In recent years, besides the development of efficient terahertz (THz) sources and detectors,[
Chinese Physics B, Volume. 29, Issue 9, (2020)
Recent advances in generation of terahertz vortex beams and their applications
Last decade has witnessed a rapid development of the generation of terahertz (THz) vortex beams as well as their wide applications, mainly due to their unique combination characteristics of regular THz radiation and orbital angular momentum (OAM). Here we have reviewed the ways to generate THz vortex beams by two representative scenarios, i.e., THz wavefront modulation via specific devices, and direct excitation of the helicity of THz vortex beams. The former is similar to those wavefront engineering devices in the optical and infrared (IR) domain, but just with suitable THz materials, while the latter is newly-developed in THz regime and some of the physical mechanisms still have not been explained explicitly enough though, which would provide both challenges and opportunities for THz vortex beam generation. As for their applications, thanks to the recent development of THz optics and singular optics, THz vortex beams have potentials to open doors towards a myriad of practice applications in many fields. Besides, some representative potential applications are evaluated such as THz wireless communication, THz super-resolution imaging, manipulating chiral matters, accelerating electron bunches, and detecting astrophysical sources.
1. Introduction
In recent years, besides the development of efficient terahertz (THz) sources and detectors,[
Because of these numerous applications, researchers have been working on how to generate efficiently THz vortex beams for years. However, there have been very fewer reports about the vortex generation in THz domain. According to these reports, methods for THz vortex beam generation can be divided into two scenarios, as shown in Fig. 1.
Figure 1.Two scenarios of methods for THz vortex beam generation (SPPs: spiral phase plates, APEs: achromatic polarization elements, DOEs: diffractive optical elements, THz LC FPG: THz liquid crystal forked polarization grating, CGHs: computer-generated holograms, STM: spatial terahertz modulator, MPs: modulated plasmas, OR: optical rectification, DFG: difference-frequency generation).
In this paper, we focus on a comprehensive overview for the generation of THz vortex beams and some representative potential applications. This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 will review and discuss the methods for THz vortex beam generation. In Section 3, we will present some potential and promising applications of vortex THz radiation. Finally, a summary and outlook will be given in Section 4.
2. Methods for THz vortex beam generation
The ways to produce THz vortex beams can be divided into two categories. One introduces OAM with some THz wavefront modulators, which is quite a straightforward strategy similar to the wavefront modulators in the optical and infrared (IR) domain and the other excites directly to generate THz vortex beams by using some vortex pump lasers and/or matters.
2.1. THz vortex beam generation by wavefront modulation devices
There are fewer THz wavefront modulation devices compared with those in the visible and IR domain due to a lack of materials for desired THz engineering.[
2.1.1. Vortex phase plates
Several vortex phase plates have been already applied to produce THz vortex beams, such as spiral phase plates (SPPs), THz q-plates, achromatic polarization elements (APEs), diffractive optical elements (DOEs), metasurfaces, and THz liquid crystal (LC) forked polarization grating (FPG).
2.1.1.1. Spiral phase plates
Generally, an SPP is a refractive optical element that can impose azimuth dependent phase retardation with azimuthally varying thickness. Its step height can be expressed as
Figure 2.3D model of an SPP with proper THz materials. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
Generally speaking, SPPs are very simple and economical, and can be applied to the pulses with any polarization states. Furthermore, one SPP can be used to generate OAM beams with two conjugated topological charges just by getting the SPP reversed. Additionally, SPPs are easy to produce high-order, free-space Laguerre–Gaussian (LG) beams. However, the size of SPPs with high-order topological charges needs a higher spatial resolution. Moreover, SPPs are not pure mode converters. The purity of LG beams produced by them is limited by the co-production of undesirable higher-order modes with radial index p and topological charge l, i.e., LGpl.[
2.1.1.2. THz q-plates
A q-plate is a pure geometrical phase optical element that enables the realization of vector beams and vortex beams with a simple and compact optical design. It is a thin optical birefringent waveplate with the space-dependent orientation of the ordinary and extraordinary axes in the transverse plane.[
Figure 3.Three examples of
Some materials can be used to fabricate THz q-plates like nematic LC, polystyrene, quartz crystal, even plasma. In specific, nematic LC has proven to be a very promising candidate for THz q-plates in a frequency range from 0.5 THz to 2.5 THz due to the pronounced optical birefringence, controllable director (i.e., local optical axis) distribution, and external field responsiveness.[
The THz q-plate is single and compact, and also has high stability in the long term and requires almost no maintenance. The device works in transmission geometry and therefore is free of many alignment problems. The device can be used to create a superposition of SAM/OAM states with no need of interferometric setups. The conversion efficiency (the ratio of OAM-converted THz radiation power over total transmitted light power) is relatively high. Moreover, several q-plates can be predicted to arrange in cascade, which is able to address a large range of OAM values.[
2.1.1.3. Achromatic polarization elements
Theoretically, a THz radially polarized beam can be converted into a THz vortex pulse by an APE, which consists of an achromatic quarter-wave plate and a wire-grid polarizer with specific fast axes orientations.[
Figure 4.Schematic of the conversion process by APEs. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
In APEs, incoming THz radially polarized beams are required. However, the direct conversion of the IR vector beam into the THz vector beam in ZnTe crystal is only reported when the beam collinearly propagates along the 〈 111 〉 axis of the ZnTe crystal possessing threefold rotational symmetry.[
