1 Introduction
Motion is everywhere in living systems and is necessary for mechanical functions in artificial systems, such as robots and machines. Functional mechanical structures that change volume and shape and move in response to external stimuli, including chemical, electrical, or optical forces, are essential in various applications.1–5 They have received immense research interest, particularly at micro-/nanoscales. Among the existing actuation proposals, many rely on light as the energy source. Optical force is thus widely used to manipulate microobjects that are either immersed in a liquid or levitated in a vacuum.6–11
It is, however, challenging to use the optical force to manipulate microobjects on solid interfaces due to surface friction that is typically several orders of magnitude larger () than the optical force ().4,6,12–15 To resolve this difficulty, it has been recently proposed to use elastic waves,16–22 which are induced by temperature rising through optical absorption in microobjects.16–20 These light-induced elastic waves carry sufficient mechanical displacements enabling microobjects to crawl on solid interfaces. The idea has been successfully exemplified with gold microplates in microfiber-based systems.16–20 Specifically, the researchers have successfully observed the stable motion of gold plates around microfibers along either or both of azimuthal and axial directions of the microfibers. The motion speed increases with the average power of input laser pulses. These pioneering results encouragingly open a new perspective for light-driven micromotors on solid interfaces. Many unique applications can be immediately envisioned. For instance, by integrating this technique into an on-chip waveguide network, one can realize mobile photonic modulation/switching by delivering microobjects to targeted positions18 to control light flow.
Notwithstanding recent advancements in this new direction, there still remain several questions to be explored.
Sign up for Advanced Photonics Nexus TOC Get the latest issue of Advanced Photonics delivered right to you!Sign up now
Here we approach these two questions by studying the motion of two-dimensional topological-insulator plates on microfibers to which laser pulses are delivered. is a unique quantum material hosting topologically protected boundary surface states that lead to several fascinating electronic and optical properties, such as spin-momentum locking of electrons and ultrabroadband plasmon excitations.23–26 Referring to our objectives, we utilize its two other properties. First, is a narrow-gap semiconductor with only a 0.21 eV bandgap,27 thus being efficient at absorbing light for the generation of elastic waves. Second, has a rather low thermal conductivity (, close to glass and two orders of magnitude smaller than that of gold), which mitigates heat diffusion and intensifies thermal effects.28
In this paper, we implement a microfiber-based actuation system in a vacuum chamber. A scanning electron microscope (SEM) is employed to precisely characterize pulsed light-induced actuation of microsized plates on microfibers. The successful observations of continuous spiral motions of plates supplement the previous ones with gold plates, and thus contributes new evidence to support the actuation principle based on light-induced elastic waves. Further, we intentionally increase laser power to examine thermal effects on actuation. Specifically, we show formations of microbumps due to the Marangoni effects on a surface and observe a new type of liquid-like motion that shows features completely different from the elastic-waves-based spiral motion.
2 Light-Induced Actuation
As illustrated in Fig. 1(a), a plate is placed on a suspended silica microfiber. A supercontinuum light (wavelength range from 450 to 2400 nm) is launched into the microfiber to drive the locomotion of the plate. The experimental setup is similar as that used for actuating gold plates in our previous work.17,19 The plate was obtained by mechanical exfoliation using dicing tape and then dispersed on a (300 nm) thin film on a Si substrate. The confocal laser scanning microscopy images [see the inset in Fig. 1(b) and, similarly, Fig. S1 in the Supplementary Material] show that the plate considerably warps around its edges. The plate was transferred onto the microfiber using a tapered fiber. The thickness of the plate varies between 0.2 and . We measured the plate by micro-Raman spectroscopy (Alpha300R) with 532-nm-laser light. The Raman spectrum [Fig. 1(b)] shows three characteristic peaks at 68.26, 112.45, and , respectively, which correspond to , , and phonon vibrational modes of .30
Figure 1.Optical and thermal properties of hybrid plate–silica microfiber systems. (a) Sketch of a plate on top of a suspended microfiber. Zoomed inset: a plate is modeled as a dielectric bulk slab sandwiched between two metallic thin layers. (b) Micro-Raman spectrum of a plate measured by a 532-nm pumping laser. Inset: confocal laser scanning microscopy image of a mechanical-exfoliated plate on a substrate. (c) Simulated absorption spectrum of a hybrid plate–microfiber system under incidence of fundamental mode of the microfiber. (d) Simulated modal profiles of the mode without (left panel) and with (right panel) the plate. The arrows specify the directions of modal electric fields. (e) Simulated characteristic temperature distributions in the central plane of and gold plates at , 100, 1000 ns when heated by pulsed light. In (c)–(e), the microfiber has a radius of and a refractive index of 1.45. The plate has a width of , a length of , and a thickness of 300 nm, and its surface and bulk refractive indices are adopted from Ref. 29. The Au plate has the same geometrical parameters as the plate. The details of the thermal simulations in (e) are given in Note S1 in the Supplementary Material.
