Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves, Volume. 43, Issue 6, 806(2024)

Angular-tunable on-chip coding metasurface enabled by phase-change material with immersion liquid

Xue-Nan LI1...2, Zeng-Yue ZHAO1,*, Fei-Long YU1, Jin CHEN1, Guan-Hai LI1,2,3,4,**, Zhi-Feng LI1, and Xiao-Shuang CHEN1,2,34,*** |Show fewer author(s)
Author Affiliations
  • 1State Key Laboratory of Infrared Physics,Shanghai Institute of Technical Physics,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shanghai,200083,China
  • 2University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing,100049,China
  • 3Hangzhou Institute for Advanced Study,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Hangzhou,310024,China
  • 4Shanghai Research Center for Quantum Sciences,Shanghai,201315,China
  • show less

    Metasurfaces provide a potent platform for the dynamic manipulation of electromagnetic waves. Coupled with phase-change materials, they facilitate the creation of versatile metadevices, showcasing various tunable functions based on the transition between amorphous and crystalline states. However, the inherent limitation in tunable states imposes constraints on the multiplexing channels of metadevices. Here, this paper introduces a novel approach - a multi-functional metadevice achieved through the two-level control of the encoding phase-change metaatoms. Utilizing the phase-change material Ge2Sb2Se4Te1 (GSST) and high refractive-index liquid diiodomethane (CH2I2), this paper showcases precise control over electromagnetic wave manipulation. The GSST state governs the tunable function, switching it ON and OFF, while the presence of liquid in the hole dictates the deflection angle when the tunable function is active. Importantly, our tunable coding metasurface exhibits robust performance across a broad wavelength spectrum. The incorporation of high refractive-index liquid extends the regulatory dimension of the metadevice, enabling dynamic switching of encoding bit levels. This two-level tunable metadevice, rooted in phase-change materials, presents a promising avenue for the dynamic control of functions.

    Keywords

    Introduction

    Metasurfaces offer distinct advantages,such as compact dimension and low loss,making them widely employed in various applications including metalens,holograms,and optical vortex manipulation 1-4. Traditionally,metasurface structures are fixed upon array configuration,limiting their adaptability. The growing demand for tunable metasurfaces has emerged with advancements in metasurface technology. The introduction of phase-change materials(PCMs),exemplified by the germanium-antimony-telluride(GST)family and vanadium dioxide(VO2),has facilitated the development of tunable metadevices 5-6. PCMs undergo reversible transitions between amorphous and crystalline states,enabling the creation of multifunctional metalens,optical switches,and beam-steering devices 7-9.

    Notably,the integration of liquid crystals,diodes,and graphene in coding metasurfaces,where discrete phase shifts manipulate electromagnetic waves,has found extensive applications in tunable devices 10-13. Moreover,coding metasurfaces utilizing PCMs have been widely adopted for dynamic applications. For example,Huang et al. designed a coding metasurface with switchable beam deflection and focusing based on GST 14,while Lin et al. proposed a coding metasurface based on germanium telluride(GeTe)for dynamic modification of terahertz beams 15. However,traditional PCM-based metasurfaces are constrained to only two tunable states,pre- and post-phase change. Recent attention has shifted towards miniaturized and highly integrated devices,particularly on-chip devices 16-18. It offers advantages for the manipulation of in-plane electromagnetic wave propagation. Liquid-based tunable metamaterials,leveraging the ease of liquid addition and removal,have been developed with diverse functionalities. CH2I2 with high refractive index has been utilized for aplanatic numerical aperture increasing lenses 19. Switchable beam-steering has also been achieved through water immersion or drying 20,and the filling height of water in integrated-resonant metaatoms is adjusted to tune the focal length of meta-lenses 21. Metasurface with a strong polarization correlation shows different beam reflections in a liquid environment 22. Water-immersion tuning scheme achieves the switch for both near- and far-field meta-display transformation 23. Dynamic control of light fields is realized by flowing liquids with different refractive indices over nanostructures 24. An environment-compliant tunable meta-optics is enabled by a liquid immersion tuning scheme 25. Despite the versatility demonstrated in different states,the current approaches are limited in their maximal multiplexing channels.

