Journal of Inorganic Materials, Volume. 36, Issue 7, 773(2021)

Molten Salt Synthesis of Nanolaminated Sc2SnC MAX Phase

Youbing LI1,2, Yanqing QIN1,2, Ke CHEN1,2, Lu CHEN1,2, Xiao ZHANG1,2, Haoming DING1,2, Mian LI1,2, Yiming ZHANG1,2, Shiyu DU1,2, Zhifang CHAI1,2, and Qing HUANG1,2、*
Author Affiliations
  • 11. Engineering Laboratory of Advanced Energy Materials, Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology and Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo 315201, China
  • 22. Qianwan Institute of CNiTECH, Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology and Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo 315201, China
  • show less

    The MAX phases are a family of ternary layered material with both metal and ceramic properties, and it is also precursor materials for synthesis of two-dimensional MXenes. The theory predicts that there are more than 600 kinds of stable ternary layered MAX phase materials. Now, more than 80 kinds of ternary layered MAX phases that the M-site elements are mainly from early transition metal have been experimental synthesized, but few researches are reported on MAX phases where M is a rare earth element. In this study, Sc, Sn and C powders were used as raw materials to synthesize a novel ternary Sc2SnC MAX phase via molten salt method. Phase composition and microstructure of Sc2SnC were confirmed by X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscope and X-ray energy spectrum analysis. And, structural stability, lattice parameters, mechanical and electronic properties of Sc2SnC were investigated via density functional theory. The theoretical results show that Sc2SnC is thermodynamically stable, and the Sc2SnC is metallic in nature where the contribution from Sc-3d states dominates the electronic conductivity at the Fermi level. This study provides a route to explore more unknown ternary layered rare earth compounds Ren+1SnCn (Re=Sc, Y, La-Nd, n=1) and corresponding rare earth MXenes.

    Keywords

    The MAX phases are a family of nanolayered ternary carbides or nitrides with a hexagonal lattice structure (P63/mmc), the chemical formula is Mn+1AXn (where M is an early transition metal; A is an element mainly from 13-16; and X is carbon or/and nitrogen, n=1-3)[1,2,3]. Generally, the heterodesmic feature of MAX phases contributes to a unique combination of both metallic and ceramic properties, which have been investigated as promising candidates for structural applications in many fields[4,5,6,7]. Moreover, MAX phases are used as a precursor to synthesize two-dimensional (2D) MXene with many attractive physical and chemical properties, and show promise in a broad range of applications, notably electrochemical energy storage[8,9,10,11]. Due to the continuing efforts from the scientific community, about 155 MAX phases have been reported so far, including some novel MAX phases that A-site elements are late transition metals[12,13,14,15,16]. The theoretical studies have predicted around 665 ternary MAX phases that could be experimentally synthesized[17], for example, the ones which M site element is rare earth Sc.

    As previous reported, Sc2InC was listed as one of possible stable MAX phases[1,3], where the structure, properties and potential applications are investigated via theoretical predictions[18,19,20], but not been experimentally identified yet. The Sc2InC is expected to be a promising candidate for optoelectronic devices for the visible light and ultraviolet regions, as well as coating materials to avoid solar heating[20]. In addition, theoretical calculations indicate that the Sc2CT2 (T= F, OH) MXenes can be promising candidate materials for the next generation electronic devices[21]. Kuchida, et al[22] focused on non- transition metal M2AX compounds which embody Sc, Y, and Lu atoms in M site, however, only polycrystalline sample of Lu2SnC was reported. As a result, the study of new MAX phases taking Sc as M site element is an intriguing and challenging work.

    Now, the common methods to synthesize MAX phases are hot pressing (HP) and spark plasma sintering (SPS). Compared to HP and SPS, the molten salt method is a simple and cost-effective route for preparing MAX phase powders. As a high-temperature ionic solvent, the molten salt bath offers high solvation power and liquid environment for reactants that will greatly facilitate the mass transport and nucleation processes, thus need lower synthesis temperature and bold time[23]. Some MAX phases (e.g. Ti3SiC2, Ti3AlC2, V2AlC, Cr2AlC) have been synthesized by molten salt method[24,25,26,27,28]. In the present work, we synthesized a MAX phase of Sc2SnC in molten salts environment where the Sc element belongs to rare earth. The crystal structure and chemical composition were confirmed by XRD and SEM-EDS, respectively. Furthermore, the structure stability, electronic structure and mechanical properties of Sc2SnC are also be investigated via density functional theory (DFT).