2.1.1.4. Diffractive optical elements
There are some types of staircaselike DOEs reported to generate THz vortex beams, such as binary phase spiral Fresnel plates (BPSFPs),[
Figure 5.Phase profiles of two BPSAs. (a)
BPSFPs can be designed by silicon binary phase plates with the spiral configuration of zones, whose prototype is an amplitude Fresnel zone plate reported in Ref. [74]. In simple terms, when a spherical wave interferes with a vortex beam, the interference intensity pattern can be described as
Generally, DOEs provide a flexible method to generate OAM beams and allow for in situ adjustment of the diffraction pattern. The sign of the topological charge determines the direction of the spiral rotation. In addition, DOEs have high efficiency and resolution and are not sensitive to polarization of the incident laser light. Most DOEs are designed only to generate Bessel vortex beams. Certainly, it is also desirable to design DOEs to produce more complex THz vortex patterns.[
2.1.1.5. Metasurfaces
Metasurfaces, some ultrathin metamaterials consisting of planar subwavelength units, have been used to achieve phase modulations covering a full range of 360°.[
There are several typical metasurfaces reported for THz vortex beam generation based on the aforementioned two categories. The resonance-based metasurfaces in THz domain are reported, such as V-shaped slit antennas structure,[
Figure 6.Schematic structure of two representative metasurfaces. (a)–(c) V-shaped slit antennas structure; (d)–(e) circular sub-wavelength slits. Reproduced with permission from Refs. [
The complementary V-shaped slit antennas structure was fabricated on a thin metal film (100 nm Au).[
By contrast, the circular sub-wavelength slit structure[
When a circularly polarized THz wave incidents normally upon the thin film, the output complex amplitude in the near-field zone can be expressed as
In contrast to the traditional bulk optical elements, metasurfaces provide a perspective on shaping flexibly the electromagnetic field by manipulating the phase, amplitude as well as polarization at will via a compact and easy-of-fabrication system.[
2.1.1.6. THz liquid crystal forked polarization grating
When a gradient blazed phase is introduced into a common spiral phase, the integrated phase profile in the xy plane shall be[
Figure 7.Phase presentation and idea 3D schematic structure of THz LC FPG. (a) A common spiral phase distribution; (b) introduced gradient blazed phase distribution; (c) integrated phase distribution; (d) ideal 3D LC FPG. Reproduced with permission from Refs. [
A THz LC FPG can be used to generate and separate simultaneously pure THz vortex beams with conjugated circular polarization. However, it is bulky, and its fabricating process is very difficult and complicated.[
2.1.2. THz hologram technology
Hologram technology can also be utilized to generate THz vortex beams. Some reported works include computer-generated holograms (CGHs) and spatial terahertz modulator (STM). The former operates at the sub-THz frequency range, such as 0.119 THz,[
2.1.2.1. THz computer-generated holograms
CGHs are locally periodic diffraction gratings that modify both the reflected and transmitted electromagnetic fields.[
Figure 8.Local grating structures. (a) Amplitude holograms; (b) phase holograms. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
In an amplitude-type hologram, its diffraction grating consists of copper stripes (17 μm) on a dielectric Mylar film (75 μm thick, relative permittivity εr = 3.3). The designed pattern can be fabricated using photolithography and chemical wet etching.[
While in the phase-type holograms, the hologram structure features locally change the effective thickness seen by the electromagnetic waves which can be realized by varying either the refractive index or the depth of the surface profiles. The hologram elements consist of milled grooves on a dielectric substrate (obomodulan(®), εr ≈ 2.2). The sub-THz field passing through the grooves acquires a phase difference with respect to that between the grooves, leading to phase modulation of the transmitted field, instead of amplitude modulation. There are, however, always some losses due to both the reflection of the electric field on the interface of a dielectric material and the attenuation within a lossy dielectric. The groove profile of a phase hologram may be binary (all grooves have rectangular cross sections), multilevel (stepped profile), or continuous. Rigorous electromagnetic modeling is required to optimize the grating structure.[
Since binary holograms are cheap and easy to fabricate, and typically suitable for sub-THz regime, they are useful in real-world applications of OAM. In reality, these holograms are with wavelength-scale diffractive structures, and the modulations of their amplitudes are never purely binary, so further optimization is usually necessary by rigorous modeling methods.[
2.1.2.2. Spatial terahertz modulator
An STM requires an array of small building blocks that can independently control the transmission or reflection of a THz beam at different positions. Hence, the transparency at different positions of the semiconductor wafer can be independently modulated. Specifically, the control beam modulated by a conventional SLM illuminates the surface of a 500 μm thick semiconductor silicon wafer to produce the corresponding pattern of photo-generated carriers, whose prototype is shown in Fig. 9. Its intrinsic broadband response results in the relatively broad bandwidth (1–1.6 THz) of the generated THz vortex beams.[
Figure 9.Prototype of STM. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
The STM allows the all-optical or electrical control of the spatial transmission or reflection of an input THz wave; therefore, it can encode the information in a wavefront, and produce broadband THz vortex beams.[
The above devices discussed in Subsection 2.1 are basically designed to manipulate the regular THz beams with a specific topological charge and a given frequency, or with a relatively narrow bandwidth. These elements are lack of tunability, switchability, and versatility inherently, which are key requirements to handle the wavefront of THz pulses. Furthermore, their bandwidths are still not enough to develop tunable THz vortex beams.