    In this work,we present a novel tunable coding metasurface designed for two-level control. Leveraging a combination of GSST and CH2I2 liquid,our metasurface regulates in-plane electromagnetic waves across both single and broadband wavelengths. The tunable function is inactive when GSST is in the crystalline state,resulting in an indistinguishable deflection angle for etched holes with or without CH2I2. Conversely,when GSST transitions to the amorphous state,the tunable function activates,allowing the conversion of the coding metasurface from 3-bit to 4-bit,accompanied by a change in deflection angle when the etched hole is filled with CH2I2. We also discuss the impact of the refractive index of the liquid. This two-level control mechanism introduces a new avenue for designing on-chip dynamic tunable devices.

    1 Design and theory

    Fig. 1(a)illustrates the schematic of our tunable coding metasurface,designed as a beam deflection device operating at a wavelength of 5.2 μm. The tunable functionality,denoted as ON or OFF,is contingent upon the state of GSST,while the specific deflection angle is determined by the presence or absence of CH2I2 liquid within the etched hole. The arrangement of the etched hole along the y-direction allows manipulation of the TE polarization(polarized along the y-direction)incident wave,propagating along the +x-direction. In the amorphous state of GSST,the deflection angle of the electromagnetic wave undergoes alteration upon filling or emptying the CH2I2 liquid within the hole. Correspondingly,the phase distribution of the xy-plane is depicted in Fig. 1(b). This dynamic modulation of the deflection angle and phase distribution highlights the tunable nature of our coding metasurface,showcasing its ability to control electromagnetic waves based on the state of GSST and the presence of CH2I2 liquid.

    Schematic representation of the designed tunable coding metasurface:(a)illustration of the tunable coding metasurface's structural configuration(When the phase-change material,GSST,is in the amorphous state,the deflection angle varies in response to the presence or absence of CH2I2 liquid in the etched hole);(b)phase distribution in the xy-plane without or with CH2I2 liquid in the etched hole,showcasing the tunability of the metasurface

    Figure 1.Schematic representation of the designed tunable coding metasurface:(a)illustration of the tunable coding metasurface's structural configuration(When the phase-change material,GSST,is in the amorphous state,the deflection angle varies in response to the presence or absence of CH2I2 liquid in the etched hole);(b)phase distribution in the xy-plane without or with CH2I2 liquid in the etched hole,showcasing the tunability of the metasurface

    The metaatom's schematic diagram,as depicted in Fig. 2(a),comprises the etched hole,GSST,and SiO2 substrate. GSST is a kind of nonvolatile phase change materials,which phase state can maintain at room temperature. GSST has a large difference in the optical property between the crystalline and amorphous states 26,making it a perfect candidate for the design of tunable metasurfaces. The GSST layer,with a thickness(H)of 2 μm,plays a crucial role in the overall functionality. The dimensions of the etched hole,denoted as length(L)and width(W),are carefully tuned to achieve the desired deflection function. The periodicity of the metaatom,extending along the y-direction,is established at P = 1 μm. It’s necessary to have further consideration on the experimental feasibility. The GSST film can be deposited onto the substrate by thermal co-evaporation,and the desired film can be achieved by controlling the ratio of evaporation rates of two isolated targets of Ge2Sb2Te5 and Ge2Sb2Se5. The GSST film can be etched via electron beam lithography and reactive ion etching. The GSST film can be changed to the crystalline state by hot-plate annealing at 250°C for 30 min 27. The addition of CH2I2 liquid can by a pipettor and the removal of it can by vaporization 28. Therefore,the practical experimental is possible for this work. In terms of material properties,the refractive indices of GSST differ in its amorphous and crystalline states,measuring 3.19 and 4.65,respectively,at the operational wavelength of 5.2 μm 26. Additionally,CH2I2 liquid,a key component,exhibits a refractive index of 1.691 at the specified wavelength(5.2 μm)and temperature(20 ℃)29. The high refractive index of CH2I2 can provide a wide range of phase control,making it a good choice to replace low refractive index water or oil for the design of the tunable metasurface. To determine the refraction angle(θ),we employ the generalized Snell's law 30,expressed as θ = sin-1λ/(ntΓ)),where λ represents the designed wavelength,nt is the effective refractive index of the refraction medium,and Г signifies the super-period of the designed coding sequence. This formulation guides the modulation of the refraction angle based on the specified parameters,ensuring precise control over the metaatom's optical properties.

