Salmonids is a typical cold-water fish with high economic value and promising market prospects. As one of the important economic fish in the world[
Journal of Semiconductors, Volume. 44, Issue 2, 023103(2023)
A brief review of novel nucleic acid test biosensors and their application prospects for salmonids viral diseases detection
Viral diseases represent one of the major threats for salmonids aquaculture. Early detection and identification of viral pathogens is the main prerequisite prior to undertaking effective prevention and control measures. Rapid, sensitive, efficient and portable detection method is highly essential for fish viral diseases detection. Biosensor strategies are highly prevalent and fulfill the expanding demands of on-site detection with fast response, cost-effectiveness, high sensitivity, and selectivity. With the development of material science, the nucleic acid biosensors fabricated by semiconductor have shown great potential in rapid and early detection or screening for diseases at salmonids fisheries. This paper reviews the current detection development of salmonids viral diseases. The present limitations and challenges of salmonids virus diseases surveillance and early detection are presented. Novel nucleic acid semiconductor biosensors are briefly reviewed. The perspective and potential application of biosensors in the on-site detection of salmonids diseases are discussed.Viral diseases represent one of the major threats for salmonids aquaculture. Early detection and identification of viral pathogens is the main prerequisite prior to undertaking effective prevention and control measures. Rapid, sensitive, efficient and portable detection method is highly essential for fish viral diseases detection. Biosensor strategies are highly prevalent and fulfill the expanding demands of on-site detection with fast response, cost-effectiveness, high sensitivity, and selectivity. With the development of material science, the nucleic acid biosensors fabricated by semiconductor have shown great potential in rapid and early detection or screening for diseases at salmonids fisheries. This paper reviews the current detection development of salmonids viral diseases. The present limitations and challenges of salmonids virus diseases surveillance and early detection are presented. Novel nucleic acid semiconductor biosensors are briefly reviewed. The perspective and potential application of biosensors in the on-site detection of salmonids diseases are discussed.
1. Introduction
Salmonids is a typical cold-water fish with high economic value and promising market prospects. As one of the important economic fish in the world[
The biosensors have attracted the researchers due to superior performance in sensitivity, low sample, high throughput and potential for miniaturization[
Here, we give a brief description of the current development of salmonids viral diseases detection. And then the present limitations and challenges of early detection for salmonids viral diseases are proposed. Finally, advances of nucleic acid semiconductor biosensors which have potential to apply for on-site early detection of salmonids viral diseases are introduced and the prospects are put forwarded.
2. Salmonids viral diseases detection developments
In 2021, the economic losses caused by diseases in China's aquaculture were about 53.9 billion RMB. Due to the rapid transmission, high mortality and difficulty in treatment of salmonids viruses, the viral diseases outbreaks have resulted in significant economic losses for salmonid fishes. IHN and IPN are the most prevalent two viral diseases of farmed salmonids in China. IHN caused by IHNV is one of the most contagious viral diseases in salmonids that should be reported to the World Organization for Animal Health (WOAH), which can lead to significant mortality rates and huge economic losses on the salmonid farming industry[
Detection and surveillance on farmed salmonids diseases in China mainly follows the traditional workflow which transport live fish to the testing laboratory (
Figure 1.(Color online) The traditional workflow of salmonids diseases detection and surveillance.