    1 Experimental

    The raw materials used to prepare the MAX phase are scandium (Hunan Rare Earth Metal Materials Research Institute, Hunan, China; ~48 μm (300 mesh), 99.5wt% purity), tin (Target Research Center of General Research Institute for Nonferrous Metals, Beijing, China, ~48 μm (300 mesh), 99.5wt% purity), graphite (Qingdao Tianshengda Graphite Co. Ltd, Shandong, China; ~48 μm (300 mesh), 99wt% purity), sodium chloride (Aladdin Industrial Co. Ltd, Shanghai, China; NaCl, 99.5wt% purity), potassium chloride (Aladdin Industrial Co. Ltd, Shanghai, China; KCl, 99.5wt% purity).

    The powders were mixed in a stoichiometric ratio of Sc : Sn : C=2 : 1.1 : 1 (Due to the melting point of Sn is relatively low, we increased the content ratio of tin for compensating the weight loss of tin at a high temperature, as in the preparation of V2(Sn,A)C MAX phases)[16]. The starting powders of Sc, Sn and graphite are mixed with inorganic salt (NaCl + KCl), and the mole ratio of (Sc + Sn + C) : (NaCl + KCl) was 1 : 10, and the mole ratio of (NaCl : KCl) was 1 : 1. After ground for 10 min, the powder mixture was put into an aluminum oxide boat, and then moved to a tube furnace and heated to 1000 ℃ for 3 h at heating rate of 5 ℃/min under argon atmosphere, respectively. After the reaction was finished, the product was washed, filtered and dried at 40 ℃ in vacuum; and the excess Sn element was removed by ferric chloride (Aladdim Industrial Co. Ltd, Shanghai, China; FeCl3, 99.5wt% purity).

    The phase composition of the samples was determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD, D8 Advance, Bruker AXS, Germany) with Cu Kα radiation. X-ray diffraction patterns were collected at a step size of 0.02° (2θ) with a collection time of 1 s per step. The microstructure and chemical composition were observed by scanning electron microscope (SEM, QUANTA 250 FEG, FEI, USA) equipped with an energy-dispersive spectrometer (EDS), and the EDS values were fitted by XPP (extended Puchou/Pichoir).

    Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were programmed in the CASTEP code[29,30], using the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) as implemented in the Perdew-Breke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional[31,32]. Phonon calculations were carried out to evaluate the dynamical stability using the finite displacement approach, as implemented in CASTEP[33,34]. The equation E= (Ebroken-Ebulk)/S[13] was adopted to calculate the cleavage energy E, where Ebulk and Ebroken represent the total energies of bulk MAX and the cleaving structures respectively with a 1 nm vacuum separation in the corresponding M and A atomic layers, and S is the cross- sectional surface area of the MAX phase materials. The Rietveld refinement of powder XRD pattern of Sc2SnC was by Total Pattern Solution (TOPAS-Academic V6) software.

    2 Results and discussion

    2.1 Phase analysis of the Sc2SnC

    Fig. 1(a) shows the XRD pattern of as-prepared powders synthesized at 1000 ℃ for 3 h, has characteristic peaks at 2θ~12°, 24°, 36°, which neither belong to Sn nor other compounds, indicating that a new MAX phase of Sc2SnC is synthesized (also with minor amount of Sn metal as by-product). In comparison with experimental result, the simulated XRD pattern of Sc2SnC in Fig. 1(b), the peaks positioned at 2θ =12.174°, 24.517°, 36.277°, etc., consist with the experimental peak positions in Fig. 1(a), which further validates the formation of the new MAX phase Sc2SnC.