The presence of nontrivial topological surface states renders the plate a multilayer character;31 that is, a dielectric bulk slab is sandwiched between two metallic surface layers [see the zoomed inset in Fig. 1(a)]. The permittivity of the metallic surface layers and the insulating bulk of the plate is adopted from Ref. 29 and is plotted in Fig. S2 in the Supplementary Material. However, due to their negligible thickness (2.6 nm), the metallic layers only slightly impact the optical absorption of the plate (see Fig. S3 in the Supplementary Material). Consider that a fundamental mode (linearly polarized perpendicular to the plate surface) propagates in a microfiber with a diameter of and interacts with a rectangular plate (width: , length: , and thickness: 300 nm). The calculated absorption spectrum is plotted in Fig. 1(c), showing an average absorptance of about 0.15. Figure 1(d) compares modal profiles with and without the plate. Interestingly, in the presence of the plate, the displacement electric field in the plate strongly localizes around the touching point between the plate and the microfiber, where the most absorption occurs. This field profile manifests strong near-field interactions between the electric polarization in the microfiber and its induced mirror image inside the plate. Furthermore, since the near-field interactions are polarization sensitive, those modes, which host weak interactions such as the fundamental mode (linearly polarized parallel with the plate surface), are negligibly absorbed (see Fig. S3 in the Supplementary Material).
The absorbed optical power generates heat. The heat diffusion in the plate is rather slow. More precisely, the thermal diffusivity of is only about , while this value for gold is , two orders of magnitude larger. Quantitatively, to transport heat diffusively across a plate with side length (similar to that in our experiments), it roughly takes time . In contrast, for the same-sized gold plate, this time is significantly reduced to . Hence, inside the plate, the absorbed heat could be efficiently stored in vicinity to the contact line between the plate and the microfiber, where the optical absorption is maximum; whereas inside the Au plate, the initially localized heat rapidly spreads throughout the plate, as validated with the numerical simulations in Fig. 1(e). The slow heat diffusion in the plate is naturally envisioned to boost noticeable thermal effects, as shall be experimentally examined later.
The temperature rising in the plate excites elastic waves, which drive the locomotion of the plate on the microfiber. The underlying mechanisms, featuring interplay between elastic waves and their induced friction force, have been comprehensively studied in our previous work, and we refer the interested reader to Refs. 17, 19, and 20.
We characterized the motion of the plate using a SEM in a vacuum chamber [see Fig. 2(a)]. The SEM here brings two advantages. First, it provides a much better spatial resolution compared with the use of an optical microscope. Second, due to the high-vacuum environment (), those less important effects, e.g., due to surrounding gas molecules (including photophoretic forces and air resistances), on actuation are safely screened out, thus simplifying the physics interpretation. In addition, we also conducted the experiments at ambient conditions and arrived at similar observations as in vacuum.
Figure 2.Experimental observations of a plate moving spirally around a microfiber. (a) Sketch of experimental setup implemented in a vacuum chamber. VOA, variable optical attenuator; FC, fiber coupler; MF, microfiber; and PM, power meter. (b) Temporal sequencing SEM images of a plate moving around a microfiber. The microfiber has a diameter of . The supercontinuum laser pulses have 2.6-ns duration, 230-Hz repetition rate, 0.1-mW average power, and wavelength range from 450 to 2400 nm. Scale bar: (Video 1, MP4, 4.34 MB [URL: https://doi.org/10.1117/1.APN.1.2.026005.s1). (c) Fourier transformation of the detected areas of the plate during the motion. The spectral peak specifies the azimuthal rotation frequency of the plate. The axis is linear and the shaded region here is to better show its rotation frequency. (d) Translation displacement of the plate along the axial direction of the microfiber as a function of time.
