Acta Optica Sinica, Volume. 45, Issue 6, 0601007(2025)
Sensitivity Analysis of Simultaneous Remote Sensing of Carbon Dioxide and Water Vapor Isotope Using LiDAR
Carbon dioxide (CO2) and water vapor (H2O) play crucial roles in global climate change through the carbon?water cycle. Semi-heavy water, as a stable isotope of water vapor, helps deepen our understanding of the water cycle process. A large number of active and passive remote sensing technologies based on absorption spectroscopy have been applied to the detection of atmospheric CO2 and H216O. However, passive remote sensing, which relies on sunlight, cannot provide continuous day-and-night monitoring, while active remote sensing based on differential absorption LiDAR (DIAL) can effectively compensate for this limitation. Research has shown that H216O is the primary interfering gas in CO2 detection that causes measurement errors. Since dual-wavelength DIAL can only measure one type of gas, the interference effect of H216O on CO2 is minimized by selecting an appropriate absorption line, where the absorptions of H216O at the on-line and off-line wavelengths are almost equal. However, HD16O, a stable isotope of H216O, also affects the detection accuracy of CO2, though this is rarely addressed. In addition, in terms of vertical height, especially within the troposphere, H2O and atmospheric parameters can vary significantly. To date, no DIAL system can simultaneously provide vertical profile measurements for CO2 and HD16O, and there has been limited theoretical analysis and feasibility verification of this. In the present study, we report the sensitivity analysis of simultaneous remote sensing of atmospheric CO2 and HD16O profiles using LiDAR. This analysis is based on the MODTRAN atmospheric model. This sensitivity analysis aids in improving the inversion algorithm for the concentration profiles of CO2 and HD16O, which is significant for enhancing the detection capability and inversion accuracy of both ground-based and airborne DIAL systems. It also provides a theoretical framework for accurate remote sensing of greenhouse gases and a deeper understanding of climate change in the context of carbon neutrality.
The sensitivity analysis of simultaneous remote sensing of atmospheric CO2 and HD16O profiles using LiDAR, based on the MODTRAN atmospheric model, is conducted. First, the mixed spectral lines of CO2 and HD16O under different atmospheric models are calculated using HITRAN spectroscopy parameters, and the feasibility of simultaneous measurement of these two gases by LiDAR is verified by selecting appropriate absorption lines. Next, considering the variation of atmospheric parameters with vertical height, the column and range-resolved concentration inversion errors of CO2 and HD16O are evaluated based on the optimization of weight functions and spectral line shapes. Further investigation is conducted on atmospheric factors, the frequency stability of LiDAR laser emissions, the overlapping effects of CO2 and HD16O, and the influence of altitude changes on concentration inversion errors.
In response to potential sources of error in the inversion of column and range-resolved concentrations of CO2 and HD16O, we comprehensively consider atmospheric factors, laser frequency stability, the overlap effect of the two gases, and altitude-induced changes in concentration inversion. When the temperature variation is ±1 K, the column concentrations of CO2 and HD16O reach their maximum temperature sensitivity of 0.18% and 0.09% at altitudes of 12.6 km and 23.4 km, respectively. The range-resolved concentrations of the two gases show maximum sensitivity of 0.21% and 0.38% near the tropopause. At a pressure variation of ±0.5 hPa, the sensitivity of both column and range-resolved concentrations of CO2 and HD16O gradually increases with altitude. The column concentration errors for CO2 and HD16O reach 0.33% and 0.03% at the top of the stratosphere, while the range-resolved concentration errors reach 0.54% and 0.83% at 20 km. The frequency sensitivity for CO2 column and range-resolved concentrations is generally higher than that of HD16O, and the frequency sensitivity at the center of both gas absorption lines is close to zero at any altitude. When the H2O mixing ratio variation is 5%, errors in CO2 column and range-resolved concentrations due to overlapping effects decrease with increasing altitude, reaching 0.15% and 0.01% at sea level in tropical and sub-arctic winter models, respectively. For altitudes greater than 5 km, the range-resolved concentration error of CO2 at the line centers for all atmospheric models is less than 0.001%, and the error caused by the overlapping effect can be ignored. When the tropic model and the 1976 U.S. standard atmospheric model are used, without considering the absorption of HD16O, the errors for the range-resolved CO2 concentrations at sea level are 1.87% and 0.60%, respectively. Even under the sub-arctic winter model, the column concentration error at the center line reaches 0.17%, which confirms the non-negligible role of HD16O in CO2 inversion. In addition, with an 80 dB signal-to-noise ratio at the LiDAR origin in mid-latitude regions, the altitude sensitivity of CO2 and HD16O column concentrations at the top of the troposphere is 0.10% and 0.18%, respectively, while the sensitivity of range-resolved concentrations is 1.1% and 6.3%, respectively.
To meet precise greenhouse gas monitoring requirements, we conduct a theoretical analysis on the simultaneous remote sensing of atmospheric CO2 and HD16O using LiDAR. Based on the MODTRAN atmospheric model, independent and mixed optical depth spectra of CO2, H216O, and HD16O are derived under different models. The absorption lines suitable for detecting CO2 and HD16O are identified by analyzing the relative absorption intensities and spectral parameters of each gas. The spectral broadening of CO2 and HD16O caused by collision and Doppler effects is calculated based on temperature and pressure profiles from the 1976 U.S. standard atmospheric model. The two spectra exhibit Voigt line shapes in the altitude ranges of 9.4?34.5 km and 8.3?33.8 km, and their absorption lines are optimized for different altitudes. The systematic errors in range-resolved and column concentrations of CO2 and HD16O, considering factors like atmospheric conditions, laser frequency stability, and the overlapping effect of the two gases, are analyzed. Our findings confirm that HD16O plays a critical role in CO2 inversion at the R16 line. Considering the errors introduced by these factors, inversion accuracy for CO2 and HD16O column concentrations of better than 1% and 2%, respectively, and range-resolved concentrations of 2% and 8%, respectively, can be achieved in the troposphere of mid-latitudes.
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Saifen Yu, Zhen Zhang, Haiyun Xia. Sensitivity Analysis of Simultaneous Remote Sensing of Carbon Dioxide and Water Vapor Isotope Using LiDAR[J]. Acta Optica Sinica, 2025, 45(6): 0601007
Category: Atmospheric Optics and Oceanic Optics
Received: Jul. 30, 2024
Accepted: Oct. 14, 2024
Published Online: Mar. 27, 2025
The Author Email: Zhang Zhen (003514@nuist.edu.cn)