Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, Volume. 58, Issue 1, 100002(2021)

Research Progress on Security LiDAR

Song Zhaoqi1,2, Zhu Jingguo1、*, Xie Tianpeng1,2, Li Feng1, Jiang Chenghao1, Guo Wenju1, Wang Chunxiao1, and Jiang Yan1
Author Affiliations
  • 1Institute of Mircroelectronics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100029, China
  • 2University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(23)
    Application scenarios. (a) Perimeter protection[9]; (b) industrial monitoring[10]; (c) intrusion warning[11]; (d) cultural relic protection[12]
    Drones equipped with security LiDAR for detecting intrusion target in forest scenario[15]
    Working principle of traditional mechanical LiDAR[21]
    SICK safety laser scanner series[22]
    Schematic of MEMS. (a) Working principle of MEMS LiDAR[24]; (b) MEMS scanning mirror[25]
    Working principle of Flash LiDAR[21]
    Working scenario and experimental results of Flash LiDAR[31]. (a) Experimental setup with real-time tracking on PC and Flash LiDAR on pan-tilt head; (b) point cloud of scenario; (c) intensity view of scenario with person marked center; (d) range view of scenario with person marked center
    Working principle of OPA[33]
    Working principle of Quanergy S3 LiDAR[34]
    Relationship between maximum permissible exposure and wavelength[35]
    Miniaturized LiDAR. (a) RealSense L515[40]; (b) SICK safety LiDAR nanoScan3[41]
    Micrograph of fully differential main amplifier chip[42]
    Working flow chart of FMCW LiDAR[44]
    Working principle of coherent LiDAR[45]. (a) Schematic of solid-state LiDAR system with transmittable and receivable optical phased array; (b) chip containing LiDAR system on top of dime
    Equipment diagram of security system[50]. (a) Optosafe Opto-Q-Guard system; (b) electronic equipment monitoring
    Security robots. (a) Intelligent inspection robot equipped with LiDAR[52]; (b) Orby-One tracking robot[53]
    • Table 1. Detecting targets in different security scenarios

      View table

      Table 1. Detecting targets in different security scenarios

      Security scenarioDectect object
      Perimeter protectionPeople, animal, and weapon
      Traffic controlPeople, car, animal, and rolling stone
      Cultural relic protectionPeople
      Airborne intrusion warningUAV, bird, and people
    • Table 2. Product indicators of traditional security LiDAR

      View table

      Table 2. Product indicators of traditional security LiDAR

      CompanyProduct modelAccuracy /mmAngular resolution /(°)Mass /kgSize /(mm×mm×mm)Cost /USD
      RieglVZ-400i50.0007 (horizontal) and0.0005 (vertical)9.7206×206×308Over 105
      OptechGalaxy T2000827340×340×250Over 106
      LeicaScanStation P5030.002212.5238×358×395115240
      TrimbleTrimble GX70.003 (horizontal) and0.004 (vertical)13323×343×404183300
    • Table 3. Product indicators of foreign mainstream security LiDAR[16-18]

      View table

      Table 3. Product indicators of foreign mainstream security LiDAR[16-18]

      CompanyTechnological regimeProduct modelMaximum measurement distance /mField of view /(°)Mass /kgWavelength /nmCost /USD
      SICKMechanicaloutdoorScan342751.158504834
      nanoScan332750.67905
      TiM-S252700.25850
      S30032701.209052437
      S300071903.309054500
      TiM1xx102000.09850782
      HOKUYOMechanicalUAM-05LP202700.809051200
      UTM-30LX602700.379054800
      UXM-30LX301900.809054800
      UST-10LX302700.139051600
      YVT-35LX35 (horizontal) and 14(vertical)210(horizontal) and40(vertical)0.659057500
      QuanergyMechanicalM8300@ρ=80%360(horizontal) and20(vertical)1.09055000
      OPAS3-1150@ρ=80%120(horizontal) and10(vertical)0.5905250
      OusterFlashOS0-325595(vertical)0.4458506000
      OS1-3212045(vertical)0.4458508000
      OS2-3224025(vertical)0.93085016000
    • Table 4. Product indicators of domestic mainstream security LiDAR[19]

      View table

      Table 4. Product indicators of domestic mainstream security LiDAR[19]

      CompanyTechnological regimeProduct modelMaximum measurement distance /mField of view /(°)Mass /kgWavelength /nmCost /USD
      Galaxy electronicMechanicalGL-11xx30@ρ=10%2701.80905
      GL-21xx20@ρ=10%1801.00905
      GL-41xx260@ρ=10%10014.00905
      GL-52xx10@ρ=10%3000.75905
      LiShen inelligent systemMechanicalCX16-151C150@ρ=30%360(horizontal) and20(vertical)0.879052800
      CX32-151A150@ρ=30%360(horizontal) and31(vertical)1.509058500
      MEMSLS20C200120(horizontal) and20(vertical)9051500
      LS21AOver 20060 (horizontal) and20(vertical)15501500
      BenewakeMechanicalTF0222@ρ=90%3.00.052905162
      TF03180@ρ=90%0.50.077905229
      FlashCE03-D28@ρ=90%240.00.3568501500
      LorentechFlashIT series80@ρ=80%60(horizontal) and45(vertical)0.62850
      IG series40@ρ=80%60(horizontal) and30(vertical)0.38850
      IM series20@ρ=80%30(horizontal) and20(vertical)0.30850
    • Table 5. Comparison of three ranging schemes

      View table

      Table 5. Comparison of three ranging schemes

      SchemeMeasurement distanceAccuracyAnti-interferencePowerCost
      TOFBestWorstWorstWorstHigh
      AMCWWorstBetterBetterBetterMedium
      FMCWBetterBestBestBestHigh
    • Table 6. Comparison of four scanning schemes

      View table

      Table 6. Comparison of four scanning schemes

      Scanning schemeMeasurement distanceAccuracyCostSizeTechnological readiness levelStability
      MechanicalBetterBetterHighWorstBestWorst
      MEMSWorstWorstMediumBetterBetterBetter
      FlashWorstWorstLowBetterBetterBetter
      OPAWorstWorstLowBetterWorst-
    • Table 7. Comparison of three light sources for LiDAR

      View table

      Table 7. Comparison of three light sources for LiDAR

      WavelengthAnti-interferenceEye- safetyHype cycleCost
      850 nmBetterWorstWorstBetter
      950 nmBetterWorstBetterBetter
      1550 nmWorstBetterWorstWorst
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Song Zhaoqi, Zhu Jingguo, Xie Tianpeng, Li Feng, Jiang Chenghao, Guo Wenju, Wang Chunxiao, Jiang Yan. Research Progress on Security LiDAR[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2021, 58(1): 100002

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Reviews

    Received: Mar. 31, 2020

    Accepted: --

    Published Online: Jan. 27, 2021

    The Author Email: Jingguo Zhu (zhujingguo@ime.ac.cn)

    DOI:10.3788/LOP202158.0100002

    Topics