2.2. Directly exciting the helicity of the THz vortex beams
So far, there are also some reports on directly exciting the OAM of the THz vortex beams. These reported methods include optical rectification (OR), difference-frequency generation (DFG), and laser plasma techniques.
2.2.1. Optical rectification
THz beams can be generated by OR of an IR laser pulse in a 〈110〉 ZnTe crystal. Both pulses are assumed to propagate along the
Figure 10.Geometry of 〈110〉 ZnTe crystal. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
Considering an incident IR vector pulse with azimuthal order l, the electric field can be written as[
In general, OR is well suited for intense THz vortex generation — one can simply increase the surface area of the OR crystal with more input laser energy and efficient phase-matching condition. The bandwidth depends on the frequency response of the OR crystal. However, until now, using OR still fails to generate pure THz vortex pulses.
2.2.2. Difference-frequency generation
There are two schemes reported to generate THz vortex beams by DFG. The first one bases on type-II DFG between two collinear near-infrared (NIR, 800 nm) chirped pulses with orthogonal polarizations, conjugated topological charges, and a relative time delay.[
Figure 11.Some experimental devices for a pair of 800 nm vortex beams and some experimental results for THz vortex beam generation. (a) Passive and transmissive device of generating collinear vortex pulse pair of 800 nm with conjugated topological charges and orthogonal polarizations. P, polarizer;
The complex amplitude of generated THz beams ATHz by type-II DFG can be described by[
In the second setup, a vortex beam (1.56 μm) and a Gaussian beam (1.5–1.64 μm) generated by two optical parametric amplifiers (OPA1 and OPA2) are focused and spatially overlapped on a 4′-dimethylamino-N-methyl-4-stilbazolium tosylate (DAST) crystal to generate the high-quality THz vortex mode within the frequency range of 2–6 THz via soft-aperture DFG.[
One of DFG advantages is tunability. The spectra of the generated THz vortex beams are limited by the frequency responses of the used nonlinear DFG crystals.
2.2.3. Laser plasma techniques
So far, there are two types of laser plasma techniques reported to generate THz vortex beams, namely, space-periodically modulated plasmas (MPs) and spatial non-periodically MPs.
2.2.3.1. Space-periodically modulated plasmas
Recently, a few schemes for generating THz vortex beams have been proposed based on space-periodically MPs, which include rippled plasmas (RPs) and vortex plasmas (VPs).
The plasma density of a RP can be defined as[
Figure 12.Simulation results of the generation of THz vortex beams via a type of (a) RPs; (b) SVPs; and (c) DVPs. Reproduced with permission from Ref. [
While in VP, the OAM exchange occurs between it and the emitted THz radiation.[
The space-periodically MPs can produce THz vortex beams with a specific topological charge by choosing suitable plasma density distribution. In order to generate such space-periodically MPs, many methods are explored, but the implementation of such plasmas is not straightforward, and it suffers from low efficiency, too.
2.2.3.2. Spatial non-periodically modulated plasmas
Laser-induced gas plasmas by a two-color field (a fundamental wave and its second harmonics) or a few-cycle ultrashort pulse can be considered as spatial non-periodically MPs, which are exclusive to achieve a high intensity and broad bandwidth regular THz field beyond the damage threshold of bulk materials.[
Figure 1.Two scenarios of methods for THz vortex beam generation (SPPs: spiral phase plates, APEs: achromatic polarization elements, DOEs: diffractive optical elements, THz LC FPG: THz liquid crystal forked polarization grating, CGHs: computer-generated holograms, STM: spatial terahertz modulator, MPs: modulated plasmas, OR: optical rectification, DFG: difference-frequency generation).
On the one hand, typically, most inert gases such as N2, He, Ar, and so on can be used as the media to generate spatial non-periodically MPs, and thus radiate THz pulses.[
3. Potential applications of THz vortex beams
Thanks to the advent and continuous development of THz optics and singular optics, many applications of THz vortex beams have been made possible, such as optical tweezers, optical wrenches, cell rotators and stretchers in biomedical engineering and medical fields. Going beyond conventional THz photonics, manipulating the wavefront of THz radiation opens new opportunities that underpin application areas in THz wireless communication, THz super-resolution imaging, manipulation of chiral matters, acceleration of electron bunches, detection of astrophysical sources, and so on.
