Acta Optica Sinica, Volume. 39, Issue 8, 0810004(2019)

U-Shaped Retinal Vessel Segmentation Algorithm Based on Adaptive Scale Information

Liming Liang1、*, Xiaoqi Sheng1, Zhimin Lan1, Guoliang Yang1, and Xinjian Chen2
Author Affiliations
  • 1 School of Electrical Engineering and Automation, Jiangxi University of Science and Technology, Ganzhou, Jiangxi 341000, China
  • 2 School of Electronic and Information Engineering, Soochow University, Suzhou, Jiangsu 215006, China
  • show less
    Figures & Tables(17)
    Point clusters after K-L transformation in color coordinate space
    3×3 normal convolution and deformable convolution diagram
    Deformable convolution feature extraction process
    Internal structure of dense deformable convolution model
    Multiscale dilated convolution
    Internal structure of AGs
    Computation of compatibility tensor dimension
    U-shaped network architecture model of adaptive scale information
    Preprocessing images in each stage. (a) Original image; (b) image of green channel; (c) principal component I1; (d) principal component I2; (e) principal component I3; (f) morphological transformation
    Local vessel block informations. (a) Gold standard block information; (b) DRIVE data block information
    Retinal vascular segmentation results using different algorithms. (a) Origin image; (b) gold standard of image; (c) proposed algorithm; (d) results in Ref. [9]; (e) results in Ref. [28]; (f) results in Ref. [29]
    Performance comparison of deep learning segmentation algorithms. (a) Origin images; (b) details of original images; (c) details of gold standard; (d) details of proposed algorithm; (e) details of algorithm in Ref. [9]; (f) details of algorithm in Ref. [29]
    ROC curves of proposed algorithm. (a) ROC curve of DRIVE dataset; (b) ROC curve of STARE dataset
    Fmeasure of different algorithms. (a) Fmeasure of DRIVE dataset; (b) Fmeasure of STARE dataset
    • Table 1. Performance comparison of different network structures based on U-shaped network architecture

      View table

      Table 1. Performance comparison of different network structures based on U-shaped network architecture

      MethodσAccuracy /%σSensitivity /%σSpecificity /%AUC /%
      M196.2179.6998.5298.30
      M296.5083.2198.6398.56
      M396.2981.1298.5298.41
      M496.8582.7498.7198.63
      M596.5481.5098.2098.28
      M696.2480.6798.5498.36
      TP97.4885.7898.8398.72
    • Table 2. Retinal vessel segmentation results in DRIVE dataset

      View table

      Table 2. Retinal vessel segmentation results in DRIVE dataset

      NumberMethodσSensitivity /%σSpecificity /%σAccuracy /%AUC /%
      12nd human observer77.9697.1794.6494.66
      2Method in Ref. [2]71.4098.6896.0790.86
      3Method in Ref. [3]83.5495.9194.82
      4Method in Ref. [6]75.3597.2695.36
      5Method in Ref. [7]80.3697.7895.5698.00
      6Method in Ref. [9]78.0298.7696.3695.88
      7Method in Ref. [10]81.5098.2096.7498.08
      8Method in Ref. [28]78.9796.84
      9Method in Ref. [29]81.1597.2495.2098.03
      10Method in Ref. [31]80.5397.6795.4697.71
      11Method in Ref. [32]81.7397.3397.6794.75
      12Method in Ref. [33]76.9198.0195.33
      13Method in Ref. [34]84.7395.9295.12
      14Method in Ref. [35]77.3197.2494.67
      15Method in Ref. [36]72.9298.1594.9495.99
      16TP85.7898.8397.4898.72
    • Table 3. Retinal vessel segmentation results in STARE dataset

      View table

      Table 3. Retinal vessel segmentation results in STARE dataset

      NumberMethodσSensitivity /%σSpecificity /%σAccuracy /%AUC /%
      12nd human observer89.5593.8493.4796.86
      2Method in Ref. [3]84.5296.1995.34
      3Method in Ref. [6]79.0996.3095.03
      4Method in Ref. [28]63.5097.38
      5Method in Ref. [29]76.8696.6298.03
      6Method in Ref. [31]82.9997.9496.8498.17
      7Method in Ref. [32]81.0497.9198.1397.51
      8Method in Ref. [36]72.1198.4095.6997.08
      9Method in Ref. [37]77.9197.5895.5497.48
      10TP84.3297.7596.8398.13
    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Liming Liang, Xiaoqi Sheng, Zhimin Lan, Guoliang Yang, Xinjian Chen. U-Shaped Retinal Vessel Segmentation Algorithm Based on Adaptive Scale Information[J]. Acta Optica Sinica, 2019, 39(8): 0810004

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Image Processing

    Received: Mar. 4, 2019

    Accepted: May. 5, 2019

    Published Online: Aug. 7, 2019

    The Author Email: Liang Liming (lianglm67@163.com)

    DOI:10.3788/AOS201939.0810004

    Topics