of polarization in-phase/quadrature (I/Q) demodulation, ambiguous frequency estimation in direct detection can be avoided while the amplitude and phase mismatch in traditional I/Q demodulation can be mitigated.
The proposed channelization scheme is shown in Fig.
We experimentally tested the scheme by inputting single and dual RF tones. The two OFCs with 40 GHz FSR are coherent, and the channelizer equally divides the 3.75–7.25 GHz band seamlessly into seven channels. First, we tested the scheme by inputting a single RF tone placed at 4.111, 5.55, and 6.63 GHz. The downconverted IF tone is expected to be 111, 50, and 130 MHz in theory, which appears in the first, fourth, and sixth channel, respectively. In the experiment, the IF tone is digitalized with the sampling rate of
Figure 6.Output of the first, fourth, and sixth channels when RF signals of 4.111, 5.55, and 6.63 GHz are inputted, respectively.
We can observe that each RF tone is correctly downconverted and channelized exactly as the theory predicts. The IF frequency errors (
The crosstalk and frequency response of the channelization scheme are measured. In theory, due to the ideal rectangle filtering response of the numerical filter, the out-of-channel cross talk can be removed. In our experiment, the input RF tone is placed at 6.055 GHz (the corresponding IF locates in the fifth channel). Then, the outputs of the fifth channel and the next-nearest neighbor channels (fourth and sixth channels) are measured and shown in Fig.
Figure 7.(a) Output of the fourth, fifth, and sixth channels when 6.055 GHz signal is inputted. (b) Normalized channel response of the third channel with center frequency of 5 GHz and channel width of 500 MHz.
To measure the channel frequency response, a sweeping RF tone is applied to the MZM. The third channel is measured from 4.75 to 5.25 GHz with a 25 MHz step. The normalized amplitude response is shown in Fig.
Therefore, by using two coherent OFCs with a FSR of about 40 GHz, we demonstrate the channelization scheme with seven channels, 500 MHz channel spacing, and frequency coverage from 3.75 to 7.25 GHz. The input RF tones are accurately downconverted to an IF with a maximum frequency error of 125 kHz.
2. Compressive Sampling System
Over a broad frequency range, it is highly desired to provide the RF spectrum information of the intercepted signal with multifrequency resolving, high accuracy, and real-time operation. Several photonics-based multifrequency resolving approaches have been demonstrated [
The proposed experimental setup of the multifrequency RF sensing system is shown in Fig.
Figure 8.(a) System configuration of the proposed scheme. (b) Spectrum of a single tone. (c) Spectrum of PRBS. * denotes convolution. (d) Spectrum of the encoded signal. The dashed green line indicates the frequency response of the LPF. (e) Enlargement of the LPF’s passband. The dashed red line denotes the case of inputting another RF tone. PPG, pulse pattern generator; AWG, arbitrary waveform generator.
An intuitive explanation that involves inputting one RF tone is illustrated in Figs.
Since the cross-correlation between
In our experiment, first, to obtain
Figure 9.Experimental results. (a) Self-correlation function of
Therefore, we propose a compressed multifrequency RF sensing method with photonic assistance. The frequencies of a 40-tone RF signal ranging randomly from 0 to 1 GHz are recognized precisely.
3. Multiband Microwave Frequency Conversion System
An integrated RF system that is capable of sharing data or functionality with other systems requires flexible information transition among multiple dimensions, such as frequency or space domain. However, the demands on great capacity and large instantaneous bandwidth have driven today’s RF system to operate at higher frequencies and more bands. Conventional purely electrical RF techniques are coming up short when dealing with multiband, high-frequency signals since electrical devices have limited response bandwidth and strong electromagnetic interference. Recently, MWPs, with its unique characteristics of parallel signal processing over an extremely wide bandwidth, is emerging as a powerful tool for constructing complicated RF systems, such as the European Space Agency’s SAT’N LIGHT project [
Specifically, the implementation is divided into three steps: multiband LO generation, electro-optical mixing, and channelized heterodyne. As illustrated in Figs.