3.1. THz wireless communication
With the increasing demand for higher bandwidth and bigger capacity of the wireless communication system, the extension of the operating frequency of the communication system to the THz wave regime is inevitable.[
3.2. THz super-resolution imaging
THz imaging technologies show great potentials when it comes to nondestructive testing and biomedical sensing. However, the resolutions of conventional THz imaging systems are constrained by the diffraction limit.[
3.3. Manipulation of chiral matters
As is known to all, chirality is used for describing the symmetry properties of an object. A chiral object, which cannot be superposed with its mirror by rotations or translations, is one of quite ubiquitous and exciting phenomena in the micro and macro world, such as protein, DNA, hands, shells, and etc. There are two types of chirality, i.e., one is left-handed, and the other is right-handed. Whereas objects in nature seem to prefer one chirality, for example, DNA is right-handed; almost all the natural amino acids are left-handed. Interestingly, vortex beams can be chiral by carrying OAM. On the other hand, the elementary excitations of many matters in nature have been found in the THz frequency range, such as the vibration frequencies of biomacromolecule (e.g., DNA, protein, and so on),[
3.4. Acceleration of electron bunches
Acceleration and manipulation of electron bunches underline most electron and x-ray devices used for ultrafast imaging and spectroscopy. THz vortex beams are also promising in acceleration and manipulation of electron bunches. New THz-vortex-driven concepts could offer orders-of-magnitude improvements in field strengths, field gradients, laser synchronization, and compactness relative to conventional radio-frequency devices, enabling shorter electron bunches and higher resolution with less infrastructure while maintaining high charge capacities, repetition rates, and stability.[
3.5. Detection of astrophysical sources
Recently, the properties of beams carrying OAM have attracted attention for practical astronomical applications.[
4. Summary and outlook
This paper provides an overview of the generation of vortex THz radiation and some of its potential applications. Generally speaking, there are two scenarios of methods to generate THz beams with OAM: one is via wavefront modulation devices to engineer the wavefront of regular THz waves; and the other is through exciting the helicity of the THz vortex from the incident vortex beams and/or special media. The limitation of the former is the lack of suitable and desired materials for THz waves, and the devices in the former also suffer from relatively narrow bandwidth for the THz vortex beams. While the latter can work with relatively high pump laser power with broad bandwidth despite of relatively low conversion efficiency. It is newly-developed where some of the physical mechanisms still have not been explored explicitly, so there will be full of both challenges and opportunities therein. As for applications, one can foresee a historic breakthrough for science and technology through THz vortex pulses research. It is also noteworthy that the research of THz vortex waves is built on many areas of science. Activities and efforts geared towards the implementation of applications of THz vortex waves are unbounded. THz vortex beams are promising in the fields of observational astronomy, material science, biomedicine, nondestructive super-resolution molecular spectroscopy, and even some uncharted territories. Among these applications, sometimes, the THz vortex radiation sources with high power and broad bandwidth are required, besides sensitive sensors and detectors, and functional THz devices and materials.
In recent years, several breakthroughs related to the sources of THz vortex beam generation have essentially bridged the OAM-based THz technological gap and fashioned their sovereignty over the current and future cutting-edge technologies. Promisingly, future directions and emerging areas of interests will be identified with translating these methods into practical devices.
[1] X C Zhang, A Shkurinov, Y Zhang. Nat. Photon, 11, 16(2017).
[2] M F Pererira, O V Shulika. Terahertz and Mid Infrared Radiation: Detection of Explosives and CBRN (Using Terahertz)(2014).
[3] R A Lewis. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 47(2014).
[4] C Zhang, L Deng, J Zhu, W Hong, L Wang, W Yang, S Li. Materials, 11, 1054(2018).
[5] T Kampfrath, K Tanaka, K A Nelson. Nat. Photon, 7, 680(2013).
[6] S Koenig, D Lopez-Diaz, J Antes, F Boes, R Henneberger, A Leuther, A Tessmann, R Schmogrow, D Hillerkuss, R Palmer, T Zwick, C Koos, W Freude, O Ambacher, J Leuthold, I Kallfass. Nat. Photon, 7, 977(2013).
[7] E Pickwell, V P Wallace. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 39, R301(2006).
[8] K Miyamoto, B J Kang, W T Kim, Y Sasaki, H Niinomi, K Suizu, F Rotermund, T Omatsu. Sci. Rep, 6(2016).
[9] T Watanabe, Y Iketaki, T Omatsu, K Yamamoto, M Sakai, M Fujii. Opt. Express, 11, 3271(2003).
[10] K Miyamoto, K Sano, T MIyakawa, H Niinomi, K Toyoda, A Vallés, T Omatsu. Opt. Express, 27(2019).
[11] M Tonouchi. Nat. Photon, 1, 97(2007).
[12] D M Mittleman. Opt. Express, 26, 9417(2018).
[13] K Kawase, Y Ogawa, Y Watanabe, H Inoue. Opt. Express, 11, 2549(2003).
[14] M Hangyo. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 54(2015).
[15] L Ju, B Geng, J Horng, C Girit, M Martin, Z Hao, H A Bechtel, X Liang, A Zettl, Y R Shen, F Wang. Nat. Nanotechnol, 6, 630(2011).
[16] S S Dhillon, M S Vitiello, E H Linfield et al. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 50(2017).
[17] K Humphreys, J Loughran, M Gradziel, W Lanigan, T Ward, J Murphy, C O’Sullivan. Proceedings of the 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE EMBS, 1302(2004).