    Comparison of XRD patterns between (a) powders synthesized through the reaction between Sc, Sn, and C mixtures, and (b) the simulated one of Sc2SnC

    Figure 1.Comparison of XRD patterns between (a) powders synthesized through the reaction between Sc, Sn, and C mixtures, and (b) the simulated one of Sc2SnC

    XRD pattern is important for phase identification and structure analysis. Because no XRD pattern of Sc2SnC was available in previous literatures, the Rietveld refinement of powder XRD pattern of Sc2SnC was conducted. As shown in Fig. 2, the blue crosses represent the experimental diffraction profile (the Sn metal was remove by FeCl3 solution), while the red solid line denotes the theoretical pattern. The theoretical Bragg diffraction positions of Sc2SnC are marked as red line. The gray curve is the deviation between calculated and experimental XRD patterns. The obtained reliability factors are Rp=8.56% and Rwp=11.19%, respectively, indicating good agreement between model and measured data. The space group of Sc2SnC is P63/mmc (194), and the lattice constants measured from XRD pattern are a=0.33692 nm and c=1.46374 nm, respectively. The difference between theoretical calculation and the Rietveld refinement is probably ascribed to the existence of defects in the crystal structure, as the case of V2SnC in the previous report[35]. The atomic positions of Sc2SnC determined from the Rietveld refinement are listed in Table 1.

    Comparison between experimental (blue line) and calculated XRD (red line) pattern of Sc2SnC

    Figure 2.Comparison between experimental (blue line) and calculated XRD (red line) pattern of Sc2SnC

    • Table 1.

      Atomic positions in Sc2SnC determined from the Rietveld refinement

      Table 1.

      Atomic positions in Sc2SnC determined from the Rietveld refinement

      SiteElementxyzSymmetryWyckoff symbol
      MSc1/32/30.57863m4f
      ASn1/32/30.2500m22d
      XC000m2a

    2.2 Microstructural of the Sc2SnC

    It is well known that MAX phases crystallize in hexagonal structures and their grains are generally layered hexagonsin morphology[1]. To confirm that Sc2SnC has a similar microstructure, the microstructure of as-prepared powder was observed by SEM. It can be seen from Fig. 3(a) that Sc2SnC exhibits the microstructure of typical thin hexagons. EDS equipped in SEM detected all constitutive elements (Sc, Sn and C) within these particles (as shown in Fig. 3(b)). Although the EDS analysis is semi-quantitative and the accurate determination of light elements like C is difficult, the relative atomic ratio of (Sc : Sn : C) could be revealed by EDS as about (2 : 1 : 1), consistent with the stoichiometry of 211 MAX phases. The elemental mapping of Sc, Sn and C corroborated that all of these three elements have the same distribution. The above results further confirm that the new MAX phase compound Sc2SnC is experimentally synthesized.

    (a) SEM image and (b) EDS analysis of Sc2SnC, (c) elemental mappings of Sc, Sn and C elements

    Figure 3.(a) SEM image and (b) EDS analysis of Sc2SnC, (c) elemental mappings of Sc, Sn and C elements

    2.3 DFT results

    The structural analysis of Sc2SnC phase was carried out via DFT calculations. Fig. 4(a) shows the ternary- layered carbide crystal structure of Sc2SnC; and the calculated ΔHform (Sc2SnC) is -0.7167 eV, indicating the stability of Sc2SnC phase. The lattice parameters, elastic constants and polycrystalline elastic modulus of Sc2SnC, as well as for other Sn-containing MAX phases are listed in Table 2. From the DFT calculation result, i.e. a= 0.33686, c=1.46532 nm, is very close to experimental results. The mechanical stability of Sc2SnC is justified from the Born stability criteria[36]: C11>0, C11-C12>0, C44>0, (C11-C12)C33-2C13>0. Besides, the dynamical stability of Sc2SnC can also be identified from the phonon dispersion curves in Fig. 4(b). The results performed by theoretical calculations are consistent with experiments. However, compared with other MAX phases (listed in Table 2), it is found that they have lower values of elastic constants (i.e. C11, C33, C44, and C66).

    (a) Crystal structure , (b) calculated phonon dispersion and (c) band structure of Sc2SnC, and (d) projected density of Sc, Sn, and C atom states in the Sc2SnC

    Figure 4.(a) Crystal structure , (b) calculated phonon dispersion and (c) band structure of Sc2SnC, and (d) projected density of Sc, Sn, and C atom states in the Sc2SnC

    • Table 2.

      Theoretically predicted Lattice parameters (nm), calculated elastic constants, Cij (GPa), bulk modulus, B (GPa), shear modulus, G (GPa), and Young’s modulus, E (GPa), Pugh ratio, G/B, and Poisson ratio, v, of different compounds

      Table 2.