Figure 10.(a) Schematic diagram of multiple LO generation, electro-optical mixing, and channelized heterodyne detection. (b) Illustration of multiband LO generation. (c) Illustration of signal multicasting and the instantaneous bandwidth.
It is worth noting that the structure can be configured to implement frequency multicasting by simply inserting an electro-optical (E/O) mixing module into one branch of the structure, as shown in the dashed line box of Fig.
Theoretically, for the mixing process shown in the inset of Fig.
In the experiment, as shown in Fig.
Figure 11.(a) Dual coherent OFCs with 18 GHz center frequency shift and 38 and 30 GHz mode spacing. (b) Channelized dual OFCs, with one carrying the signal. (c)–(f) Generated multiple LOs within different bands. (g)–(i) Multicast signals within different bands. (j) EVM test results of the multicast signals.
When the structure is configured to implement signal multicasting, an input C band frequency of 6.1 GHz is successfully converted to 4.1, 3.9, 11.9 GHz in separate channels. The first three results are shown in Fig.
C. Efficient Utilization and Dynamic Management of the Resources in the DASs
The point-to-point, high dynamic, and phase-stabilized RoF links are able to reconstruct a centrally managed point-to-multipoint DAS, which can realize broadband, ubiquitous, and convergent wireless access or high-resolution aerospace measurement and controlling and astronomy monitoring. For broadband wireless access, DAS using RoF links has been demonstrated as a commonly used infrastructure solution to provide broadband wireless coverage within a geographic area with reduced total power and improved reliability [
The IEEE 802.11 media access control (MAC) protocols were originally designed and standardized for WLANs. In a simulcast WLAN RoF DAS, the coverage of one access point (AP) is enlarged into a greater scale and many more user stations communicate with the AP through multiple different fiber-connected antennas. Therefore, it is in strong demand to investigate the performance of the existing IEEE 802.11 MAC protocols in simulcast WLAN RoF DASs. The IEEE 802.11 standards suggest two mechanisms or so-called coordination functions in the MAC layer [
Figure 12.Typical simulcast WLAN RoF DAS architecture.
For describing the DCF performance in a simulcast RoF DAS accurately, we present an analytical model based on the two-dimensional Markov chain model, considering the fiber length difference effects. Figure
Figure 13.Comparison of fiber effect via different fiber delays between RAU-A and RAU-B. Solid lines represent basic access mode and dashed lines represent RTS/CTS exchange mode.
The most different characteristic of the PCF is that it achieves coordination through a centralized algorithm, where the AP runs the algorithm, while the DCF has a distributed algorithm run by all the stations. For PCF, all the stations in the polling list are polled by a point coordinator normally situated in the AP. The PCF uses a centralized resource scheduler, where a single AP controls the associated stations’ access to the channel by sending the polling messages. With its strong characteristics of a centralized allocation scheduler, we want to use it to improve the throughput performance in a simulcast RoF DAS, where the stations covered in different located RAUs can barely sense each other properly. A strong demand for a centralized allocation arises because of the needs of the blind stations. As observed from Fig.
Figure 14.(a) Normalized throughputs for the basic-access DCF mode, DCF in RTS/CTS mode, and adaptive PCF as a function of the number of RAUs assuming identical fiber length. (b) Throughput performance of each RAU as the function the length of one of the fiber links assuming different fiber lengths in a two-RAU scenario.
Figure
So the performance of several key WLAN MAC mechanisms has been investigated in simulcast RoF DASs, including the DCF in both the basic access and RTS/CTS exchange modes, and the PCF. It is shown that the adaptive PCF is a promising mechanism for simulcast RoF DASs in terms of the overall throughput and fairness among RAUs.
3. APPLICATION AND FUTURE WORK
A. Multiband Satellite Repeater
According to the information-mapping principles between microwaves and photonics, we propose a satellite repeater architecture that consists of multiple paths to support repeating signals among the C, Ku, K, and Ka bands [
Figure 15.Conceptual architecture of multiband satellite repeater based on OFCs. LNA: low noise amplifier.