[18] Z D Taylor, R S Singh, D B Bennett, P Tewari, C P Kealey, N Bajwa, M O Culjat, A Stojadinovic, H Lee, J P Hubschman, E R Brown, W S Grundfest. IEEE T. THz Sci. Techn, 1, 201(2011).
[19] M Walther, B M Fischer, A Ortner, A Bitzer, A Thoman, H Helm. Anal. Bioanal. Chem, 397, 1009(2010).
[20] J Y Suen, P Tewari, Z D Taylor, W S Grundfest, H Lee, E R Brown, M O Culjat, R S Singh. Stud. Health Technol. Inform, 142, 364(2009).
[21] T Omatsu, K Chujo, K Miyamoto, M Okida, K Nakamura, N Aoki, R Morita. Opt. Express, 18(2010).
[22] D Zhang, A Fallahi, M Hemmer, X Wu, M Fakhari, Y Hua, H Cankaya, A L Calendron, L E Zapata, N H Matlis, F X Kärtner. Nat. Photon, 12, 336(2018).
[23] J Vieira, J T Mendonça. Phys. Rev. Lett, 112(2014).
[24] J Hebling, J A Fülöp, M I Mechler, L Pálfalvi, C Töke, G Almási(2011).
[25] A J Silenko, P Zhang, L Zou. Phys. Rev. Lett, 119(2017).
[26] H Zheng, U M Mirsaidov, L W Wang, P Matsudaira. Nano Lett, 12, 5644(2012).
[27] F Tamburini, B Thidé, G Molina-Terriza, G Anzolin. Nat. Phys, 7, 195(2011).
[28] M Harwit. Astrophys. J, 597, 1266(2003).
[29] D J Sanchez, D W Oesch, O R Reynolds. Astron. Astrophys, 556, A130(2013).
[30] B Thidé, H Then, J Sjöholm, K Palmer, J Bergman, T D Carozzi, Y N Istomin, N H Ibragimov, R Khamitova. Phys. Rev. Lett, 99(2007).
[31] W L Chan, H T Chen, A J Taylor, I Brener, M J Cich, D M Mittleman. Appl. Phys. Lett, 94(2009).
[32] A Podzorov, G Gallot. Appl. Opt, 47, 3254(2008).
[33] S Walia, C M Shah, P Gutruf, H Nili, D R Chowdhury, W Withayachumnankul, M Bhaskaran, S Sriram. Appl. Phys. Rev, 2(2015).
[34] K Miyamoto, K Suizu, T Akiba, T Omatsu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 104(2014).
[35] B J Kang, K Miyamoto, W T Kim, K J Ahn, T Omatsu, F Rotermund. Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Pacific Rim (CLEO-PR)(2018).
[36] X Wang, J Shi, W Sun, S Feng, P Han, J Ye, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 24, 7178(2016).
[37] P Schemmel, G Pisano, B Maffei. Opt. Express, 22(2014).
[38] P Schemmel, S Maccalli, G Pisano, B Maffei, M W R Ng. Opt. Letters, 39, 626(2014).
[39] N V Petrov, M S Kulya, A N Tsypkin, V G Bespalov, A A Gorodetsky. IEEE T. THz Sci. Techn, 6, 464(2016).
[40] V A Semenova, M S Kulya, N V Petrov, Y V Grachev, A N Tsypkin, S E Putilin, V G Bespalov. 41st International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2016).
[41] V Semenova, M Kulya, V Bespalov. J. Phys.: Conf. Ser, 735(2016).
[42] T Wakayama, T Higashiguchi, H Oikawa, K Sakaue, M Washio, M Yonemura, T Yoshizawa, J S Tyo, Y Otani. Sci. Rep, 5, 9416(2015).
[43] L Wang, X W Lin, X Liang, J B Wu, W Hu, Z G Zheng, B B Jin, Y Q Qin, Y Q Lu. Opt. Mater. Express, 2, 1314(2012).
[44] X W Lin, J B Wu, W Hu, Z G Zheng, Z J Wu, G Zhu, F Xu, B B Jin, Y Q Lu. AIP Adv, 1(2011).
[45] G Turnbull, D Robertson, G Smith, L Allen, M Padgett. Opt. Commun, 127, 183(1996).
[46] A I Hernandez-Serrano, E Castro-Camus, D Lopez-Mago. J. Infrared Millim. Te, 38, 938(2017).
[47] W D Furlan, V Ferrando, J A Monsoriu, P Zagrajek, E Czerwińska, M Szustakowski. Opt. Lett, 41, 1748(2016).
[48] L Zhu, X Wei, J Wang, Z Zhang, Z Li, H Zhang, S Li, K Wang, J Liu. Optical Fiber Communications Conference and Exhibition (OFC)(2014).
[49] C Liu, J Liu, L Niu, X Wei, K Wang, Z Yang. Sci. Rep, 7, 3891(2017).
[50] S Fallah, K Rouhi, A Abdolali. J. Phy. D: Appl. Phys, 53(2020).
[51] K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Carbon, 149, 125(2019).
[52] A Momeni, K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Sci. Rep, 8, 6200(2018).
[53] K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Ann. Phys, 530(2017).
[54] S Asgari, M Rahmanzadeh. Opt. Commun, 456(2020).
