NUCLEAR TECHNIQUES, Volume. 45, Issue 11, 110501(2022)
Evaluation of radiation accident emergency drill based on AHP-FCE
Figures & Tables(8)
Fig. 1. Evaluation index system of radiation accident emergency exercise
Table 1. Evaluation index system for radiation accident emergency drill
View tableView in ArticleTable 1. Evaluation index system for radiation accident emergency drill
总目标General objective 演习阶段Exercise phase 具体指标Specific target 辐射事故应急演习效果
Effect of radiation emergency exercise
前期准备
Preliminary preparation
演习策划Exercise planning 经费预算Outlay budget 情景设定Scenario setting 文件编制Documentation 演习保障
Exercise protection
人员保障Personal security 经费保障Financial security 设备保障Equipment support 场地保障Site protection 应急启动
Emergency activation
事故报告Incident report 事故核实Accident verification 应急响应
Emergency response
指挥协调Command coordination 处置决策Disposal decisions 应急通信Emergency communication 应急监测Emergency monitoring 现场处置On-site disposal 意外情况及处置Handling of the accident 后续工作
Follow-up work
演习总结Exercise summary 预案修订Proposed amendments
Table 2. Scale
View tableView in ArticleTable 2. Scale
标度Scale 定义Definition 意义Meaning 2,4,6,8 上述判断的中值The median of the above judgments 1 同样重要Equally important 指标i与指标j重要性相同Index i has the same importance as index j 3 稍微重要A little important 指标i的重要性稍微高于指标j Indicator i is slightly more important than indicator j 5 明显重要Obviously important 指标i的重要性明显高于指标jThe importance of index i was significantly higher than that of index j 7 强烈重要Highly important 指标i的重要性强烈高于指标jThe importance of indicator i was strongly higher than that of indicator j 9 极端重要Extremely important 指标i的重要性极端高于指标jThe importance of indicator i is extremely higher than that of indicator j
Table 3. Average RI value reference table
View tableView in ArticleTable 3. Average RI value reference table
阶数Order number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 RI 0 0 0.52 0.89 1.12 1.26 1.36 1.41 1.46 1.49
Table 4. The weight calculation results of the evaluation indexes at all levels of the radiation accident emergency drill
View tableView in ArticleTable 4. The weight calculation results of the evaluation indexes at all levels of the radiation accident emergency drill
总目标（A层）
Overall objective
(tier A)
一级指标（B层）
Primary index
(tier B)
权重
Weight
一级指标
一致性检验
Consistency
test of first-
class index
二级指标（C层）
Secondary indicators
(tier C)
二级指标
一致性检验
Second-level
index
consistency test
权重
Weight
总权重
Total weight
辐射事故应急
演习效果
Effect of
radiation accident
emergency drill
前期准备（B1）
Preparation (B1)
0.108 3 λmax=5.026 1
CI=0.029 20
CR=0.026 07
演习策划（C1）
Exercise planning (C1)
― 0.666 7 0.072 2 演习脚本质量（C2）
Exercise script quality
(C2)
0.333 3 0.036 1 演习保障（B2）
Exercise protection (B2)
0.143 5 人员保障（C3）
Personal security (C3)
λmax=4.162 1
CI=0.054 03
CR=0.060 7
0.547 1 0.078 5 经费保障（C4）
Financial security (C4)
0.079 6 0.011 4 设备保障（C5）
Equipment support (C5)
0.267 3 0.038 4 场地保障（C6）
Site protection (C6)
0.106 1 0.015 2 应急启动（B3）
Emergency start (B3)
0.216 6 事故报告（C7）
Incident report (C7)
― 0.666 7 0.072 2 事故核实（C8）
Accident verification
(C8)
0.333 3 0.144 4 应急响应（B4）
Emergency response (B4)
0.244 6 指挥协调（C9）
Command coordination
(C9)
λmax=5.411 8
CI=0.102 95
CR=0.091 9
0.183 1 0.044 8 应急通信（C10）
Emergency
communication (C10)
0.080 6 0.019 7 应急监测（C11）
Emergency monitoring
(C11)
0.513 7 0.125 7 现场处置（C12）
On-site disposal (C12)
0.178 7 0.043 7 意外情况及处置（C13）
Handling of the
accident (C13)
0.043 9 0.010 7 后续工作（B5）
Follow-up work (B5)
0.287 0 演习总结（C14）
Exercise summary (C14)
― 0.875 0.251 1 预案修订（C15）
Proposed amendments
(C15)
0.125 0.035 9
Table 5. Comprehensive scores of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 1
View tableView in ArticleTable 5. Comprehensive scores of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 1
总目标（A层）
Overall objective
(tier A)
综合得分