    Metaatom configuration and its tunable characteristics across different phase-change states:(a)schematic illustration of the metaatom with parameters H = 2 μm,P = 1 μm,W ranging from 0 to 1 μm,and L from 0 to 10 μm;(b)four states of the tunable coding metasurface;transmittance and phase shift of amorphous state GSST coding metaatoms when the etched hole is without(c)or with(d)CH2I2 liquid;transmittance and phase shift of crystalline state GSST coding metaatoms when the etched hole is without(e)or with(f)CH2I2 liquid. This highlights the tunable properties of the coding metaatoms in response to different phase-change conditions

    Figure 2.Metaatom configuration and its tunable characteristics across different phase-change states:(a)schematic illustration of the metaatom with parameters H = 2 μm,P = 1 μm,W ranging from 0 to 1 μm,and L from 0 to 10 μm;(b)four states of the tunable coding metasurface;transmittance and phase shift of amorphous state GSST coding metaatoms when the etched hole is without(c)or with(d)CH2I2 liquid;transmittance and phase shift of crystalline state GSST coding metaatoms when the etched hole is without(e)or with(f)CH2I2 liquid. This highlights the tunable properties of the coding metaatoms in response to different phase-change conditions

    Figs. 2(b)to 2(f)collectively illustrate the four tunable states of the coding metasurface,offering insight into the phase shift and transmittance characteristics of the metaatoms. In the amorphous state of GSST,the phase shift of the metaatom is approximately π/4 and π/8 for the etched hole without or with CH2I2 liquid,respectively(Figs. 2(c)and 2(d)). According to the concept of coding metasurface,n-bit coding metasurfaces consist of 2n coding units with a phase difference of 2π/2n10-12. Due to the smaller discrete phase difference,higher bit coding provides more precise control of electromagnetic waves and the spurious interference will be effectively suppressed 31-32. This distinction allows us to define the metaatoms as 3-bit and 4-bit coding configurations,respectively. Conversely,in the crystalline state of GSST,the phase shift remains approximately π/4 for both configurations,regardless of the absence or presence of CH2I2(Figs. 2(e)and 2(f)). Consequently,in this crystalline state,the metaatoms are categorized as 3-bit coding. Notably,during the crystalline state of GSST,the tunable function of the coding metasurface is inactive,signifying that the tunable coding metasurface is in the OFF state.

    2 Results and discussions

    The validation of our designed tunable coding metasurface was conducted through full-wave simulations. In the amorphous state of GSST,when the tunable function is active,the simulated deflection angles for the etched hole without or with CH2I2 liquid are 12.1° and 5.9°,respectively,as depicted in Fig. 3(a). The theoretically calculated deflection angles closely match at 12.4° and 6.2°,respectively. This alignment highlights the dynamic changes in the deflection angle corresponding to the presence or absence of CH2I2 in the etched hole. Upon conversion of GSST into the crystalline state,the simulated deflection angles for the etched hole without or with CH2I2 liquid are 8.8° and 8.0°,as illustrated in Fig. 3(b). The theoretically calculated deflection angles for both cases are consistent at 8.3°. Remarkably,the presence of CH2I2 has minimal impact on the deflection angle in this crystalline state. The phase distribution in the xy-plane for the four different states is presented in Figs. 3(c)~(f). It is evident that the isophase of the wavefront propagating in-plane inclines to varying degrees in each state,resulting in distinct deflection angles in the far field. This observation reinforces the tunable nature of the coding metasurface,demonstrating its ability to dynamically control the direction of electromagnetic waves based on the state of GSST and the presence of CH2I2.