Figure 2(b) plots sequencing SEM images of a plate that crawls along a microfiber following a spiral trajectory (also see Video 1). We characterized the spiral motion by decomposing it into the rotation and the translation along the azimuthal and axial directions of the microfiber separately. The azimuthal rotation frequency is obtained by the Fourier transformation of the effective area of the plate, which changes periodically over time. On average, the rotation frequency is estimated to be about 0.177 Hz [see Fig. 2(c)], indicating a traveling distance of 12.8 nm along the azimuthal direction per pulse on average. Figure 2(d) analyzes the axial displacement. The trajectory curve is fitted well with a straight line, and the velocity is determined to be , implying a translation distance of 6.9 nm along the axial direction per pulse on average.
3 Remarks on Actuation Efficiency
We experimentally observe that a plate can be driven much more efficiently than a similarly sized gold plate17,19,20 under irradiation of the same light pulses. For instance, as is shown in Fig. 2, when a single nanosecond light pulse with a 0.43 nJ pulse energy is delivered, the plate travels on average about 6.9 and 12.8 nm in the axial and azimuthal directions of the microfiber, respectively. In contrast, to enable the gold plate to travel a similar distance, a much larger pulse energy (at least several times or even dozens of times larger, which are sample dependent) is needed.19 Furthermore, from numerous repetitive tests, we consistently notice that the plates generally require a lower threshold pulse energy to enable their motion than the gold plates. These intuitive observations suggest that, compared with the gold plates, the plates have a higher actuation efficiency.
To reveal the material difference in actuation, we start with the linear elastic equation that involves both the surface friction and the thermal deformation: where , , and are the Young’s modulus, Poisson’s ratio, and mass density of the driven object, respectively, is the linear expansion coefficient, is the friction force, is the temperature variation, and is the elastic displacement vector. Given by the above equation, the object displacement characterized by is proportional to the strength of the thermal deformation defined by , which induces the surface friction when the relative position between the driven object and the substrate changes in response to the thermal deformation. Consequently, the defined thermal-deformation strength indicates the actuation efficiency (that is, a larger principally corresponds to a higher actuation efficiency and vice versa). Specifically, when an input nanosecond light pulse is converted to heat in the driven object with an optical absorption efficiency denoted by , , where is the object’s specific heat capacity. It is obvious that materials with larger and , and smaller and are more favorable for the use of actuation than the opposite. In addition, we note that the estimation of cannot be directly inferred from the basic electromagnetic parameters (complex-valued permittivity and permeability), and quantitative electromagnetic simulations should be consulted [such as in Fig. 1(c)].
Referring to the and gold plates with similar sizes, they show close absorption efficiency [see Fig. 1(c) and Fig. S8c in the Supplementary Material in Ref. 19 that the average absorption between 400 nm and wavelength is about 0.15 to 0.2 in both cases]. The other relevant parameters of such two materials are , , , , and , . As a result, , which is mainly due to the lighter mass density and slightly larger thermal expansion coefficient of than those of gold, thus contributing to a higher actuation efficiency of the plate.
Moreover, we note that the thermal conductivity of is two orders of magnitude smaller than that of gold, which leads to their significant difference in heat diffusion. As a result, the local temperature in the contact region of the plate could be much higher than that of the gold plate [see Fig. 1(e)]. The high temperature (especially when approaching the melting point) is known to induce random motions of interfacial atoms and mitigate the friction, which could be another reason for the observed high actuation efficiency with the use of the plate; at the same time, the thermal effects in the plate become noticeable, as discussed below.
4 Thermal Effects
To examine the thermal effects on the motion of the plate, we intentionally increase the average power of the laser pulses by increasing the pulse repetition rate. Initially, when the pulse repetition rate is low (less than a few kHz), the plate generally moves stably, as shown in Fig. 4(a). The motion speed increases linearly with the repetition rate, as is shown in Fig. 3 with two samples (see Video 2). This result thus suggests that, in the stable-motion regime, the motion speed can be regularly controlled by tuning the pulse repetition rate because the motion is repeatedly driven by individual pulses in a stepwise fashion. Physically, the use of the low-repetition-rate pulses ensures that the plate heated by one pulse can be sufficiently cooled down before next pulse arrives, thereby denying thermal effects.