Composite score
一级指标（B层）
Primary index (tier B)
分值
Score
二级指标（C层）
Secondary indicators (tier C)
分值
Score
辐射事故应急
演习效果
Effect of radiation
accident emergency
drill
86.25 前期准备（B1）
Preparation (B1)
85.78 演习策划（C1）Exercise planning (C1) 85.67 演习脚本质量（C2）Exercise script quality(C2) 85.99 演习保障（B2）
Exercise protection (B2)
81.07 人员保障（C3）Personal security (C3) 86.16 经费保障（C4）Financial security (C4) 65.73 设备保障（C5）Equipment support (C5) 82.93 场地保障（C6）Site protection (C6) 61.61 应急启动（B3）
Emergency start (B3)
81.37 事故报告（C7）Incident report (C7) 79.82 事故核实（C8）Accident verification(C8) 82.14 应急响应（B4）
Emergency response (B4)
89.87 指挥协调（C9）Command coordination(C9) 95.28 应急通信（C10）Emergency communication (C10) 79.31 应急监测（C11）Emergency monitoring(C11) 91.63 现场处置（C12）On-site disposal (C12) 87.07 意外情况及处置（C13）Handling of the accident (C13) 77.54 后续工作（B5）
Follow-up work (B5)
89.62 演习总结（C14）Exercise summary (C14) 94.37 预案修订（C15）Proposed amendments (C15) 56.37
Table 6. Comprehensive scores of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 2
View tableView in ArticleTable 6. Comprehensive scores of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 2
总目标（A层）
Overall objective
(tier A)
综合得分
Composite score
一级指标（B层）
Primary index (tier B)
分值
Score
二级指标（C层）
Secondary indicators (tier C)
分值
Score
辐射事故应急
演习效果
Effect of radiation
accident emergency
drill
81.84 前期准备（B1）
Preparation (B1)
82.51 演习策划（C1）Exercise planning (C1) 85.45 演习脚本质量（C2）Exercise script quality (C2) 76.59 演习保障（B2）
Exercise protection (B2)
80.27 人员保障（C3）Personal security (C3) 86.03 经费保障（C4）Financial security (C4) 67.15 设备保障（C5）Equipment support (C5) 75.48 场地保障（C6）Site protection (C6) 72.42 应急启动（B3）
Emergency start (B3)
86.80 事故报告（C7）Incident report (C7) 88.35 事故核实（C8）Accident verification (C8) 86.03 应急响应（B4）
Emergency response (B4)
80.84 指挥协调（C9）Command coordination (C9) 84.33 应急通信（C10）Emergency communication (C10) 85.01 应急监测（C11）Emergency monitoring (C11) 78.74 现场处置（C12）On-site disposal (C12) 85.01 意外情况及处置（C13）Handling of the accident (C13) 66.21 后续工作（B5）
Follow-up work (B5)
79.49 演习总结（C14）Exercise summary (C14) 81.55 预案修订（C15）Proposed amendments (C15) 65.07
Table 7. Comprehensive score of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 3
View tableView in ArticleTable 7. Comprehensive score of the evaluation indexes at all levels of Example 3
总目标（A层）
Overall objective
(tier A)
综合得分
Composite score
一级指标（B层）
Primary index (tier B)
分值
Score
二级指标（C层）
Secondary indicators (tier C)
分值
Score
辐射事故应急
演习效果
Effect of radiation
accident emergency
drill
86.19 前期准备（B1）
Preparation (B1)
88.16 演习策划（C1）Exercise planning (C1) 87.77 演习脚本质量（C2）Exercise script quality (C2) 88.94 演习保障（B2）
Exercise protection (B2)
83.08 人员保障（C3）Personal security (C3) 83.19 经费保障（C4）Financial security (C4) 78.11 设备保障（C5）Equipment support (C5) 87.63 场地保障（C6）Site protection (C6) 74.75 应急启动（B3）
Emergency start (B3)
84.91 事故报告（C7）Incident report (C7) 83.20 事故核实（C8）Accident verification (C8) 85.76 应急响应（B4）
Emergency response (B4)
86.08 指挥协调（C9）Command coordination (C9) 85.86 应急通信（C10）Emergency communication (C10) 79.04 应急监测（C11）Emergency monitoring (C11) 83.14 现场处置（C12）On-site disposal (C12) 90.15 意外情况及处置（C13）Handling of the accident (C13) 82.68 后续工作（B5）
Follow-up work (B5)
88.06 演习总结（C14）Exercise summary (C14) 90.95 预案修订（C15）Proposed amendments (C15) 67.86
Tools
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Fanxing MENG, Ming YANG, Hao WANG, Lujian SUN, Jiangqi FANG, Jinzheng YANG. Evaluation of radiation accident emergency drill based on AHP-FCE[J]. NUCLEAR TECHNIQUES, 2022, 45(11): 110501
Paper Information
Category: Research Articles
Received: Jul. 4, 2022
Accepted: --
Published Online: Nov. 25, 2022
The Author Email:
© Copyright 2018-2021 | Chinese Laser Press.
All Rights Reserved 沪ICP备15018463号-20