    Deflection function of the tunable coding metasurface:(a)simulated far-field scattering pattern of the etched hole with(blue line)or without(red line)CH2I2 liquid at a wavelength of 5.2 μm when GSST is in the amorphous state;For comparison,the scattering pattern of GSST in the crystalline state is also presented in(b);Phase distribution in the xy-plane with the etched hole containing(c)or lacking(e)CH2I2 liquid in the amorphous state of GSST. Phase distribution in the xy-plane with the etched hole containing(d)or lacking(f)CH2I2 liquid in the crystalline state of GSST. These results illustrate the deflection characteristics of the tunable coding metasurface under different conditions

    Figure 3.Deflection function of the tunable coding metasurface:(a)simulated far-field scattering pattern of the etched hole with(blue line)or without(red line)CH2I2 liquid at a wavelength of 5.2 μm when GSST is in the amorphous state;For comparison,the scattering pattern of GSST in the crystalline state is also presented in(b);Phase distribution in the xy-plane with the etched hole containing(c)or lacking(e)CH2I2 liquid in the amorphous state of GSST. Phase distribution in the xy-plane with the etched hole containing(d)or lacking(f)CH2I2 liquid in the crystalline state of GSST. These results illustrate the deflection characteristics of the tunable coding metasurface under different conditions

    The potential influence of evaporation-induced fluctuations in the refractive index of CH2I2 liquid on deflection is investigated by simulating four different refractive indices in both amorphous and crystalline states of GSST. The results,presented in Figs. 4(a~d)and 4(e~h),demonstrate the robustness of the coding metasurface in maintaining a consistent deflection effect within a certain range of liquid refractive indices. For the amorphous state of GSST,as the refractive index of the liquid varies between 1.4,1.6,1.9,and 2.0,the simulated deflection angles are 6.8°,6.4°,5.5°,and 4.7°,respectively(Figs. 4(a~d)). Similarly,in the crystalline state of GSST,the simulated deflection angles for the same range of liquid refractive indices are 8.4°,8.4°,7.6°,and 6.4°,as shown in Figs. 4(e~h). Notably,the coding metasurface exhibits a consistent and reliable deflection effect across different liquid refractive indices in both amorphous and crystalline states. Furthermore,the deflection angle decreases with an increase in the liquid refractive index,indicating the sensitivity of the deflection effect to variations in the refractive index of CH2I2 liquid within the specified range.

    Refractive index changes of CH2I2 liquid. Simulated far-field scattering patterns of amorphous state GSST(a~d)and crystalline state GSST(e~h)at refractive indices of the liquid:1.4,1.6,1.9,and 2.0,respectively. These results demonstrate the influence of varying refractive indices of CH2I2 liquid on the scattering patterns in both amorphous and crystalline states of GSST

    Figure 4.Refractive index changes of CH2I2 liquid. Simulated far-field scattering patterns of amorphous state GSST(a~d)and crystalline state GSST(e~h)at refractive indices of the liquid:1.4,1.6,1.9,and 2.0,respectively. These results demonstrate the influence of varying refractive indices of CH2I2 liquid on the scattering patterns in both amorphous and crystalline states of GSST

    In addition,we delved into the operational bandwidth of the proposed tunable coding metasurface. When the device operates in the amorphous state of GSST,we found that the working wavelength of the metasurface can be expanded to a broadband range from 5 to 6 μm. The deflection angles of the etched hole without or with liquid at wavelengths of 5 μm,5.5 μm,5.7 μm,and 6 μm are illustrated in Fig. 5. At these specified wavelengths,the simulated deflection angle varies from 11.7° to 14.1° when the etched hole is without liquid,and from 5.5° to 6.8° when the etched hole is filled with liquid. According to the generalized Snell's law,the deflection angle is positive correlation with the working wavelength. Hence,the deflection angle is corresponding increases with the increase of working wavelength. This indicates that the deflection function remains valid across a broadband spectrum. The on-chip photonic device we designed exhibits robust performance,showcasing its suitability for applications requiring reliable and tunable deflection within a broad range of wavelengths.