Figure 3.Manipulating motion speed of plates by tuning repetition rates of laser pulses. Note that the integrated single-pulse energy remains the same as the repetition rate changes. Scale bars: (Video 2, MP4, 19.6 MB [URL: https://doi.org/10.1117/1.APN.1.2.026005.s2]).
Figure 4.Stable motion of a plate degenerates into unstable motion by thermal effects. Sequencing SEM images show (a) stable and (b) unstable motions with pulse repetition rates of 2.2 kHz and 4.8 kHz, respectively. Scale bars: (Video 3, MP4, 9.73 MB [URL: https://doi.org/10.1117/1.APN.1.2.026005.s3]).
On the other hand, as the pulse repetition rate exceeds a certain threshold value, the plate starts to move unstably and to continually adjust its gesture during the motion, as shown in Fig. 4(b) and also Video 3. The threshold repetition rate, which triggers the motion instability, is observed to be sample dependent. Nevertheless, its value is consistently on the order of a few kHz. We argue that the threshold repetition rate is proportional to the reciprocal of the cooling time of the plate under single-pulse irradiation. More precisely, if the repetition rate is above the threshold value, the multi-pulse heat accumulation starts. As the accumulated temperature is close to the melting point of , the plate shall be strongly deformed, particularly around the contact-line region where the absorbed optical power is largest. Numerically, we find that the cooling time is about , suggesting that the threshold repetition rate is about 10 kHz, close to the experimental observations.
The thermal-induced morphology dynamic changes are proposed to be responsible for the motion instability. In this regard, the formations of microbumps are one dominant phenomenon associated with the surface morphology deformations of under high-laser irradiance.32 The underlying mechanism is attributed to the Marangoni effects involving both thermocapillary and chemicapillary forces. Specifically, the thermocapillary force tends to push the interfacial atoms toward the cold peripheral region with a higher surface tension. Therefore, a surface compositional gradient shall be established. In contrast, the chemicapillary force pushes the materials toward the hotter region with lower surfactant concentrations. (Note: The surfactant Te, which lowers the surface tension, can be generated by irradiation of nanosecond laser pulses, as confirmed with the Raman measurements in Fig. S4 in the Supplementary Material.) The chemicapillary and thermocapillary forces thus compete with each other. The dominance of the chemicapillary force over the thermocapillary force leads to the formations of the microbumps in the hotter region. That is, in our case, around the contact line between the plate and the microfiber, as shown in Fig. 6(b) and Video 4. The size of the microbump increases with the average power of the incident laser power, as shown in Fig. S5 in the Supplementary Material. In comparison, these thermal-induced morphology changes cannot be observed in the gold plate even when the repetition rate is above 20 kHz due to its high thermal conductivity and melting point.
To better visualize the formed microbumps, we compare two SEM images of a plate before and after the unstable motion. Figure 5(a) shows that the surface of the plate before the motion is rather flat. Contrastingly, Fig. 5(b) shows that, after the motion, several microbumps (marked with red dashed circles) are induced as expected due to the Marangoni effects. Moreover, a myriad of small spheres is observed in the colder peripheral regions (marked with white dashed circles) potentially due to the dewetting effects.33 Further, to observe the microbumps formed in larger areas, we transferred a plate onto a fiber endface (SMF-28, from Corning Company). The fiber core and the plate overlap each other. The nanosecond laser pulses are guided through the fiber and impinge on the plate directly. Similar observations as in Fig. 5 are given in Fig. S6 in the Supplementary Material.
Figure 5.SEM images of a plate (a) before and (b) after motion. The red and white dashed circles in (b) mark formed microbumps and a myriad of small spheres, respectively.
5 Liquid-Like Motion
In addition to the induced motion instability shown in Fig. 4, the thermal effects lead to a new type of liquid-like motion. This liquid-like motion exhibits several features completely different from the spiral motion that is known to be driven by elastic waves, thus being worthy of discussion.