In particular, these three sections can be compatible with each other since all their functions are implemented in the optical domain. Consequently, this concept of a MWP repeater is very suitable for transparent and broadband telecom missions. Besides, such a MWP system with a parallel structure offers high scalability so that it can be upgraded to large scale with the number of channels. In the future, once integrated in a single chip, this concept will bring the current all-microwave repeaters to a new era with unprecedented performance improvement.
B. Intelligent and Dynamic Controlled Next-Generation Wireless Information System
The conceptual architecture of the next-generation intelligent wireless information system is illustrated in Fig.
Figure 16.Conceptual architecture of a next-generation intelligent wireless information system.
4. CONCLUSION
Microwave photonics (MWPs) combines the advantages of microwaves and photonics, which is an interdisciplinary area that studies the interaction between microwaves and lightwaves. However, there are still several challenges in strengthening the performance of the technology to support systems and applications with a more complex structure, multiple functionality, larger bandwidth, and enhanced processing capability. In this paper, we addressed some of the challenges in MWP and presented the progress of our work in three main area: (1) high-linearity conversion and control between the lightwave and microwave; (2) precise processing and handling of broadband microwave signals; and (3) efficient utilization and dynamic management of the resources in the DASs. Finally, some applications and future directions of research based on those systems are discussed, especially, an intelligent wireless information system using a SDR for centralized management and MWP systems for photonic RF processing is proposed.
[1] J. Capmany, D. Novak. Microwave photonics combines two worlds. Nat. Photonics, 1, 319-330(2007).
[8] M. Sotom, B. Bénazet, A. Le Kernec, M. Maignan. Microwave photonic technologies for flexible satellite telecom payloads. Proceedings of the 35th European Conference on Optical Communication, 1-4(2009).
[10] M. E. Manka. Microwave photonics for electronic warfare applications. International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics (MWP), 275-278(2008).
[14] V. Urick. Long-haul analog links tutorial. Optical Fiber Communication, Collocated National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference, 1-39(2010).
[17] Y. Pei, J. Yao, K. Xu, J. Li, Y. Dai, J. Lin. Advanced DSP Technique for dynamic range improvement of a phase-modulation and coherent-detection microwave photonics link. International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics, 72-75(2013).
[24] P. F. Snawerdt, D. Koontz, R. K. Morse, N. C. Hollingsworth. Acousto-optic channelizer-based ultra-wideband signal processor. U.S. Patent(2000).
[26] D. B. Hunter, L. G. Edvell, M. A. Englund. Wideband microwave photonic channelized receiver. International Topical Meeting on Microwave Photonics (MWP), 249-252(2005).
[34] M. J. Crisp, S. Li, A. Wonfor, R. V. Penty, I. H. White. Demonstration of a radio over fibre distributed antenna network for combined In-building WLAN and 3G coverage. Optical Fiber Communication and the National Fiber Optic Engineers Conference, 249-252(2007).
[36] (2012).
[37] A. Zhou, M. Liu, X. Jiao. Convergence analysis and its application in the fixed point formulation of medium access in wireless network. China Commun., 8, 43-49(2011).
[38] S. Wang, A. Hafid, H. Zhao, S. Huang, C. Xiong, J. Wei. Towards wide-open, adaptable DCF implementation for dynamic networks. China Commun., 8, 77-89(2012).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Kun Xu, Ruixin Wang, Yitang Dai, Feifei Yin, Jianqiang Li, Yuefeng Ji, and Jintong Lin, "Microwave photonics: radio-over-fiber links, systems, and applications [Invited]," Photonics Res. 2, B54 (2014)
Special Issue: MICROWAVE PHOTONICS
Received: Mar. 17, 2014
Accepted: Jun. 18, 2014
Published Online: Sep. 15, 2014
The Author Email: Kun Xu (xukun@bupt.edu.cn)