Journal of Applied Optics, Volume. 44, Issue 5, 927(2023)

Principle and research progress of four-quadrant detector spot detection

Zheng LI1... Haoyu XU1, Jingyuan LIANG1, Ying ZHANG1, and Xizheng KE1,23,* |Show fewer author(s)
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Automation and Information Engineering, Xi'an University of Technology, Xi'an 710048, China
  • 2School of Information Engineering, Xi'an University, Xi'an 710065, China
  • 3Shaanxi Civil-Military Integration Key Laboratory of Intelligence Collaborative Networks, Xi'an 710048 China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(33)
    Uniformly-distributed circular light spot
    Gaussian-distributed circular light spot
    Uniformly-distributed elliptical light spot
    Gaussian-distributed elliptical light spot
    Gaussian-distributed ring light spots
    Schematic diagram of QD
    Schematic diagram of internal structure of LUCE terminal
    Schematic block diagram of LCE
    Structure diagram of BLISL system
    Schematic diagram of laser tracking system based on quadrant APD
    Schematic diagram of KODEN receiver
    Schematic diagram of experimental device
    Basic block diagram of SLT
    Optical path diagram of LLST
    QD output values under different spot modes
    QD output values under different spot radius
    QD output values under different deadband widths
    QD output values under different scales of background light
    Variation curve of standard deviation of spot position under different SNR
    Simulation comparison under different positioning algorithms
    Effect of different quadrant response uniformity on QD output
    Offset of X and Y axis under different spot models
    Structure diagram of beam-alignment detection system
    Missing spot detection image
    Complete spot detection image
    QD output diagram during adjustment process
    Tracking and communication composite detection system
    Structure diagram of micro nano laser communication terminal system
    • Table 1. Comparison of three detectors

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 1. Comparison of three detectors

      参数QDCCDPSD
      性能可靠可靠可靠
      驱动电路复杂较复杂简单
      信号处理复杂复杂简单
      噪声处理外电路窄带滤波复杂外电路窄带滤波
      响应时间<4 ns1 μs左右0.5 μs左右
      极限分辨率0.01 μm像元间距(几微米)0.3 μs
    • Table 2. Summary of research progress on influencing factors of spot detection

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 2. Summary of research progress on influencing factors of spot detection

      年份研究人员研究内容
      2007徐代升提出了光斑大小优化设计,改善系统性能
      2010赵馨等人研究了QD的各种性能及外部环境对其性能的影响,并进行了实验测试
      2015张辉等人推导出高斯光斑模型下位置检测精度的数学模型
      2016张骏等人对QD定位误差的影响进行了研究,并提出了相应的修正方法
      2017李世艳提出了一种光斑检测方法,减小了检测误差
      2021李树德等人研究噪声因素对QD光斑位置定位的影响
      2022刁宽等人建立了光斑半径、能量分布和探测器死区等影响因素下QD输出与光斑位置的表征方程
    • Table 3. Summary of research progress on spot detection algorithms

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 3. Summary of research progress on spot detection algorithms

      年份研究人员研究内容
      2009陈勇等人提出将插值法和对角线算法相结合的一种改进算法,将测角误差控制在0.1°之内
      2012司栋森等人提出了增益可调的快速跟踪定位算法,将跟踪精度提高到0.049 7 mm
      2012陈梦苇等人对各种光斑模型讨论了和差、对角线、Δ/Σ和对数四种算法,并进行了比较
      2015WU J B 等人提出了Composite拟合算法,提高了测量精度
      2017郭小康等人简化了二段式多项式拟合算法,将精度提高到10−4 mm数量级
      2021苟晔鹏等人提出了基于无穷积分拟合方法的改进算法,提高了灵敏度
      2021秦立存等人改进高斯光斑模型下的定位算法,均方根误差减小60.4%
    • Table 4. Summary of research progress on spot detection systems

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 4. Summary of research progress on spot detection systems

      年份研究人员研究内容
      2003王岱等人设计了双轴跟踪控制试验演示系统
      2013ZHANG W等人研制了一种利用QD做光斑检测探测器的小型激光跟踪系统
      2017范新坤等人提出了使用雪崩二极管型QD实现跟踪与通信复用的方案,角分辨率为0.8 μrad
      2018林鑫等人设计了一套基于QD的激光束二维扫描跟踪系统,并进行了测试
      2019刘思鸣等人提出了一种基于QD的激光跟踪系统,跟踪误差约为0.1%
      2019王睿扬等人设计数字跟踪通信复合接收机,探测灵敏度为−30 dBm
      2020王淋正等人提出了一种中心开孔型四象限探测器光纤定位技术,并设计了定位算法
      2021KE X Z等人设计了一种新型机载激光通信结构
      2022陈韵等人设计微纳激光通信终端,跟踪误差为84 μrad
    • Table 5. Summary of spot detection algorithms

      View table
      View in Article

      Table 5. Summary of spot detection algorithms

      函数名称优点缺点
      加减算法灵敏度和线性范围较为平衡线性范围较窄
      对角线算法线性范围较宽灵敏度较低
      差比和算法灵敏度高线性范围窄
      对数算法线性范围宽灵敏度较差
      函数拟合法简单、易实现拟合效果取决于拟合函数
      归一化中心法公式简单、计算速度快、对硬件要求较低使用范围小
      多项式拟合法检测范围较大、检测精度较高公式复杂、对硬件要求高
      无穷积分法检测精度较高未考虑探测器死区和大小,检测误差较高
      Boltzmann函数拟合法检测精度较高检测误差较高
      Composite拟合算法检测误差较低、检测精度高精度难以再次提升
      无穷积分拟合改进算法检测精度高、计算量小,对硬件要求较低反求导过程较为困难,适应范围小
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Zheng LI, Haoyu XU, Jingyuan LIANG, Ying ZHANG, Xizheng KE. Principle and research progress of four-quadrant detector spot detection[J]. Journal of Applied Optics, 2023, 44(5): 927

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Research Articles

    Received: May. 15, 2023

    Accepted: --

    Published Online: Mar. 12, 2024

    The Author Email: KE Xizheng (柯熙政)

    DOI:10.5768/JAO202344.0509001

    Topics