The tests of salmonids viruses used in the laboratory mainly are the traditional methods including virological, immunological and nucleic acid test methods. The viral culture needs too much time for isolating and authenticating. Moreover, there is no sensitive cell lines for some viruses of aquatic animals[
3. Salmonids viral diseases detection limits and challenges
The current salmonids virus detection and monitoring mode are time-consuming, high cost and limited to laboratory. Firstly, the traditional monitoring mode consumes lengthy time and financial costs during the transportation of samples because aquaculture farms are usually located in lakes, reservoirs and sea areas far from towns and transportation arteries. And the temperature, dissolved oxygen, pH and other conditions of the water during transportation are difficult to control, which are distinct from the living environment of fish and virus, leading to the inaccurate results. This will affect the fish farmers take timely and effective prevention and control measures. In addition, as stated, the widely applied detection method in practice concentrated on the traditional nucleic acid-based methods. However, their detection is too traditional and cumbersome to detect on field. Sophisticated instruments, high power condition, long time and professional staff cause traditional RT-PCR or RT-qPCR non-amenable for on-site and real-time detection[
The limitations and problems existing related to the above-mentioned encourage researchers to discover and develop more robust and accurate detection systems for efficient on-site detection and screening[
4. Nucleic acid semiconductor biosensors
Semiconductor materials such as silicon (Si), TiO2, quantum dots (QDs) and indium tin oxide (ITO) are widely used in biosensors. Researchers have developed highly sensitive nucleic acid amplification biosensors and amplification-free biosensors based on the properties of semiconductor materials. In addition, microfluidics researches on on-site detection highlights integrated sample-to-detection chip for nucleic acid test assays. They can realize nucleic acid tests implemented on a portable, miniaturized, and integrated device with rapid and sensitive results readout[
4.1. Nucleic acid amplification biosensors
In combination with classical PCR amplification and isothermal amplification technology such as LAMP, helicase dependent amplification (HDA) which are more suitable for on-site detection[
Si is the most commonly used material in large-scale semiconductor biosensors manufacturing, which can greatly reduce the fabricating costs. A portable and battery-powered PCR device which integrated a PCR thermal control system, a PCR reaction chip and the end-point fluorescence detection system was developed by Jieet al. The disposable reaction chips were fabricated with a silicon substrate due to its excellent thermal conductivity, silicone rubber and a quartz plate. The PCR thermal control system was developed using Al thin-film heaters and RTDs to provide fast and precise temperature conditions with an average heating rate of 32 °C/s and an average cooling rate of 7.5 °C/s. The time consumption of the 40 cycles of PCR was less than 1 h[
Figure 2.(Color online) (a) Schematic illustration of a TriSilix chip and photographs of the actual device[50]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2020, Springer Nature. (b) Schematic illustration for CdS/MoS2 heterojunction-enhanced photoelectrochemical sensing strategy coupling with CHA and hemin-mediated chemiluminescence[54]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2016, Elsevier.
ITO is a conductive and transparent oxide that has advantages of high stability, ease of combination with microfabrication processes, which is used as an electrode material for biosensors[
Molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) is a typical transition-metal dichalcogenide semiconductor which has unique optical, electronic and catalytic properties. Zang and coauthors developed a CdS/MoS2 heterojunction-based photoelectrochemical DNA biosensor. The CdS/MoS2 photocathode was produced by the stepwise assembly of MoS2 and CdS QDs on ITO. The dual hemin-labeled DNA probe was introduced on high-efficiency CdS/MoS2 electrode via catalytic hairpin assembly (CHA) cycling reaction. This ultrasensitive biosensor achieved a detection limit of 0.39 fM[
4.2. Nucleic acid amplification-free biosensors
The principle of nucleic acid amplification-free biosensors depends on the hybridization through spontaneous hydrogen bonding between the target nucleic acid and its complementary strand[
A biosensor for the Cauliflower Mosaic Virus 35S (CaMV35S) promoter detection was reported to distinguish transgenic soybean from non-transgenic samples. The Au nanoparticles-reduced graphene oxide acted as a nanocarrier to immobilize the thiol-functional probe, and the SiO2@CdTe QDs core-shell nanoparticles tagged with the amino-functional probe acted as signal indicators, respectively. In the presence of target DNA of CaMV35S, the binding of tDNA with two probes through the high specific DNA hybridization led to the fabrication of sandwich structure, and thus the high loading of the signal indicators SiO2@CdTe QDs at the electrode surface, which increased the PEC signal. The increased signal depended on the concentration of tDNA and the low detection limit of 0.05 pM was obtained[
Figure 3.(Color online) (a) Schematic illustration of the fabrication procedure of the CaMV35S promoter detection biosensor based on the application of SiO2@CdTe QDs[56]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2016, Elsevier. (b) Schematic illustration of biosensor strategies based on the application of dTiO2–x[57]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2018, ACS. (c) Schematic illustration of the label-free electrochemical DNA assay based on nanoMoS2 modified electrode (nanoMoS2/CPE)[59]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2015, Elsevier. (d) Schematic illustration of the fabrication of ITO nanowires device[64]. Reproduced with permission. Copyright 2018, Elsevier.