[55] Z Liu, B Bai. Opt. Express, 25, 8584(2017).
[56] K Qu, Q Jia, N J Fisch. Phys. Rev. E, 96(2017).
[57] Y Yang, X Ye, L Niu, K Wang, Z Yang, J Liu. Opt. Express, 28, 1417(2020).
[58] J Lin, X C Yuan, S H Tao, R E Burge. Opt. Lett, 30, 3266(2005).
[59] X Wei, C Liu, L Niu, Z Zhang, K Wang, Z Yang, J Liu. Appl. Opt, 54(2015).
[60] Z Wu, X Wang, W Sun, S Feng, P Han, J Ye, Y Yu, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 26, 1506(2018).
[61] M W Beijersbergen, R P C Coerwinkel, M Kristensen, J P Woerdman. Opt. Commun, 112, 321(1994).
[62] L Marrucci, C Manzo, D Paparo. Phys. Rev. Lett, 96(2006).
[63] L Marrucci, C Manzo, D Paparo. Appl. Phys. Lett, 88(2006).
[64] A Minasyan, C Trovato, J Degert, E Freysz, E Brasselet, E Abraham. Opt. Lett, 42, 41(2017).
[65] S Ge, P Chen, Z Shen, W Sun, X Wang, W Hu, Y Zhang, Y Lu. Opt. Express, 25(2017).
[66] B Piccirillo, V D’Ambrosio, S Slussarenko, L Marrucci, E Santamato. Appl. Phys. Lett, 97(2010).
[67] A Rubano, F Cardano, B Piccirillo, L Marrucci. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 36, D70(2019).
[68] R Imai, N Kanda, T Higuchi, K Konishi, M Kuwata-Gonokami. Opt. Lett, 39, 3714(2014).
[69] X Wang, S Wang, Z Xie, W Sun, S Feng, Y Cui, J Ye, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 22(2014).
[70] R Imai, N Kanda, T Higuchi, Z Zheng, K Konishi, M K Gonokami. Opt. Express, 20(2012).
[71] B A Knyazev, Y Y Choporova, M S Mitkov, V S Pavelyev, B O Volodkin. Phys. Rev. Lett, 115(2015).
[72] B Volodkin, Y Choporova, B Knyazev, G Kulipanov, V Pavelyev, V Soifer, N Vinokurov. Opt. Quant. Electron, 48, 223(2016).
[73] Y Zhang, W Liu, J Gao, X Yang. Adv. Opt. Mater, 6(2018).
[74] R N Heckenberg, R McDuff, C P Smith, A G White. Opt. Lett, 17, 221(1992).
[75] A M Yao, M J Padgett. Adv. Opt. Photonics, 3, 161(2011).
[76] Q Zhan. Adv. Opt. Photonics, 1, 1(2009).
[77] R Dorn, S Quabis, G Leuchs. Phys. Rev. Lett, 91(2003).
[78] S N Khonina, S V Alferov, S V Karpeev. Opt. Lett, 38, 3223(2013).
[79] J He, X Wang, D Hu, J Ye, S Feng, Q Kan, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 21(2013).
[80] M Zhuldybina, C Trudeau, X Ropagnol, M Bolduc, R J Zednik, F Blanchard. Photonics North (PN) Conference(2018).
[81] Y Taira, Y Nakata, F Miyamaru, M W Takeda. Progress in Electromagnetic Research Symposium (PIERS), 2396(2016).
[82] Y Chen, S Suzuki, M Asada. 43rd International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2018).
[83] H Zhou, J Dong, S Yan, Y Zhou, X Zhang. IEEE Photonics J, 6(2014).
[84] X N Li, L Zhou, G Z Zhao. Acta Phys. Sin, 68(2019).
[85] X Zang, Y Zhu, C Mao, W Xu, H Ding, J Xie, Q Cheng, L Chen, Y Peng, Q Hu, M Gu, S Zhuang. Adv. Opt. Mater, 7(2019).
[86] M Kang, J Chen, B Gu, Y Li, L T Vuong, H T Wang. Phys. Rev. A, 85(2012).
[87] M Sakamoto, K Oka, R Morita, N Murakami. Opt. Lett, 38, 3661(2013).
[88] Y Tokizane, K Oka, R Morita. Opt. Express, 17(2009).
[89] X D Zhang, Y H Su, J C Ni, Z Y Wang, Y L Wang, C W Wang, F F Ren, Z Zhang, H Fan, W J Zhang, G Q Li, Y L Hu, J W Li, D Wu, J R Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 111(2017).
[90] S J Ge, Z X Shen, P Chen, X Liang, X K Wang, W Hu, Y Zhang, Y Q Lu. Crystals, 7, 314(2017).
[91] Y Li, J Kim, M J Escuti. Appl. Opt, 51, 8236(2012).
[92] H Wu, W Hu, H C Hu, X W Lin, G Zhu, J W Choi, V Chigrinov, Y Q Lu. Opt. Express, 20(2012).
[93] J Ala-Laurinaho, T Hirvonen, P Piironen, A Lehto, J Tuovinen, A V Räisänen, U Frisk. IEEE T. Antenn. Propag, 49, 1264(2001).