    Broadband tunable coding metasurface. Simulated far-field scattering patterns of the etched hole without liquid(a~d)or with liquid(e~h)in the amorphous state of GSST. Wavelengths considered are 5 μm,5.5 μm,5.7 μm,and 6 μm,respectively. These simulations showcase the broadband tunability of the coding metasurface,highlighting the scattering patterns at different wavelengths

    Figure 5.Broadband tunable coding metasurface. Simulated far-field scattering patterns of the etched hole without liquid(a~d)or with liquid(e~h)in the amorphous state of GSST. Wavelengths considered are 5 μm,5.5 μm,5.7 μm,and 6 μm,respectively. These simulations showcase the broadband tunability of the coding metasurface,highlighting the scattering patterns at different wavelengths

    3 Conclusions

    In conclusion,our study successfully achieved two-level control of the coding metasurface,demonstrating versatility in both single and broadband wavelength applications. The tunable function of the on-chip device transitions from OFF to ON when GSST converts from the crystalline to the amorphous state. Under the OFF state,the deflection angle remains consistent whether the etched hole is without or with liquid. Conversely,under the ON state,the deflection angle is switchable based on the presence or absence of liquid in the etched hole. Notably,the deflection effect is robust and can be maintained regardless of changes in refractive index of liquid or operating wavelength,emphasizing the resilience of our on-chip photoelectric devices. Our findings open avenues for dynamic manipulation in on-chip devices,holding potential implications for the advancement of optical computational circuits,on-chip spectrometers,detectors,and other related technologies.

    [1] H H Hsiao, C H Chu, D P Tsai. Fundamentals and Applications of Metasurfaces. Small Methods, 1, 1600064(2017).

    [2] M Khorasaninejad, F Capasso. Metalenses: Versatile multifunctional photonic components. Science, 358, eaam8100(2017).

    [3] D D Wen, F Y Yue, G X Li et al. Helicity multiplexed broadband metasurface holograms. Nature Communications, 6, 8241(2015).

    [4] K Ou, G H Li, T X Li et al. High efficiency focusing vortex generation and detection with polarization-insensitive dielectric metasurfaces. Nanoscale, 10, 19154-19161(2018).

    [5] S Raoux, D Ielmini, M Wuttig et al. Phase change materials. Mrs Bulletin, 37, 118-123(2012).

    [6] Z L Gong, F Y Yang, L T Wang et al. Phase change materials in photonic devices. Journal of Applied Physics, 129, 030902(2021).

    [7] J W Xu, X M Tian, P Ding et al. Ge2Sb2Se4Te1-based multifunctional metalenses for polarization-independent, switchable and dual-mode focusing in the mid-infrared region. Optics Express, 29, 44227-44238(2021).

    [8] U Michel A-K, P Zalden, D N Chigrin et al. Reversible optical switching of infrared antenna resonances with ultrathin phase-change layers using femtosecond laser pulses. ACS Photonics, 1, 833-839(2014).

    [9] C R De Galarreta, A M Alexeev, Y Y Au et al. Nonvolatile reconfigurable phase‐change metadevices for beam steering in the near infrared. Advanced Functional Materials, 28, 1704993(2018).

    [10] T J Cui, M Q Qi, X Wan et al. Coding metamaterials, digital metamaterials and programmable metamaterials. Light: Science & Applications, 3, e218(2014).

    [11] C X Liu, F Yang, X J Fu et al. Programmable manipulations of terahertz beams by transmissive digital coding metasurfaces based on liquid crystals. Advanced Optical Materials, 9, 2100932(2021).

    [12] C Huang, B Sun, W B Pan et al. Dynamical beam manipulation based on 2-bit digitally-controlled coding metasurface. Scientific Reports, 7, 42302(2017).

    [13] H Chen, W B Lu, Z G Liu et al. Microwave programmable graphene metasurface. ACS Photonics, 7, 1425-1435(2020).

    [14] X Y Huang, Z X Liu, Y Lian et al. Dynamic beam all-direlectric coding metasurface converter based on phase change materials of GST. Optics & Laser Technology, 159, 109037(2023).

    [15] Q W Lin, H Wong, L Huitema et al. Coding metasurfaces with reconfiguration capabilities based on optical activation of phase‐change materials for terahertz beam manipulations. Advanced Optical Materials, 10, 2101699(2021).