      Theoretically predicted Lattice parameters (nm), calculated elastic constants, Cij (GPa), bulk modulus, B (GPa), shear modulus, G (GPa), and Young’s modulus, E (GPa), Pugh ratio, G/B, and Poisson ratio, v, of different compounds

      Compounda/nmc/nmC11C12C13C33C44C66BGEG/BvRef.
      Sc2SnC0.33681.465319763471826753100631570.6300.238This work
      V2SnC0.31341.294333612612230485105190952440.5000.286[35]
      Ti2SnC0.31361.3641337861023291691261761383280.7840.188[39]
      Zr2SnC0.33521.468126980107290148941571103680.7000.215[39]
      Hf2SnC0.33081.4450330541262921671381731323160.7630.195[39]
      Nb2SnC0.32441.37543411061693211831182091263140.6030.250[39]

    The relative small value of C33 indicates that the compound is more compressible along the c-axis compared to other studied compounds; while low C44 indicates being subject to shear deformation along $[11\bar{2}0]$ (0001); and small C66 probably means lower resistance to shear in the <110> direction[20,35,37]. The low shear deformation of Sc2SnC is also reflected from shear modulus G, which represents the resistance to shape change of the polycrystalline material[38]. The calculated value of G/B >0.5 indicates that the phase is brittle in nature following Pugh’s criterion. Furthermore, the obtained value of v (0.238) for Sc2SnC shows that it locates at the boundary between covalent and ionic materials. The calculated band structure of Sc2SnC and the projected density of states (DOS) of Sc, Sn, and C atoms with k-points are shown in Fig. 4(c, d), respectively. Similar to other MAX phases and MAX phase-like compounds, Sc2SnC exhibits metallic nature, and the overlapping between valence and conduction bands across the Fermi level also reveals the presence of metallic bonding, which can be treated as the origin of the quasi-ductility of Sc2SnC (Fig. 4(c)). From Fig. 4(d), it can be observed that the Sc-3d electrons are mainly contributing to the DOS at the Fermi level, and should be involved in the conduction properties, while the minor contributions come from Sn5p electrons.

    3 Conclusions

    In conclusion, a new Sc2SnC MAX phase was successfully synthesized by molten salt method for the first time. The XRD data of Sc2SnC is useful for further phase identification and structure analysis, and Sc2SnC exhibits a typical laminar microstructure similar to other MAX phases. The first-principle calculations were employed to further study structure stability of Sc2SnC MAX phase, and the results show that Sc2SnC is metallic in nature where the contribution from Sc-3d states dominates the electronic conductivity at the Fermi level. This work implies the great potential of the ternary rare-earth metal carbide Ren+1SnCn (Re=Sc, Y, La-Nd, n=1) family waiting for further explore. More importantly, the introduction of rare earth elements can give the special properties of MAX phases, and can be used as a precursor material for preparing rare-earth MXenes.

    [6] J WARD, D BOWDEN, E PRESTAT et al. Corrosion performance of Ti3SiC2, Ti3AlC2, Ti2AlC and Cr2AlC MAX phases in simulated primary water conditions. Corrosion Science, 39, 444-453(2018).

    [16] B LI Y, J LU, M LI et al. Multielemental single-atom-thick A layers in nanolaminated V2(Sn,A)C (A=Fe, Co, Ni, Mn) for tailoring magnetic properties. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 117, 820-825(2020).

    [35] Q XU, Y ZHOU, H ZHANG et al. Theoretical prediction, synthesis, and crystal structure determination of new MAX phase compound V2SnC. Journal of Advanced Ceramics, 29, 481-492(2020).

    [36] M BORN, D MISRA R. On the stability of crystal lattices. Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 36, 466-478(1940).

    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Youbing LI, Yanqing QIN, Ke CHEN, Lu CHEN, Xiao ZHANG, Haoming DING, Mian LI, Yiming ZHANG, Shiyu DU, Zhifang CHAI, Qing HUANG. Molten Salt Synthesis of Nanolaminated Sc2SnC MAX Phase[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2021, 36(7): 773

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: RESEARCH LETTER

    Received: Sep. 9, 2020

    Accepted: --

    Published Online: Nov. 25, 2021

    The Author Email: HUANG Qing (huangqing@nimte.ac.cn)

    DOI:10.15541/jim20200529

    Topics