[94] J Salo, J Meltaus, E Noponen, M M Salomaa, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, V Viikari, J Säily, J Häkli, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. J. Opt. A: Pure Appl. Opt, 4, S161(2002).
[95] J Säily, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Häkli, J Tuovinen, A Lehto, A V Räisänen. Electron. Lett, 36, 111(2000).
[96] J Meltaus, J Salo, E Noponen, M M Salomaa, V Viikari, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, J Säily, J Häkli, J Alá-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, 1305(2002).
[97] Z Xie, X Wang, J Ye, S Feng, T Akalin, Y Zhang. Sci. Rep, 3, 3347(2013).
[98] J Meltaus, J Salo, E Noponen, M M Salomma, V Viikari, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, J Säily, J Häkli, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. IEEE T. Microw. Theory, 51, 1274(2003).
[99] J Arlt, K Dholakia. Opt. Commun, 177, 297(2000).
[100] R Petit. Electromagnetic Theory of Gratings(1980).
[101] Y Z Yu, W B Dou. Int. J. Infrared Milli. Waves, 29, 693(2008).
[102] B Ferguson, X C Zhang. Nat. Materials, 1, 26(2002).
[103] A A Dhaybi, J Degert, E Brasselet, E Abraham, E Freysz. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 36, 12(2019).
[104] Q Chen, M Tani, Z Jiang, X C Zhang. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 18, 823(2001).
[105] Q Lin, S Zheng, Q Song, X Zeng, Y Cai, Y Li, Z Chen, L Zha, X Pan, S Xu. Opt. Lett, 44, 887(2019).
[106] J R Danielson, A D Jameson, J L Tomaino, H Hui, J D Wetzel, Y S Lee, K L Vodopyanov. J. Appl. Phys, 104(2008).
[107] H Sobhani, E Dadar. J.Opt. Soc. Am. A, 36, 1187(2019).
[108] M Kreß, T Löffler, M D Thomson, R Dörner, H Gimpel, K Zrost, T Ergler, R Moshammer, U Morgner, J Ullrich, H G Roskos. Nat. Phys, 2, 327(2006).
[109] K Y Kim, J H Glownia, A J Taylor, G Rodriguez. Opt. Express, 15, 4577(2007).
[110] M D Thomson, M Kreß, T Löffler, H G Roskos. Laser Photonics Rev, 1, 349(2007).
[111] Y Bai, L Song, R Xu, C Li, P Liu, Z Zeng, Z Zhang, H Lu, R Li, Z Xu. Phys. Rev. Lett, 108(2012).
[112] H Wang, Y Bai, E Wu, Z Wang, P Liu, C Liu. Phys. Rev. A, 98(2018).
[113] H Wang, Q Song, S Zheng, Q Lin, E Wu, Y Ai, C Liu, S Xu. J. Opt, 21(2019).
[114] M Ivanov, I Thiele, L Bergé, S Skupin, D Buožius, V Vaičaitis. Opt. Lett, 44, 3889(2019).
[115] , Q Jin, A Tcypkin, X C Zhang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 113(2019).
[116] Q Jin, , K Williams, J Dai, X C Zhang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 111(2017).
[117] I Dey, K Jana, V Y Fedorov, A D Koulouklidis, A Mondal, M Shaikh, D Sarkar, A D Lad, S Tzortzakis, A Couairon, G R Kumar. Nat. Commun, 8, 1184(2017).
[118] Q Jin, , L Zhang, C Zhang, A Tcypkin, S Kozlov, X C Zhang. 43rd International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2018).
[119] G Jiang, L Zhang, S Zhang, C Zhang. Infrared, Millimeter-Wave, and Terahertz Technologies V, Proc. SPIE(2018).
[120] R Piesiewicz, M Jacob, M Koch, J Schoebel, T Kürner. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quant, 14, 421(2008).
[121] J Federici, L Moeller. J. Appl. Phys, 107(2010).
[122] C Han, A O Bicen, I F Akyildiz. IEEE T. Signal Proces, 64, 910(2016).
[123] X Wei, L Zhu, Z Zhang, K Wang, J Liu, J Wang. Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO)–-Laser Science to Photonic Application(2014).
[124] R Fickler, R Lapkiewicz, W N Plick, M Krenn, C Schaeff, S Ramelow, A Zeilinger. Science, 338, 640(2012).
[125] T Nagatsuma, G Ducournau, C C Renaud. Nat. Photon, 10, 371(2016).
[126] A Hirata, T Kosugi, H Takahashi, R Yamaguchi, F Nakajima, T Furuta, H Ito, H Sugahara, Y Sato, T Nagatsuma. IEEE T. Microw. Theory, 54, 1937(2006).
[127] H Takahashi, A Hirata, J Takeuchi, N Kukutsu, T Kosugi, K Murata. 15th European Microwave Week-Space for Microwaves Conference Proceedings, 313(2012).
[128] S Cherry. IEEE Spectrum, 41, 58(2004).
[129] N Bozinovic, Y Yue, Y Ren, M Tur, P Kristensen, H Huang, A E Willner, S Ramachandran. Science, 340, 1545(2013).