    [16] Y H Guo, M B Pu, X Li et al. Chip-integrated geometric metasurface as a novel platform for directional coupling and polarization sorting by spin-orbit interaction. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 24, 4700107(2018).

    [17] Z Wang, T T Li, A Soman et al. On-chip wavefront shaping with dielectric metasurface. Nature Communications, 10, 3547(2019).

    [18] R Yang, Y Y Shi, C J Dai et al. On-chip metalenses based on one-dimensional gradient trench in the broadband visible. Optics Letters, 45, 5640-5643(2020).

    [19] J M Laskar, P S Kumar, S Herminghaus et al. High refractive index immersion liquid for superresolution 3D imaging using sapphire-based aplanatic numerical aperture increasing lens optics. Applied Optics, 55, 3165-3169(2016).

    [20] Z Li, C W Wan, C J Dai et al. Actively switchable beam‐steering via hydrophilic/hydrophobic‐selective design of water‐immersed metasurface. Advanced Optical Materials, 9, 2100297(2021).

    [21] J Yao, M K Chen, R Lin et al. Tunable water‐based meta‐lens. Advanced Optical Materials, 2300130(2023).

    [22] K He, T T Tang, L Bi et al. Polarization-dependent reconfigurable light field manipulation by liquid-immersion metasurface. Optics Express, 31, 13739-13750(2023).

    [23] S Wan, C J Dai, Z Li et al. Toward water-immersion programmable meta-display. Advanced Science, 10, 2205581(2022).

    [24] Q T Li, J van de Groep, A K White et al. Metasurface optofluidics for dynamic control of light fields. Nature Nanotechnology, 17, 1097-1103(2022).

    [25] Z Li, C W Wan, C J Dai et al. Immersion-triggered active switch for spin-decoupled meta-optics multi-display. Small, 18, 2205041(2022).

    [26] Y F Zhang, J B Chou, J Y Li et al. Broadband transparent optical phase change materials for high-performance nonvolatile photonics. Nature Communications, 10, 4279(2019).

    [27] M Y Shalaginov, S An, Y Zhang et al. Reconfigurable all-dielectric metalens with diffraction-limited performance. Nature Communications, 12, 1225(2021).

    [28] B B Hou, L N Zhang. Liquid microdroplet as an optical component to achieve imaging of 100nm nanostructures on a far-field microscope. Journal of optics, 20, 055606(2018).

    [29] W H PRICHARD, W J ORVILLE-THOMAS. Infra-red dispersion studies Part 1.-dichloro-, dibromo-, and diiodomethane. Transactions of the Faraday Society, 59, 2218-2227(1963).

    [30] N F Yu, P Genevet, M A Kats et al. Light propagation with phase discontinuities: generalized laws of reflection and refraction. Science, 334, 333-337(2011).

    [31] Q Cheng, L Zhang, J Y Dai et al. Reconfigurable intelligent surfaces: simplified-architecture transmitters—from theory to implementations. Proceedings of the IEEE, 110, 1266-1289(2022).

    [32] H L Wang, Y K Zhang, T Y Zhang et al. Broadband and programmable amplitude-phase-joint-coding information metasurface. ACS applied materials & interfaces, 14, 29431-29440(2022).

    Tools

    Get Citation

    Copy Citation Text

    Xue-Nan LI, Zeng-Yue ZHAO, Fei-Long YU, Jin CHEN, Guan-Hai LI, Zhi-Feng LI, Xiao-Shuang CHEN. Angular-tunable on-chip coding metasurface enabled by phase-change material with immersion liquid[J]. Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves, 2024, 43(6): 806

    Download Citation

    EndNote(RIS)BibTexPlain Text
    Save article for my favorites
    Paper Information

    Category: Infrared Optoelectronic System and Application Technology

    Received: Feb. 2, 2024

    Accepted: --

    Published Online: Dec. 13, 2024

    The Author Email: ZHAO Zeng-Yue (zhaozengyue@mail.sitp.ac.cn), LI Guan-Hai (ghli0120@mail.sitp.ac.cn), CHEN Xiao-Shuang (xschen@mail.sitp.ac.cn)

    DOI:10.11972/j.issn.1001-9014.2024.06.011

    Topics