TiO2 is a classical n-type semiconductor, its production method is simple. The raw materials are cheap and easily available. More importantly, it has good biocompatibility, excellent photostability, fast charge conduction rate and excellent photoelectric chemical activity. Many biosensors have been achieved high-performance based on TiO2[
Chen and co-workers developed a nanostructured impedance biosensor to detect hepatitis B virus (HBV) DNA. The anodic aluminum oxide membrane having a uniform nano hemisphere array was selected as the substrate of the sensing electrode. A 30-nm gold film was sputtered onto the Al2O3 layer surface as the electrode, followed by electrochemical deposition of Au nanoparticles on each hemisphere surface. Target HBV DNA was captured by hybridization with the specific probe which immobilized on the nanostructured electrode. The LOD was measured to be 111 copy/mL[
5. Perspectives and conclusions
Considerable efforts of researches demonstrate the utility of robust nucleic acid tests biosensors with semiconductor for development of a flexible nucleic acid diagnostic platform. With the advantages of semiconductor materials, these biosensors have their own characteristics in rapidity, low cost, high sensitivity and specificity. Accurate and sensitive bioanalysis of nucleic acids is crucial for earlier detection of salmonids viral diseases. Currently, there are no practical applications of semiconductor-based biosensors for salmonids virus detection, but these biosensors have great potential application prospects for the diagnosis of salmonids virus infections in the field. Their portable, rapid and sensitive prosperities could meet the needs of salmonids diseases detection and achieve the goal of early detection of salmonids virus infections.
In spite of wide application prospects of biosensors in salmonids virus detection, there are still some challenges in on-site virus detection and surveillance in salmonids aquaculture. The development trends of on-site virus detection biosensors are mainly in these aspects: (1) Miniaturization and integration of the detection system. It will accord with the diagnostic needs of point-of-care (POC) in resource limited settings such as fish farms. (2) High availability and low cost. Fabricating biosensors can use the lower-cost and easily available semiconductor materials. (3) Multiplexed detection. This is highly desirable in early salmonids virus detection because virus has genetic variability such as IPNV. (4) Application effect evaluation. All biosensors need to be applied in the practical environment to evaluate their detection effect and performance. These goals will encourage researchers to make great progress in more accurate, portable, ultracompact reliable and smart on-site virus detection[
[1] M C Bianchi, F Chopin, T Farme et al. FAO: the state of world fisheries and aquaculture. Rome, Italy: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations(2014).
[2] M Crane, A Hyatt. Viruses of fish: An overview of significant pathogens. Viruses, 3, 2025(2011).
[15] [15] WOAH. Infection with infectious haematopoietic necrosis virus. Manual of Diagnostic Tests for Aquatic Animals, 2021, chapter 2.3.5
[33] A Cuenca, N Vendramin, N J Olesen. Analytical validation of one-step realtime RT-PCR for detection of infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV). Bull Eur Ass Fish Pathol, 40, 261(2020).
Get Citation
Copy Citation Text
Xiaofei Liu, Songyin Qiu, Haiping Fang, Lin Mei, Hongli Jing, Chunyan Feng, Shaoqiang Wu, Xiangmei Lin. A brief review of novel nucleic acid test biosensors and their application prospects for salmonids viral diseases detection[J]. Journal of Semiconductors, 2023, 44(2): 023103
Category: Articles
Received: Dec. 18, 2022
Accepted: --
Published Online: Mar. 20, 2023
The Author Email: Wu Shaoqiang (sqwu@sina.com), Lin Xiangmei (linxm@caiq.org.cn)