[130] J Wang, J Y Yang, I M Fazal, N Ahmed, Y Yan, H Huang, Y Ren, Y Yue, S Dolinar, M Tur, A E Willner. Nat. Photon, 6, 488(2012).
[131] Z Wang, N Zhang, X C Yuan. Opt. Express, 19, 482(2011).
[132] X Gao, S Huang, J Zhou, Y Wei, C Gao, X Zhang, W Gu. J. Opt, 15(2013).
[133] V G Bespalov. Russ. Phys. J, 58, 1420(2016).
[134] P U Jepsen, D G Cooke, M Koch. Laser Photonics Rev, 5, 124(2011).
[135] C Jansen, S Wietzke, O Peters, M Scheller, N Vieweg, M Salhi, N Krumbholz, C Jördens, T Hochrein, M Koch. Appl. Opt, 49, E48(2010).
[136] T L Cocker, M A Huber, M Eisele, M Plankl, F Mooshammer, F Sandner, D Peller, J Repp, R Huber. Progress in Electromagnetic Research Symposium (PIERS), 3339(2016).
[137] Z Long, T Wang, C You, Z Yang, K Wang, J Liu. Appl. Opt, 58, 2731(2019).
[138] K Liu, Y Cheng, Z Yang, H Wang, Y Qin, X Li. IEEE Anten Wirel. Pr, 14, 711(2015).
[139] S C Chen, L H Du, K Meng, J Li, Z H Zhai, Q W Shi, Z R Li, L G Zhu. Opt. Lett, 44, 21(2019).
[140] Y Guo, F Ling, H Li, S Zhou, J Ji, J Yao. Appl. Opt, 58, 6244(2019).
[141] S Bretschneider, C Eggeling, S W Hell. Phys. Rev. Lett, 98(2007).
[142] I H Baek, K J Ahn, B J Kang, S Bae, B H Hong, D I Yeom, K Lee, Y U Jeong, F Rotermund. Appl. Phys. Lett, 102(2013).
[143] J Hebling, K Yeh, M C Hoffmann, K A Nelson. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quant, 14, 345(2008).
[144] G Sharma, I Al-Naib, H Hafez, R Morandotti, D G Cooke, T Ozaki. Opt. Express, 20(2012).
[145] J C Cao, J C Lei. Phys. Rev. B, 67(2003).
[146] H Wen, M Wiczer, A M Lindenberg. Phys. Rev. B, 78(2008).
[147] D Sanvitto, F M Marchetti, M H Szymańska, G Tosi, M Baudisch, F P Laussy, D N Krizhanovskii, M S Skolnick, L Marrucci, A Lemaître, J Bloch, C Tejedor, L Viña. Nat. Phys, 6, 527(2010).
[148] K Toyoda, K Miyamoto, N Aoki, R Morita, T Omatsu. Nano Lett, 12, 3645(2012).
[149] K Toyoda, F Takahashi, S Takizawa, Y Tokizane, K Miyamoto, R Morita, T Omatsu. Phys. Rev. Lett, 110(2013).
[150] F Takahashi, K Miyamoto, H Hidai, K Yamane, R Morita, T Omatsu. Sci. Rep, 6(2016).
[151] E A Nanni, W R Huang, K H Hong, K Ravi, A Fallahi, G Moriena, R J D Miller, F X Kärtner. Nat. Commun, 6, 8486(2015).
[152] G Anzolin, F Tamburini, A Bianchini, G Umbriaco, C Barbieri. Astro. Astrophys, 488, 1159(2008).
[153] F Tamburini, G Anzolin, A Bianchini, C Barbieri. Phys. Rev. Lett, 97(2006).
[154] C Barbieri, G Naletto, T Occhipinti et al. J. Mod. Optic, 56, 261(2009).
[155] E Serabyn, D Mawet, R Burruss. Nature, 464, 1018(2010).
[156] J H Lee, G Foo, E G Johnson, G A Swartzlander Jr. Phys. Rev. Lett, 97(2006).
[157] A Bekshaev, K Y Bliokh, M Soskin. J. Opt, 13(2011).
[158] H Dehnen. Int. J. Theor. Phys, 7, 467(1973).
[159] P Carini, L L Feng, M Li, R Ruffini. Phys. Rev. D, 46, 5407(1992).
[160] L L Feng, W L Lee. Int. J. Mod. Phys. D, 10, 961(2001).
[161] A E Broderick, V L Fish, S S Doeleman, A Loeb. Astrophys. J, 697, 45(2009).
[162] C Jenkins. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc, 384, 515(2008).
[163] C Delacroix, O Absil, P Forsberg, D Mawet, V Christiaens, M Karlsson, A Boccaletti, P Baudoz, M Kuittinen, I Vartiainen, J Surdej, S Habraken. Astron. Astrophys, 553, A98(2013).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Honggeng Wang, Qiying Song, Yi Cai, Qinggang Lin, Xiaowei Lu, Huangcheng Shangguan, Yuexia Ai, Shixiang Xu. Recent advances in generation of terahertz vortex beams and their applications[J]. Chinese Physics B, 2020, 29(9):
Received: May. 13, 2020
Accepted: --
Published Online: Apr. 29, 2021
The Author Email: Xiaowei Lu (shxxu@szu.edu.cn)