First, the onset of this liquid-like motion must require a high-pulse repetition rate [e.g., 11.5 kHz in Fig. 6]. Consequently, the shape of the plate is strongly deformed [see Fig. 6(a)]. The Marangoni effects induce a large microbump that contacts the microfiber [marked with a black rectangle in Fig. 6(a)], and the microbump is heated to viscoelasticity (molten-like) states. During the motion, the microbump deforms its shape periodically, accompanying the asymmetry in the left and right contact angles [see Fig. 6(b)]. This characteristic feature well resembles the motion of a liquid droplet: the unbalanced Young’s force, manifesting in asymmetric contact angles, drives the motion (see Note S2 in the Supplementary Material for detailed analysis).34 For this reason, the observed motion is termed liquid-like motion.
Figure 6.Liquid-like motion of plates on microfibers. (a) Time sequencing SEM images of a plate showing liquid-like motion. The used supercontinuum laser pulse has 5.4-mW average power and 11.5-kHz repetition rate. A large microbump contacting with the microfiber and a small one is marked with a rectangle and circle, respectively (Video 4, MP4, 895 kB [URL: https://doi.org/10.1117/1.APN.1.2.026005.s4]). (b) Zoomed-in microbump [corresponding to the marked rectangle in (a)] showing asymmetric contact angles. Scale bar: . (c) Horizontal and (d) vertical displacements of the point in the plate as functions of time. The point is labeled in (a). (e) Two exemplified samples show that horizontal motion direction of the plates points from a small microbump close to the microfiber (marked with circle) to a large one contacting with the microfiber (marked with rectangle). Scale bars: (Video 5, MP4, 7.90 MB [URL: https://doi.org/10.1117/1.APN.1.2.026005.s5]).
Second, the motion speed is significantly slower than the spiral motion. Figure 6(c) shows that the motion speed is only about . Recalling that the pulse repetition rate is 11.5 kHz, the motion distance per pulse is about 0.01 nm, which is even below the atomic scale. This implies that the physics occurring in a single pulse is somehow insignificant to the observed macroscopic motion. Instead, the essential motion dynamics, which feature classical mechanics at the macroscopic scale (that is, the motion distance at least exceeds atomic lattice sizes), should occur in a longer time scale involving multiple pulses. In view of this, we deduce that this liquid-like motion is a multiple-pulse phenomenon instead of a single-pulse phenomenon as is for the elastic-waves-driven spiral motion.
Third, in all the observations of such liquid-like motions, we find that, besides the large microbump that contacts the microfiber, there also exist suspended, small ones close to the microfiber [marked with circles in Figs. 6(a) and 6(e)]. As is shown in Fig. 6(d), the suspended microbump vibrates in the vertical direction periodically by the surface adhesion of the microfiber. Simultaneously, the structure moves horizontally. The horizontal translation thus hybrids with the vertical vibration.
Finally, the horizontal motion of the plate is universally observed to be along the direction pointing from the suspended microbump to the contacted one, as is illustrated with three different samples in Figs. 6(a) (Video 4) and 6(e) (Video 5). However, a satisfactory, quantitative interpretation is not trivial due to the involvements of complicated material states of high temperature, interfacial interactions, and temperature- and surfactant-modified surface tensions. Nevertheless, a phenomenological explanation without referring to its underlying microscopic mechanisms may be because the vertical vibration of the suspended microbump leads to the periodic deformation of the contacted microbump (see Videos 4 and 5), which generates the unbalanced Young’s force in the same direction as the horizontal motion [see Note S2 in the Supplementary Material].
6 Conclusions
In summary, light-induced locomotion of microsized topological insulator plates along silica microfibers is demonstrated. The motion speed is controlled by tuning the average power of incident laser pulses. Our results confirm the validity of the previously established actuation principle based on light-induced elastic waves, and supplement previous demonstrations with gold microplates. We expect that this straightforward validation may encourage researchers to exploit this concept for more challenging application-oriented tasks, e.g., in integrated photonic circuits, wherein mobile microobjects can be precisely transported to targeted positions in circuits for user-defined functionalities, such as optical switches/modulators. Moreover, the thermal effects on actuation are examined. We observe the formations of the microbumps on the surfaces of the plates due to the Marangoni effects, and reveal their induced motion instability and a new type of liquid-like motion.
Biographies of the authors are not available.